← back to scans
Will privately owned housing units authorized by building permits in Vermont in 2026 be above 1,900 units?
32%
Agent
40%
Market Price
-8.0%
Edge
54%
Confidence
24,476
Volume
3.0c
Spread
202
Days to resolution
11
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 2 draws (0.31, 0.33) after one crux research pass. (0) The question is not resolved. The first finalized 2026 annual Census figure has not been published and is expected around May 2027. The latest data are Census/FRED monthly values through August 2026: Jan–Aug totals 1,105 by the monthly sum, or about 1,086 derived from the Census year-to-date file. (a) The calendar year still has four months of permits to come (Sep–Dec). The annual release is due around the May 3, 2027 close, and could slip past it as the 2025 release did (May 14). (b) Status quo: at the 2026 average of about 138 a month, Sep–Dec adds roughly 550–700 units. That gives a monthly-basis total near 1,650–1,800, below 1,900. (c) NO scenario: Sep–Dec looks like 2021–2023 (551–744 units) with no big multifamily permit. The benchmarked annual file, under the new 2025 imputation method, again comes in at or below the monthly sum (2025 annual 2,294 vs monthly sum 2,448). (d) YES scenario: one large multifamily project, like Sep 2025's 666 or Dec 2024's 428, lands in Q4 and pushes Sep–Dec past about 800. Alternatively, the annual benchmark adds about 200 units, as reportedly happened in 2022–2023. Either path clears the threshold. The base rate does favour YES, since the annual figure has been above 1,900 every year since 2021, and two of the last five Sep–Dec periods were large enough. However, 2026 is running 16% below 2025. The research also found that Act 152 removed the year-end Act 250 deadline that might have caused a Q4 rush. And the most recent benchmark, under the new imputation method, ran negative. The Kalshi price is about 38–40% and has been trending down. I shade slightly below it to about 31%, for the weaker rush catalyst and the negative 2025 benchmark.
price vs. prediction
market price
agent forecast at t+0
6 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen:
kalshi_direct
kalshi_related
fred
resolution_source
Planner reasoning
This resolves on the Census Building Permits Survey annual figure for Vermont, and FRED carries the Vermont permits series (VTBPPRIV monthly), which gives the year-to-date pace through roughly August 2026 and the prior annual totals. The Kalshi price is the anchor, and sibling strike markets in the same series show the full distribution. Resolution_source points at the Census BPS state annual data.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5.5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports)
Tools
- kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Above 1,900 units** (KXVTPERMITS-27MAY03-T1900) - Current price (probability): 40.00% (live; bid 36% / ask 39%) - Last daily close (2026-10-11): 39.00% - 7-day price change: -11.00% - 30-day price change: -18.00% - Average daily volume: 993 contracts - Price range: 38.00% - 65.00% - Data points: 15 days
- resolution_source: already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=2026 August YTD data (released ~late Sept 2026); BPS page notes 2025 annuals released 5/14/26. The final 2026 annual figure has not been published yet. Census released the final 2025 annual estimates on 5/14/26, so the 2026 annual figure should come out around May 2027. The latest preliminary reading is Census's Jan–Aug 2026 year-to-dat
- kalshi_related: 1 related markets / summaries. series KXVTPERMITS: 0 markets (skipped 11 no-signal) | keyword 'Vermont building permits': ok
- fred: Fetched 4 FRED series (lookback=1200d) (via search 'Vermont new private housing units authorized by building permits').
Research loops, bottom lines
- current state: Through Aug 2026 Vermont has about 1,105 permitted units, below 2025's pace. Exceeding 1,900 needs roughly 800 units in Sep–Dec, which requires large multifamily spikes like those in Sep 2025 (666) or Dec 2024 (428). The annual figure may also differ from the monthly sum, because the 2025 annual was reported as 2,294 against a monthly sum of 2,448.
- base rate: Vermont annual permits have been above 1,900 every year since 2021 (about 2,100–2,650 by monthly sums), so the outside view favours Yes. 2026 year-to-date is running about 16% below 2025, and I project roughly 1,750–1,950 on the monthly basis. That puts the result near the threshold, with the Sep–Dec total and the annual-release adjustments deciding it.
- yes case: The YES case is an outside view plus annual-file uplift. Vermont's Census annual totals have been 2,294–2,654 from 2022 to 2025, and in three of four years the annual figure beat the monthly sum. YES needs the annual file to add about 200 over the monthly sum, plus ordinary Sep–Dec activity of about 600 (three of the last five years did that), or one large multifamily permit.
- no case: For a Yes, Sep–Dec 2026 must add about 800 units, roughly 5.8 times the 2026 monthly average, which in practice needs a one-off large multifamily batch like Sep 2025's 666. Even then, the benchmarked annual figure could land below the monthly sum, and a late Census release could leave no finalized 2026 figure by the May 3, 2027 close.
Crux follow-up
- The evidence favours NO. Jan–Aug is 1,105, a normal Sep–Dec adds about 550–700, and the removal of a year-end Act 250 deadline weakens the main YES catalyst. YES needs a large one-off multifamily batch (like Sep 2025's 666), a benchmark uplift of about +200, or both. The sign of the benchmark under the new imputation method is the main uncertainty. The release may also land on or after the 3 May 2027 close.
tools
| tool | status | time | items | summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| kalshi_direct | OK | 0.2s | 1 | ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Above 1,900 units** (KXVTPERMITS-27MAY03-T1900) - Current price (probability): 40.00% (live; bid 36% / ask 39%) - Last daily close (2026-10-11): 39.00% - 7-day price change: -11.00% - 30-day price change: -18.00% - Average daily volume: 993 contracts - Price range: 38 |
| kalshi_related | OK | 0.8s | 1 | 1 related markets / summaries. series KXVTPERMITS: 0 markets (skipped 11 no-signal) | keyword 'Vermont building permits': ok |
| fred | OK | 1.7s | 4 | Fetched 4 FRED series (lookback=1200d) (via search 'Vermont new private housing units authorized by building permits'). |
| resolution_source | OK | 17.3s | 1 | already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=2026 August YTD data (released ~late Sept 2026); BPS page notes 2025 annuals released 5/14/26. The final 2026 annual figure has not been published yet. Census released the final 2025 annual estimates on 5/14/26, so the 2026 annual figure |
research loops
·
4/4 ok ·
12 searches ·
2 page reads
| dimension | status | time | searches | page reads | report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current state | OK | 15s | 2 | 0 | 3185 chars |
| base rate | OK | 22s | 3 | 0 | 4158 chars |
| yes case | OK | 27s | 4 | 0 | 5192 chars |
| no case | OK | 21s | 3 | 2 | 4746 chars |
report: current state
- [2026-09-24] The latest FRED/Census monthly series for Vermont (VTBPPRIV, NSA, all structure types) runs through Aug 2026. The 2026 monthly values are: Jan 197, Feb 77, Mar 109, Apr 134, May 125, Jun 179, Jul 138, Aug 146. Jan–Aug sums to 1,105 units (my arithmetic). https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV
- [2026-10-12] To finish above 1,900, Sep–Dec 2026 would need at least 796 units, about 199 a month. Only 2 of the 8 months so far reached about 179 or more (Jan 197, Jun 179). The Jan–Aug average is about 138 a month. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV
- [2026-09-24] Comparison with 2025, from the same series: Sep 2025 was an outlier at 666. Oct, Nov and Dec 2025 were 229, 123 and 108. The monthly values sum to 2,448 for 2025 and about 2,625 for 2024 (my arithmetic). Jan–Aug 2025 summed to 1,322, against 1,105 for Jan–Aug 2026, which is about 16% lower. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV
- [2026-09-24] The 2025 Sep–Dec total was 1,126. A repeat of that would put 2026 at about 2,230. Lumpy large multifamily permits drive these spikes: Dec 2024 was 428 and Sep 2025 was 666. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV
- [2026, undated; the page shows an Aug 6, 2026 post] VHFA says the 2025 official Census annual data show 2,294 buildings permitted statewide. It calls this a slight dip from the prior year, which had risen steadily since 2019. The 2,294 may differ from the 2,448 monthly sum, so the annual and monthly bases may differ. https://vhfa.org/news/blog/housing-data
- [2026-05-19] Vermont DHCD says Census permit data is released once a year for the prior year. It also says the state's dashboard counts typically sit within 300–400 units of Census permit counts. https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Environment/Reports%20and%20Resources/W~Department%20of%20Housing%20and%20Community%20Development~2026%20Housing%20Targets%20Report~5-21-2026.pdf
- [2026-09-17] US national permits in Aug 2026 were at a 1,394,000 seasonally adjusted annual rate, 2.7% below July and 3.5% above Aug 2025. The national trend is stable to slightly up, with no sign of a collapse. https://pipexch.com/housing-starts-and-permitting-09-17-26/
- [2026-09-24] FRED lists the next national New Residential Construction release (Sep data) for Oct 20, 2026. State-level Sep data usually follows in the monthly state permit release, a few days to a few weeks after that. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PERMIT?cid=97
- Resolution source: the first finalized annual 2026 Census figure normally appears in spring 2027, which is before the 2027-05-03 close. I did not confirm the exact date.
BOTTOM LINE: Through Aug 2026 Vermont has about 1,105 permitted units, below 2025's pace. Exceeding 1,900 needs roughly 800 units in Sep–Dec, which requires large multifamily spikes like those in Sep 2025 (666) or Dec 2024 (428). The annual figure may also differ from the monthly sum, because the 2025 annual was reported as 2,294 against a monthly sum of 2,448.
NOT FOUND: the official Census annual 2026 release date, state-level Sep 2026 data (not yet published), and any Vermont-specific pipeline reports of large pending permit projects.
report: base rate
- [2026-09-24] FRED monthly series (Census, not seasonally adjusted, updated 2026-09-24), Jan–Aug 2026: 197, 77, 109, 134, 125, 179, 138, 146. My sum is 1,105 units through August. A Yes needs about 796 or more in Sep–Dec. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2026-09-24] The same series for Jan–Aug 2025 sums to about 1,322. 2026 year-to-date is therefore about 16% below 2025. The 2025 total was lifted by a one-month spike of 666 in Sep 2025. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2026-09-24] My sums of the FRED monthly values give these full-year totals: 2021 ≈ 2,092, 2022 ≈ 2,192, 2023 ≈ 2,246, 2024 ≈ 2,625, 2025 ≈ 2,448. Official annual figures differ somewhat from the monthly sums. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2026-09-24] Sep–Dec totals from the same series: 2021 = 744, 2022 = 551, 2023 = 712, 2024 = 863, 2025 = 1,126 (including the 666 spike). Only 2024 and 2025 reached about 796 or more. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2025-2026] Vermont has not been below 1,900 on an annual basis recently. Official annual totals: 2,302 in 2022 (https://outside.vermont.gov/agency/ACCD/ACCD_Web_Docs/Housing/Housing-Needs-Assessment/2025-2029/VT-HNA-2025.pdf), 2,456 in 2023 (https://outside.vermont.gov/agency/ACCD/ACCD_Web_Docs/Housing/Housing-Needs-Assessment/2025-2029/Housing-Targets-Appendix.pdf), and a report of about 2,654 in 2024 (https://vermontdailychronicle.com/nations-fastest-shrinking-state-vermont-loses-0-3-of-population-amid-aging-crisis-and-housing-stagnation/). Fewer than 1,500 homes were permitted per year in 2008–2012, and 2010–2020 averaged about 1,178 homes added per year.
- [2026-07-22] VHFA on the 2025 Census annual release: 2,294 buildings permitted statewide, a slight dip from 2024. This is a building count, not a unit count. The post's subtitle ("The Cost of Not Reporting Data") points to non-reporting jurisdictions. https://vhfa.org/news/blog/housing-data
- [2026-05-21] The state housing agency's dashboard (E911 address data) counts about 1,600 new units in 2025, against about 3,000 in 2024. It says its counts typically land within 300–400 units of Census permit counts. It is not an official permit measure. https://www.compassvermont.com/p/vermont-built-a-way-to-count-the
- [2026-05-19] The Department of Housing and Community Development says Census building-permit data is released once a year and lags. https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Environment/Reports%20and%20Resources/W~Department%20of%20Housing%20and%20Community%20Development~2026%20Housing%20Targets%20Report~5-21-2026.pdf
- [2026-09-30] Seven Days reports that permits dipped in 2025 after a few years of modest growth. https://www.sevendaysvt.com/home-design/realestate/vermonts-housing-market-has-tilted-back-toward-buyers-but-only-a-certain-kind/
- [2026-08] National context: US permits for July 2026 were 1.443M seasonally adjusted annual rate, up 5.9% year on year. The Northeast was up 20.8% year on year. https://www.mortgagenewsdaily.com/data/building-permits
- Timing: the first annual 2026 Census figure should come in mid-2027 (the 2025 annual release was reported in July 2026). That is after the market's 2027-05-03 close. The final Census state-level annual numbers are the first finalized annual figures per the rules. Monthly sums may stand in for them, but the annual release adds imputation and non-reporter adjustments. Check whether the market can settle on a Census annual-data release before 2027-05-03. https://vhfa.org/news/blog/housing-data
BOTTOM LINE: Vermont annual permits have been above 1,900 every year since 2021 (about 2,100–2,650 by monthly sums), so the outside view favours Yes. 2026 year-to-date is running about 16% below 2025, and I project roughly 1,750–1,950 on the monthly basis. That puts the result near the threshold, with the Sep–Dec total and the annual-release adjustments deciding it.
NOT FOUND: Official 2026 annual or year-to-date state totals from the Census Bureau itself. Exact official annual unit totals for 2025 and 2021. Any published forecast or other-venue market for Vermont 2026 permits.
report: yes case
YES means: the first finalized Census annual 2026 figure for Vermont's privately owned housing units authorized by building permits, all structure types, is strictly above 1,900.
- [2026-10-12] Most likely path to YES: the annual Census file adds imputed units for non-reporting towns, and a large Sep–Dec multifamily permit lifts the monthly total. FRED's Jan–Aug sum is 1,105 (colleagues' arithmetic). Each Census annual figure below is DHCD's table; each monthly sum is FRED's. The annual figure was higher than the FRED monthly sum by about 211 in 2022 (2,403 vs 2,192) and about 210 in 2023 (2,456 vs 2,246). It was higher by about 29 in 2024 (2,654 vs 2,625). In 2025 it was lower by about 154 (2,294 vs 2,448). If 2026 gets a gap near +200, the monthly sum needs only about 1,700. That means about 600 units in Sep–Dec, against the 796 the monthly-basis threshold implies. https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Environment/Reports%20and%20Resources/W~Department%20of%20Housing%20and%20Community%20Development~2026%20Housing%20Targets%20Report~5-21-2026.pdf
- [2026-10-12] On my reading of the FRED series, Sep–Dec totals were 744 (2021), 551 (2022), 712 (2023), 863 (2024) and 1,126 (2025). That is the five-year record from my own sum of the monthly values. Three of the five years reached 600 or more, and two reached 796 or more. Sep–Dec also contains the biggest single-month spikes: Dec 2024 was 428 and Sep 2025 was 666. A single 5+ unit project can move the total by several hundred units. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2026-10-12] The Census release schedule states that annual data come out on the first workday of May for the prior year. For 2026 data that is Monday 3 May 2027, the same day trading closes. Next monthly releases: Sep data on 20 Oct, Oct data on 18 Nov, Nov data on 17 Dec, Dec data on 20 Jan 2027. The schedule still shows the first-workday rule, but the 2025 data actually came out on 14 May 2026, so a slip past the close is possible. https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/schedule.html
- [2026-05-14] Census reports that final 2025 annual estimates came out on 14 May 2026, benchmarked to the final totals. The annual file covers all permit-issuing places and imputes for non-reporters, so it is not just the sum of the monthly values. https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/index.html
- [2026-07-22] VHFA says about 50 Vermont municipalities did not submit permit reports last year, and their estimates rely wholly on imputation. If imputation baselines stay high for those towns, the annual file can come in above the reported monthly sum, as in 2022–2023. https://www.healthcareindustrytoday.com/article/928818527-2025-census-building-permit-data-released-the-cost-of-not-reporting-data
- [2026-10-12] Four of the first eight 2026 months were low, but Jan was 197 and Jun was 179. The 2026 monthly figures from Apr to Aug are 125–179. Jul and Aug (138, 146) look steady, not collapsing. Seasonally, Oct usually runs above Aug in the series: Oct 2025 was 229, Oct 2023 was 329 and Oct 2021 was 198. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2026-06-18] Policy support for multifamily. Act 181's Tier 1A/1B interim Act 250 housing exemptions took effect 1 Jan 2026. S.325/Act 152 extended the interim exemptions through early 2028. S.328, signed 18 Jun 2026, adds zoning support for duplexes and small multi-unit housing. Developers face no near-term cliff, and some may start projects before the Tier 2 rules begin on 31 Dec 2026. https://www.srhlaw.com/vermont-2026-legislative-wrap-up/ and https://act250.vermont.gov/src/interim-act-250-housing-exemptions
- [2026-05-21] Burlington metro permits for May 2026 were 45 units, and the trailing 12 months were 1,212. That is roughly half of Vermont's monthly permit total, so the trailing base in Chittenden County remains large. Pumsdata, which cites the Census Building Permits Survey, puts the latest month at -4.3% year on year, so the metro is flat, not collapsing. https://pumsdata.com/data/permits/metro/burlington-south-burlington-vt
- [2026-05-21] DHCD's Nov 2025 testimony, citing Census data, shows Vermont annual permits at 2,000–3,100 over 2020–2024. It had a growth goal of about 3% a year and said average growth over the last 10 years was about 3%. The dashboard (E911) 2025 count of 1,598 versus Census 2,294 shows the Census series runs well above other measures. https://ljfo.vermont.gov/assets/Meetings/Joint-Fiscal-Committee/2025-11-13/DHCD_JFC-Testimony_11-13-2025.pdf
BOTTOM LINE: The YES case is an outside view plus annual-file uplift. Vermont's Census annual totals have been 2,294–2,654 from 2022 to 2025, and in three of four years the annual figure beat the monthly sum. YES needs the annual file to add about 200 over the monthly sum, plus ordinary Sep–Dec activity of about 600 (three of the last five years did that), or one large multifamily permit.
NOT FOUND: Vermont-specific pending large multifamily projects scheduled for Q4 2026 permits. The Sep 2026 state figure (due after 20 Oct). A confirmed 2027 annual release date. Official Census 2026 year-to-date state totals, other than the FRED monthly series.
report: no case
YES means: Census's first finalized annual 2026 figure for Vermont privately owned housing units authorized by building permits (all structure types) is strictly above 1,900.
- [2026-09-24] The FRED/Census series (VTBPPRIV) runs through Aug 2026 and shows a Jan–Aug 2026 total of 1,105 units. Only 2 of 8 months reached 179 or more. Since 1988, a Sep–Dec total of 796 or more has been rare. Beyond the 2024 and 2025 spikes, the 2021–2023 Sep–Dec totals ran 551–744, so the status-quo run rate points to about 1,650–1,850. I read the 1988–2026 monthly values in full. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2026-09-24] Month by month, Sep–Dec 2025 was 666, 229, 123 and 108. The 666 in Sep 2025 sits far above any other month since 2010 except Dec 2024 (428). A one-off that size would have to repeat. Without one, Sep–Dec at the 2026 average of about 138 a month gives about 550, and a 2026 total near 1,650. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- [2026-09-24] Single-unit permits are weak. The April snapshot of the 1-unit series shows Jan–Apr 2026 at 92, 70, 77 and 112, against Dec 2025 at 57. Single-family is the steady base of the total, so no recovery there offsets the multifamily lumpiness. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/VTBP1FH
- [2026-05-14] Census published the final 2025 annual estimates on May 14, 2026, not the "first working day in May" its methodology page promises. The 2027 market closes May 3, 2027, which is the first working day of May 2027. A slip like 2026's means no finalized 2026 figure exists by the close. The rules state no other deadline. https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/index.html
- [2026-10-12] Census's methodology says final annual estimates come on "the 1st working day in May". They are benchmarked to the completed annual survey, and no annual data are revised afterward. The first finalized figure is therefore the benchmarked, imputed one, not the monthly sum. https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/about.html
- [2026-07-22] VHFA says roughly 50 Vermont municipalities did not report their permits last year, so their figures are imputed. Imputation can move the annual total away from the monthly sum, and the 2025 annual was reported as 2,294, below the 2,448 monthly sum, so the benchmark may cut totals. A similar cut applied to a 2026 monthly sum near 1,800 would leave it below 1,900. This is my inference from two numbers on different bases (buildings versus units), not a confirmed pattern. https://www.healthcareindustrytoday.com/article/928818527-2025-census-building-permit-data-released-the-cost-of-not-reporting-data
- [2025-05-01] Census changed its imputation method with the January 2025 release, from regional factors to a mix of division and large individual states. That adds some uncertainty to how Vermont's imputed towns are scaled, in either direction. https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/announcements.html
- [2026-01-01] Act 181's Tier 1A/1B exemptions took effect Jan 1, 2026, and Tiers 2 and 3 take effect Dec 31, 2026. The 2026 Jan–Aug numbers show no visible permit boost from them so far. Some interim Act 250 exemptions end Jan 1, 2027. A deadline-driven rush might fall in Q4 but is not yet visible in the data. https://act250.vermont.gov/src/interim-act-250-housing-exemptions
- [2026-01-07] Let's Build Homes told legislators that 2025 production was "decent but below goals". It also said many towns are opting out of Tier 1A/1B and that more than half of Vermont communities get no housing relief from the tier mapping. That limits upside from the reform. https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20General/Housing/Organizational%20Updates%20and%20Overviews/W~Miro%20Weinberger~Let's%20Build%20Homes%20Testimony~1-7-2026.pdf
- [2026-03-01] One commentary source puts Vermont at "roughly 1,800 permits per year", which is below the threshold. It is a low-quality source, but it shows how close 1,900 sits to the typical figure. https://askdoss.com/vermont-act-250-land-use-law-explained-what-homeowners-need-to-know-in-2026/
BOTTOM LINE: For a Yes, Sep–Dec 2026 must add about 800 units, roughly 5.8 times the 2026 monthly average, which in practice needs a one-off large multifamily batch like Sep 2025's 666. Even then, the benchmarked annual figure could land below the monthly sum, and a late Census release could leave no finalized 2026 figure by the May 3, 2027 close.
NOT FOUND: Vermont Sep 2026 state-level permit data, which was not yet published. Named large Vermont multifamily projects expected to be permitted in Q4 2026. The official Census 2025 annual unit total for Vermont. The Census release date for the 2026 annual data. Any explicit Kalshi rule on what happens if Census releases late.
3. Forecasters 2 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT · plain mean · re-drawn after crux research
crux research
The first round disagreed: the forecasts rest on claims no source in the evidence confirms: (1) The 2026 annual Census figure will exceed the monthly sum by about 200 units as in 2022–2023, rather than falling below it as in 2025.; (2) No large Vermont multifamily project (200+ units) is scheduled to receive permits in Q4 2026.; (3) Kalshi will settle on the Census annual release even if it slips past May 3, 2027..
One more research loop went after the crux and every draw below was redone with its report.
first-round draws:
33%, 31%
· crux loop: 3 searches, 0 page reads
report: crux
CRUX: The claim that moves the forecast most is (1), the size and sign of the annual-versus-monthly benchmark adjustment. It is a swing of about ±200 against a gap of roughly 150–250 units. Claim (1) also drives the "needed Sep–Dec" arithmetic in both forecasts.
- **Monthly data, Jan–Aug 2026 (FRED, updated 2026-09-24):** Vermont monthly permits were 197, 77, 109, 134, 125, 179, 138 and 146. That sums to 1,105 for January–August, matching the forecasters. Source: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/data/VTBPPRIV.txt
- **Prior Sep–Dec totals (same FRED series):**
- 2022: 551.
- 2023: 712.
- 2024: 863, including a 428 spike in December.
- 2025: 1,126, including a 666 spike in September.
- Reaching 1,900 on the monthly basis needs Sep–Dec 2026 of about 795 or more. Only 2024 and 2025 got there, and both depended on one large project.
- **Claim 1, annual benchmark: cannot be established for 2026.**
- Census says monthly estimates are benchmarked after the annual survey, and final annual estimates follow (https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/about.html).
- Census also changed its imputation method with the January 2025 data. Imputation factors moved from region level to a mix of division and large individual states (https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/announcements.html).
- That change could explain why 2025's adjustment was negative, as the forecasters report (annual 2,294 against a monthly sum of 2,448). I did not independently re-verify those 2025 figures or the 2022–2024 adjustments. The +200 for 2022–2023 is also unverified. Under the new method the sign is unknown.
- **Claim 2, no large project scheduled for Q4: cannot be established.** I found no source listing Vermont projects of 200 or more units scheduled for permitting in Q4 2026.
- **Pull-forward rush before year-end:** this driver looks weaker than the forecasters assumed.
- Act 152 of 2026 (S.325) pushed the interim Act 250 housing exemptions from 1 Jan 2027 to 1 Jan 2028 (https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Docs/ACTS/ACT152/ACT152%20As%20Enacted.pdf).
- The Act 250 interim-exemption page lists availability through 1 July 2028 (https://act250.vermont.gov/modernizing-land-use-review/interim-act-250-housing-exemptions).
- So there is no 31 Dec 2026 deadline forcing a Q4 rush. The enacted text is dated 2026. An earlier draft analysis described a 1 Jan 2028 deadline (https://www.compassvermont.com/p/analysis-vermont-gave-itself-until).
- **Claim 3, settlement timing:**
- Census's stated schedule releases final annual estimates on the first working day of May (https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/about.html). The first working day of May 2027 is Monday, 3 May, the same day trading closes.
- The 2025 annual data came out on 14 May 2026, later than the stated schedule (https://www.census.gov/construction/soc/schedule.html).
- The 2024 annual came out on 1 May 2025 (https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/announcements.html).
- If the 2026 release slips, it falls after the close. How Kalshi would settle in that case is not stated in the rules provided.
- **Tracker comparison:** Vermont's housing agency says its dashboard counts generally land within 300–400 units of Census permit counts (https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Environment/Reports%20and%20Resources/W~Department%20of%20Housing%20and%20Community%20Development~2026%20Housing%20Targets%20Report~5-21-2026.pdf). It gives no 2026 forecast.
- **National context:** the August 2026 US permit rate was 1.394 million seasonally adjusted annual rate, up 3.5% from August 2025 (https://pipexch.com/housing-starts-and-permitting-09-17-26/). That is mildly positive, but Vermont is running about 16% below 2025 year to date.
BOTTOM LINE: The evidence favours NO. Jan–Aug is 1,105, a normal Sep–Dec adds about 550–700, and the removal of a year-end Act 250 deadline weakens the main YES catalyst. YES needs a large one-off multifamily batch (like Sep 2025's 666), a benchmark uplift of about +200, or both. The sign of the benchmark under the new imputation method is the main uncertainty. The release may also land on or after the 3 May 2027 close.
NOT FOUND:
- The 2026 annual benchmark direction.
- Any named Vermont 200-plus-unit permit scheduled for Q4 2026.
- Kalshi's rule for settlement if Census publishes after the close.
- The Census state-file vintage and 2025 annual figures, which I did not re-verify.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
55% conf
| Yes | 31% |
| No | 69% |
(0) The question is not resolved. The first finalized 2026 annual Census figure has not been published and is expected around May 2027. The latest data are Census/FRED monthly values through August 2026: Jan–Aug totals 1,105 by the monthly sum, or about 1,086 derived from the Census year-to-date file. (a) The calendar year still has four months of permits to come (Sep–Dec). The annual release is due around the May 3, 2027 close, and could slip past it as the 2025 release did (May 14). (b) Status quo: at the 2026 average of about 138 a month, Sep–Dec adds roughly 550–700 units. That gives a monthly-basis total near 1,650–1,800, below 1,900. (c) NO scenario: Sep–Dec looks like 2021–2023 (551–744 units) with no big multifamily permit. The benchmarked annual file, under the new 2025 imputation method, again comes in at or below the monthly sum (2025 annual 2,294 vs monthly sum 2,448). (d) YES scenario: one large multifamily project, like Sep 2025's 666 or Dec 2024's 428, lands in Q4 and pushes Sep–Dec past about 800. Alternatively, the annual benchmark adds about 200 units, as reportedly happened in 2022–2023. Either path clears the threshold. The base rate does favour YES, since the annual figure has been above 1,900 every year since 2021, and two of the last five Sep–Dec periods were large enough. However, 2026 is running 16% below 2025. The research also found that Act 152 removed the year-end Act 250 deadline that might have caused a Q4 rush. And the most recent benchmark, under the new imputation method, ran negative. The Kalshi price is about 38–40% and has been trending down. I shade slightly below it to about 31%, for the weaker rush catalyst and the negative 2025 benchmark.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
52% conf
| Yes | 33% |
| No | 67% |
(0) Not resolved: the final 2026 Census annual figure is due around May 2027. Jan–Aug 2026 is 1,105 units per FRED VTBPPRIV and about 1,086 per the Census YTD file, so YES needs about 800 units in Sep–Dec on the monthly basis. (a) Four months of permitting remain, then the annual benchmark release on or after 3 May 2027. (b) The status quo run rate (about 138 a month, or historical Sep–Dec of 551–744) gives about 1,650–1,850, below the threshold. (c) NO: no large multifamily batch arrives and the annual benchmark is flat or negative, as in 2025 (2,294 annual against a 2,448 monthly sum) after the 2025 imputation change. (d) YES: a lumpy 400–650-unit multifamily permit, as in Dec 2024 or Sep 2025, and/or a +200 imputation uplift like 2022–2023. Two of the last five Sep–Dec periods cleared the bar. The Act 250 year-end rush catalyst is weakened by the extension to 2028, and no large Q4 project was identified. I anchor on the market's ~38–40% and shade down to 33% on the YTD shortfall and the recent negative benchmark sign.
4. Final plain mean of 2 draws · second round
32%
(54% confidence)
Yes: 32%
No: 68%
Mean of 2 draws (0.31, 0.33) after one crux research pass. (0) The question is not resolved. The first finalized 2026 annual Census figure has not been published and is expected around May 2027. The latest data are Census/FRED monthly values through August 2026: Jan–Aug totals 1,105 by the monthly sum, or about 1,086 derived from the Census year-to-date file. (a) The calendar year still has four months of permits to come (Sep–Dec). The annual release is due around the May 3, 2027 close, and could slip past it as the 2025 release did (May 14). (b) Status quo: at the 2026 average of about 138 a month, Sep–Dec adds roughly 550–700 units. That gives a monthly-basis total near 1,650–1,800, below 1,900. (c) NO scenario: Sep–Dec looks like 2021–2023 (551–744 units) with no big multifamily permit. The benchmarked annual file, under the new 2025 imputation method, again comes in at or below the monthly sum (2025 annual 2,294 vs monthly sum 2,448). (d) YES scenario: one large multifamily project, like Sep 2025's 666 or Dec 2024's 428, lands in Q4 and pushes Sep–Dec past about 800. Alternatively, the annual benchmark adds about 200 units, as reportedly happened in 2022–2023. Either path clears the threshold. The base rate does favour YES, since the annual figure has been above 1,900 every year since 2021, and two of the last five Sep–Dec periods were large enough. However, 2026 is running 16% below 2025. The research also found that Act 152 removed the year-end Act 250 deadline that might have caused a Q4 rush. And the most recent benchmark, under the new imputation method, ran negative. The Kalshi price is about 38–40% and has been trending down. I shade slightly below it to about 31%, for the weaker rush catalyst and the negative 2025 benchmark.
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 106.7s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.