← back to scans
Will Missouri’s annual-average manufacturing employment for 2026 be above 280,500 jobs?
14%
Agent
28%
Market Price
-13.8%
Edge
64%
Confidence
23,584
Volume
1.0c
Spread
200
Days to resolution
1
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 4 draws (0.15, 0.15, 0.13, 0.14). (0) Not resolved. BLS has not published a 2026 annual average and will likely do so only after the benchmark revision around March 2027. The NSA series SMU29000003000000001 shows January–August 2026 averaging about 278.4k, below the fixed 280.5k threshold. (a) About 6.5 months remain before the April 30, 2027 close; four monthly prints (Sep–Dec) plus the annual benchmark revision are still to come. (b) Status quo: if September–December runs near the recent 278–280k range, as September–December 2025 did at about 278k, the preliminary annual average lands around 278.5–279k. That is No. (c) No: September–December stays flat or slips. Missouri WARN notices from Nature's Bakery and Cornerstone fall in the fourth quarter, monthly reports show manufacturing as a laggard (-1,000 in August, -500 year over year), and the benchmark revision is small or negative. (d) Yes: the realistic path is not a fourth-quarter surge, since September–December would need to average about 284.7k. It is the March 2027 benchmark revising 2026 levels up by roughly 2k or more across the year. State manufacturing benchmark revisions of 1–2% do happen, and Missouri's PMI at 57.5 and national ISM expansion offer mild support. The direction of that revision is unknown, and recent revisions have tended to be downward. The Kalshi anchor at 28% (down 12 points in a week) seems to price substantial revision risk. I shade below it because the arithmetic gap is large and the trend is negative, while keeping meaningful weight on the revision uncertainty.
price vs. prediction
market price
agent forecast at t+0
7 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen:
kalshi_direct
resolution_source
fred
kalshi_related
Planner reasoning
The key input is the monthly 2026 Missouri manufacturing employment data published so far (Jan to ~Aug), set against the 280.5k threshold. FRED carries the state series: MOMFG is the SA version, and SMU29000003000000001 is the NSA series the annual average is computed from. The resolution source is the BLS data page, and related Kalshi markets at other strikes help with calibration. I'm also flagging that the March 2027 benchmark revision can shift the annual average.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports)
Tools
- kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Above 280,500 jobs** (KXMOMFGEMP-27APR30-T280500) - Current price (probability): 28.00% (live; bid 27% / ask 28%) - 7-day price change: -12.00% - 30-day price change: +0.00% - Average daily volume: 1310 contracts - Price range: 10.00% - 44.00% - Data points: 18 days
- resolution_source: already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=Data extracted October 11, 2026; latest data point is August 2026 (preliminary). The BLS series SMU29000003000000001 (Missouri manufacturing, not seasonally adjusted, in thousands) shows these 2026 monthly values: Jan 275.9, Feb 279.7, Mar 278.1, Apr 277.0, May 276.6, Jun 280.5, Jul 280.2, Aug 279.4(P). From January to August the averag
- fred: Fetched 6 FRED series (lookback=730d) (via search 'Missouri manufacturing employment').
- kalshi_related: 0 related markets / summaries. series KXMOMFGEMP: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal)
Research loops, bottom lines
- current state: Based on the official BLS series cited in the contract, Missouri manufacturing employment has run below the 2025 pace all year (8-month 2026 average ≈278.4k vs. the 280.5k threshold), and would need an implausible jump in the Sep–Dec 2026 monthly readings to push the annual average above 280,500; current trend data point toward No.
- base rate: The reference class — Missouri's own manufacturing employment history — shows a declining trend (286.7→284.4→280.5 thousand for 2023-2025) that has continued into 2026, with seasonally-adjusted monthly readings mostly in the 277-280 range through mid-2026; because the fixed 280.5 threshold exactly equals the 2025 actual average and the trend/momentum is still negative, the outside view leans toward the 2026 annual average coming in at or below 280.5 rather than clearly above it.
- yes case: The YES case rests on a confluence of improving leading indicators — Missouri's own PMI surging to 57.5 in August, a ninth straight month of national ISM manufacturing expansion with accelerating new orders, a September 2026 BLS report showing national manufacturing payroll gains, and several Missouri plant openings/expansions in Q3 2026 — plus the standing possibility of upward benchmark revisions, all of which could lift Sep–Dec 2026 monthly readings well above the 277–280k range seen earlier
- no case: Confirmed WARN notices (Cornerstone Building Brands, Nature's Bakery) show additional Missouri manufacturing job cuts landing precisely in the Sep–Dec 2026 window, on top of an already-negative year-over-year trend and soft PMI readings, making the required ~284.7k four-month average to clear 280.5k look not just unlikely but actively contradicted by scheduled layoffs.
tools
| tool | status | time | items | summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| kalshi_direct | OK | 0.2s | 1 | ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Above 280,500 jobs** (KXMOMFGEMP-27APR30-T280500) - Current price (probability): 28.00% (live; bid 27% / ask 28%) - 7-day price change: -12.00% - 30-day price change: +0.00% - Average daily volume: 1310 contracts - Price range: 10.00% - 44.00% - Data points: 18 days |
| resolution_source | OK | 10.0s | 1 | already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=Data extracted October 11, 2026; latest data point is August 2026 (preliminary). The BLS series SMU29000003000000001 (Missouri manufacturing, not seasonally adjusted, in thousands) shows these 2026 monthly values: Jan 275.9, Feb 279.7, Ma |
| fred | OK | 3.6s | 6 | Fetched 6 FRED series (lookback=730d) (via search 'Missouri manufacturing employment'). |
| kalshi_related | OK | 0.2s | 0 | 0 related markets / summaries. series KXMOMFGEMP: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal) |
research loops
·
4/4 ok ·
14 searches ·
7 page reads
| dimension | status | time | searches | page reads | report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current state | OK | 44s | 3 | 2 | 3488 chars |
| base rate | OK | 42s | 4 | 2 | 4017 chars |
| yes case | OK | 39s | 4 | 2 | 4924 chars |
| no case | OK | 25s | 3 | 1 | 4032 chars |
report: current state
- [2026-10-11] BLS's official monthly series SMU29000003000000001 (Missouri, not-seasonally-adjusted, all-employee manufacturing) shows 2026 values: Jan 275.9k, Feb 279.7k, Mar 278.1k, Apr 277.0k, May 276.6k, Jun 280.5k, Jul 280.2k, Aug 279.4k (preliminary). Source: BLS public API, https://api.bls.gov/publicAPI/v2/timeseries/data/SMU29000003000000001
- [2026-10-11] The 8-month (Jan–Aug 2026) average of the NSA series is ~278.4k, about 3.3k below the same-period 2025 average (~281.75k), confirming a year-over-year decline in the raw monthly series.
- [2025-12-31] Using the same BLS series, the full 2025 annual average computes to ~280.5k (sum of 12 months ÷12 ≈ 280.51), which is the basis for the 280,500 threshold fixed in the contract rules.
- [2026-09-18] MERIC (Missouri's state labor-market office, in partnership with BLS) reported for August 2026:
"Goods-producing industries increased by 1,200 jobs over the month, with mining, logging, and construction gaining 2,200 jobs and manufacturing declining by 1,000 jobs."
(seasonally adjusted monthly change). Source: https://meric.mo.gov/missouri-monthly-jobs-report
- [2026-09-18] Over the year to August 2026, MERIC/BLS data show
"an increase of 34,100 jobs from August 2025 to August 2026"
in total nonfarm, but
"Employment decreased in manufacturing (-500 jobs) and other services (-400 jobs)"
over that same year, i.e., manufacturing is one of the few shrinking sectors.
- [2026-09-18] The Joint Economic Committee's state update similarly flags manufacturing as a laggard:
"The worst performing sectors were Manufacturing (-1,000) and Information (-700)"
from July to August 2026, and
"The worst performing sectors were Federal Government (-4,200) and Manufacturing (-500)"
from August 2025 to August 2026. Source: https://www.jec.senate.gov/public/vendor/_accounts/JEC-R/employment/state/Missouri%20Employment%20Update.html
- [2026-10-11] FRED's mirror of the same NSA series (MOMFGN) confirms Aug 2026 = 279.4k and lists the next BLS data release date as 2026-10-20 (September 2026 data). Source: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MOMFGN
- [2026-01-28] Annual-revision/benchmarking notes from MERIC indicate that 2025 CES estimates for Missouri were revised during the January 2026 benchmark process, meaning both 2025 (baseline) and 2026 monthly figures remain subject to further revision before the final 2026 annual average is published (typically around Feb-March 2027). Source: https://meric.mo.gov/missouri-monthly-jobs-report
- [2026-10-11] Arithmetic check: with Jan–Aug 2026 NSA sum = 2,227.4 (thousand-months), reaching a 280.5k annual average over 12 months would require the remaining four months (Sep–Dec 2026) to average ~284.7k — higher than any single month Missouri manufacturing has recorded in 2026 so far (peak was 280.5k in June) and well above the Sep–Dec 2025 average of ~278.0k.
BOTTOM LINE: Based on the official BLS series cited in the contract, Missouri manufacturing employment has run below the 2025 pace all year (8-month 2026 average ≈278.4k vs. the 280.5k threshold), and would need an implausible jump in the Sep–Dec 2026 monthly readings to push the annual average above 280,500; current trend data point toward No.
NOT FOUND: No official BLS forecast or September 2026 SMU29000003000000001 value yet (scheduled for release 2026-10-20); no Missouri-specific manufacturing outlook/survey (e.g., ISM-style index) with a 2026 full-year projection was located in this search.
report: base rate
- [2026-04-10] BLS's official annual-average Missouri manufacturing employment (NSA, series SMU29000003000000001A) came in at exactly 280.5 thousand for 2025 — the identical level used as this contract's fixed 2026 threshold — after averaging 284.4 (2024), 286.7 (2023) and 282.5 (2022), showing a declining three-year trend. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/fredgraph.csv?id=SMU29000003000000001A
- [2026-01-?] University of Missouri Extension's Missouri Manufacturing Indicators reported
Missouri manufacturers employed 279,100 workers in December 2025, down 100 jobs from November, and over the past year Missouri manufacturing jobs have decreased by 5,300, representing a 1.9% decline in production jobs since December 2024.
https://extension.missouri.edu/media/wysiwyg/Extensiondata/Pro/ExCEED/Docs/MissouriMfgIndicators_Jan2026.pdf
- [2025-08-?] The same series showed a brief rebound mid-2025, with
Missouri manufacturers employing 283,300 workers in July 2025, up 1,200 jobs from June, and over one year Missouri manufacturing jobs having grown by 5,000, a 1.8% increase since July 2024
, but that gain reversed by year-end. https://extension.missouri.edu/media/wysiwyg/Extensiondata/Pro/ExCEED/Docs/MissouriMfgIndicators_Aug2025.pdf
- [2026-07-22] FRED's seasonally-adjusted MOMFG series (same underlying BLS state employment program) shows 2026 monthly readings well below the 280.5 threshold for most of the year: Jan 277.9, Feb 280.0, Mar 278.5, Apr 277.8, May 277.3, Jun 278.8. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MOMFG
- [2026-08-21] The next FRED update pegged Jul 2026 manufacturing employment at 280.1 thousand (seasonally adjusted), still under the 280.5 annual-average bar needed for the full-year figure to clear it given weak early-year months. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MOMFG (search snippet, FRED MOMFG page)
- [2026-10-?] BLS's Mountain-Plains regional office confirms the Missouri manufacturing series SMS29000003000000001 (seasonally adjusted) and reiterates no methodology change; the state monthly jobs report (MERIC) corroborates continued manufacturing softness through mid-2026, noting manufacturing job losses in several recent months (e.g., -1,000, -500, -2,800, -4,000 in various 2026 months). https://meric.mo.gov/missouri-monthly-jobs-report
- [2024 vintage] Longer-run base rate: Missouri manufacturing employment peaked post-pandemic at 286.7 thousand (2023 annual average) before declining for two consecutive years (2024: 284.4; 2025: 280.5), a cumulative loss of about 6,200 jobs over two years, consistent with a secular manufacturing slowdown rather than a one-off dip. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/fredgraph.csv?id=SMU29000003000000001A
- [2024-10-?] A third-party workforce-projection analysis (ETQ/state labor dept compilations) projected Missouri manufacturing employment growing modestly from a 282,238 base year to 286,536 over a 10-year horizon (+1.5%), implying only slow longer-term growth, not the kind of rapid rebound needed to push 2026 well above 280.5 given the 2025 starting point was already at 280.5. https://www.webstercountycitizen.com/news/state/article_d7eeadca-290f-5022-9c87-517693f7de2a.html
BOTTOM LINE: The reference class — Missouri's own manufacturing employment history — shows a declining trend (286.7→284.4→280.5 thousand for 2023-2025) that has continued into 2026, with seasonally-adjusted monthly readings mostly in the 277-280 range through mid-2026; because the fixed 280.5 threshold exactly equals the 2025 actual average and the trend/momentum is still negative, the outside view leans toward the 2026 annual average coming in at or below 280.5 rather than clearly above it.
NOT FOUND: No official BLS annual-average estimate for 2026 exists yet (not published until early 2027); could not find an explicit forecast/survey specifically predicting the 2026 annual-average Missouri manufacturing employment figure, nor any betting-market or expert consensus number distinct from the raw monthly BLS data already cited.
report: yes case
YES means: BLS's officially published annual-average 2026 Missouri Manufacturing employment (series SMU29000003000000001) comes in strictly above 280,500, which would require the Sep–Dec 2026 monthly NSA readings to average meaningfully higher than anything recorded so far this year.
- [2026-10-02] Nationally, the BLS September 2026 employment report (released despite being delayed) showed manufacturing payrolls rising for the month, with the establishment survey showing manufacturing adding jobs even as the headline nonfarm number badly missed expectations — a signal the sector's recent softness may be turning, and that any similar Missouri uptick in September data (due Oct 20) could push monthly levels higher than the 277–280k range seen all year. https://redstate.com/wardclark/2026/10/02/manufacturing-construction-add-jobs-in-new-september-report-n2207657
- [2026-09-18] Missouri's own Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI, Creighton/MERIC survey) jumped to 57.5 in August 2026, up 3.4 points from July's 54.1, "solidly in expansion territory" — the seventh straight month the broader Mid-America business conditions index stayed above growth-neutral, a leading indicator that often precedes hiring upticks in subsequent months. https://meric.mo.gov/data/pmi
- [2026-10-01] The national ISM Manufacturing PMI registered 54.5% in September 2026, marking the ninth consecutive month of expansion after a prior 10-month contraction, with New Orders accelerating to 55.3% (up 1.6 points) and Employment sub-index rising to 52.7 (up 1.5 points) — forward-looking demand strength that, if it feeds through to Missouri plants, could lift Sep–Dec hiring. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/manufacturing-pmi-at-54-5-september-2026-ism-manufacturing-pmi-report-302894520.html
- [2026-09-23] Schreiber Foods announced a new $267 million process cheese manufacturing facility in Carthage, Missouri, its second major expansion there in two years, though hiring (~100 jobs) is not slated until operations begin in 2028, meaning this adds to the long-run case but not directly to 2026 headcount. https://www.industryselect.com/blog/new-us-factories-unveiled-in-september-2026
- [2026-08-12] Bertagni 1882 selected St. Charles, Missouri for a $36.4 million pasta manufacturing facility creating 150 jobs, and La-Z-Boy announced an August 31 expansion in Neosho investing $23 million for up to 100 new jobs — both signal continued investment inflow that could show up in Q4 2026 payroll counts if hiring ramps quickly. https://ded.mo.gov/press-room/archive
- [2026-09-29] King Technology opened a new $17 million, 208,000-square-foot manufacturing/distribution center in St. Peters, Missouri on September 29 with an active ribbon-cutting, indicating at least one facility is already operational and adding headcount within the Sep–Dec 2026 window relevant to the annual average. https://www.industryselect.com/blog/new-us-factories-unveiled-in-september-2026
- [2026-10-11] MERIC's data show Missouri's monthly manufacturing swings have been volatile and occasionally positive even in the recent downtrend (e.g., May and June 2026 revisions added manufacturing jobs of +1,500 and +900 respectively), illustrating that upward revisions in subsequent benchmarking could still lift the as-published annual average above the current trend-implied path. https://meric.mo.gov/missouri-monthly-jobs-report
- [2026-01-?] Because 2025's annual average was effectively revised during the January 2026 CES benchmark process, the 2026 monthly series itself remains provisional and subject to similar upward benchmark revision when final 2026 figures are published in 2027, leaving open a narrow path for the published annual average to land above 280.5 even if preliminary monthly prints run lower. https://meric.mo.gov/missouri-monthly-jobs-report
BOTTOM LINE: The YES case rests on a confluence of improving leading indicators — Missouri's own PMI surging to 57.5 in August, a ninth straight month of national ISM manufacturing expansion with accelerating new orders, a September 2026 BLS report showing national manufacturing payroll gains, and several Missouri plant openings/expansions in Q3 2026 — plus the standing possibility of upward benchmark revisions, all of which could lift Sep–Dec 2026 monthly readings well above the 277–280k range seen earlier in the year; however, even this bullish evidence describes only directional improvement, not yet a confirmed monthly level high enough to make the 284–285k average needed for the remaining four months plausible.
NOT FOUND: No Missouri-specific manufacturing employment projection or forecast for Sep–Dec 2026 was located; no confirmed September 2026 Missouri SMU29000003000000001 reading (scheduled Oct 20, 2026) exists yet; no evidence of a Missouri-specific CES benchmark revision already pushing 2025 or 2026 levels upward beyond what colleagues' reports already cite.
report: no case
YES means: BLS's officially published annual-average Missouri Manufacturing employment (series SMU29000003000000001A) for calendar year 2026 comes in above 280.5 thousand jobs when published (expected ~Feb-March 2027).
- [2026-08-20] A fresh WARN notice shows Cornerstone Building Brands (prefabricated metal building manufacturing) in Kearney, MO laying off 61 workers effective 2026-10-19 — squarely inside the Sep–Dec 2026 window that must average ~284.7k to clear the threshold, adding direct downward pressure on exactly the months needed to push the annual average above 280.5. https://jobs.mo.gov/warn/2026
- [2026-07-07] Nature's Bakery (Mars-owned, a manufacturing WARN filer) confirmed its Hazelwood plant will shed 130 workers on 2026-09-11, with another 215 following 2027-02-26, meaning the first cut lands in Q4 2026, the very period that would need an unprecedented rebound to hit the strike. https://www.thestreet.com/employment/mars-popular-snack-brand-close-plant-cuts-345-jobs
- [2026-10-02] A Missouri WARN tracker (updated daily) shows 2026 YTD manufacturing-heavy layoffs continuing into October, with Manufacturing accounting for the largest industry share of affected workers (52%) among all WARN filings over the trailing 24 months, underscoring that job losses are concentrated in the sector the contract measures, not a stray month. https://warnact.io/state-missouri
- [2026-09-18] FRED's MOMFGN mirror confirms the most recent official monthly print (Aug 2026 = 279.4k) and that the next data release (Sep 2026, due 2026-10-20) is still pending, so no evidence yet exists of any turnaround large enough to offset the shortfall. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MOMFGN
- [2026-03-?] University of Missouri Extension's March 2026 Indicators brief shows Missouri's manufacturing PMI fell to 50.4 that month — a "notable drop…pointing to softer business sentiment overall" — consistent with employment stagnating rather than accelerating later in the year. https://extension.missouri.edu/media/wysiwyg/Extensiondata/Pro/ExCEED/Docs/missouri-mfg-indicators-mar2026.pdf
- [2026-03-?] The same Extension brief reports Missouri manufacturing jobs were down 0.5% year-over-year as of January 2026, slightly better than the 0.7% national manufacturing decline, but still a net loss, not the growth trajectory needed. https://extension.missouri.edu/media/wysiwyg/Extensiondata/Pro/ExCEED/Docs/missouri-mfg-indicators-mar2026.pdf
- [2026-10-01] A national tariff-and-trade analysis piece (dated days ago) notes that even under an improving national ISM PMI, factory payrolls nationally only "grown by 58,000 jobs" after bottoming in December 2025 — a slow national recovery pace that, if mirrored in Missouri, is far too modest to add the roughly 5,000-6,000 extra jobs needed above the current ~279k trajectory to clear 280.5k on an annual-average basis. https://thedailyeconomy.org/article/manufacturing-surged-when-tariffs-were-lifted/
- [2026-05-?] Multiple 2026 Missouri manufacturing WARN closures already finalized earlier in the year — General Mills (163 jobs, closed June 8) and Timken Belts (283 jobs, closing July 31) — removed capacity ahead of Q4, meaning the sector enters the back half of 2026 with a lower baseline headcount than it had in January, reinforcing the downward trend rather than reversing it. https://jobs.mo.gov/warn/2026
BOTTOM LINE: Confirmed WARN notices (Cornerstone Building Brands, Nature's Bakery) show additional Missouri manufacturing job cuts landing precisely in the Sep–Dec 2026 window, on top of an already-negative year-over-year trend and soft PMI readings, making the required ~284.7k four-month average to clear 280.5k look not just unlikely but actively contradicted by scheduled layoffs.
NOT FOUND: No evidence of any large Missouri manufacturing expansion, reshoring announcement, or hiring surge scheduled for Sep–Dec 2026 large enough to offset the identified layoffs and push the annual average above 280.5k; no September 2026 BLS print yet (due 2026-10-20).
3. Forecasters 4 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT · plain mean
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
62% conf
| Yes | 15% |
| No | 85% |
(0) Not resolved. BLS has not published a 2026 annual average and will likely do so only after the benchmark revision around March 2027. The NSA series SMU29000003000000001 shows January–August 2026 averaging about 278.4k, below the fixed 280.5k threshold. (a) About 6.5 months remain before the April 30, 2027 close; four monthly prints (Sep–Dec) plus the annual benchmark revision are still to come. (b) Status quo: if September–December runs near the recent 278–280k range, as September–December 2025 did at about 278k, the preliminary annual average lands around 278.5–279k. That is No. (c) No: September–December stays flat or slips. Missouri WARN notices from Nature's Bakery and Cornerstone fall in the fourth quarter, monthly reports show manufacturing as a laggard (-1,000 in August, -500 year over year), and the benchmark revision is small or negative. (d) Yes: the realistic path is not a fourth-quarter surge, since September–December would need to average about 284.7k. It is the March 2027 benchmark revising 2026 levels up by roughly 2k or more across the year. State manufacturing benchmark revisions of 1–2% do happen, and Missouri's PMI at 57.5 and national ISM expansion offer mild support. The direction of that revision is unknown, and recent revisions have tended to be downward. The Kalshi anchor at 28% (down 12 points in a week) seems to price substantial revision risk. I shade below it because the arithmetic gap is large and the trend is negative, while keeping meaningful weight on the revision uncertainty.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
62% conf
| Yes | 15% |
| No | 85% |
(0) Not resolved. BLS series SMU29000003000000001 shows 2026 Jan–Aug NSA values averaging about 278.4k; Sep–Dec would need to average about 284.7k to clear 280.5k without revisions, above every 2026 month so far and the ~278k Sep–Dec 2025 average. (a) September data is due Oct 20; the official annual average follows the ~March 2027 benchmark, before the April 30, 2027 close. (b) Status quo: late-2026 months near 278–279k give an annual average around 278.5k, so No. (c) No: continued year-over-year decline (-500 as of August), Q4 WARN layoffs at Nature's Bakery and Cornerstone, and a small or negative benchmark revision in line with recent downward national benchmarks leave 2026 at 277–279k. (d) Yes: the QCEW-based benchmark revises 2026 manufacturing levels up by roughly 2–3k (state-sector revisions of ~1% are plausible), helped by strong leading indicators (Missouri PMI 57.5, rising national ISM employment), lifting the average just above 280.5k. The Kalshi price of 28% already fell 12 points this week; I think it still overweights benchmark uncertainty given the size of the shortfall and the negative revision tendency, but keep a tail for revision risk because the published annual average decides the market.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
68% conf
| Yes | 13% |
| No | 87% |
(0) Not resolved. The BLS series SMU29000003000000001 shows these 2026 NSA values: Jan 275.9, Feb 279.7, Mar 278.1, Apr 277.0, May 276.6, Jun 280.5, Jul 280.2, Aug 279.4 (preliminary). That puts the 8-month average near 278.4k, below the fixed 280.5k threshold. The official 2026 annual average will likely be published after the March 2027 benchmark, before the April 30, 2027 close. (a) About 6.5 months remain until close. Four more monthly prints are due (Sep data arrives Oct 20), followed by the benchmark revision. (b) Status quo is No. On preliminary data, Sep–Dec would need to average about 284.7k, above every 2026 month and well above last year's Sep–Dec average of about 278k. (c) NO: Q4 stays at 278–281k, scheduled WARN layoffs land (Nature's Bakery, Cornerstone), and the benchmark revision is small or negative. That leaves the annual average around 278–279k. (d) YES: the benchmark revision lifts the 2026 monthly levels by roughly 2–3k and Q4 hiring picks up, carried by Missouri PMI at 57.5 and national ISM expansion. Together those could push the average just over 280.5k. A state manufacturing benchmark revision of a few thousand is plausible, but its direction is unknown, and recent national revisions have tended negative. The market at 28% seems to overprice this revision path given how large the gap is. I discount to about 13%, keeping a meaningful tail for revision risk.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
66% conf
| Yes | 14% |
| No | 86% |
(0) Not resolved. BLS will not publish the 2026 annual average until after the early-2027 benchmark revision, around March 2027. The resolution-source read of SMU29000003000000001 shows Jan–Aug 2026 NSA values averaging about 278.4k, below the 280.5k threshold. (a) About 6.5 months remain until the April 30, 2027 close. Four more monthly prints (Sep–Dec) are due, plus the benchmark revision. (b) Status quo means No. If Sep–Dec looks like 2025 (about 278k), the annual average lands near 278.3k, roughly 2k short. Prints alone would need Sep–Dec to average about 284.7k, above every 2026 month so far. (c) NO scenario: manufacturing stays flat to soft. Scheduled WARN cuts (Nature's Bakery in September, Cornerstone in October) and the sector's year-over-year decline keep Q4 near 278–280k, and the benchmark revision is small or negative. (d) YES scenario: the benchmark revision lifts 2026 levels by about 0.8% or more (2k+), and Q4 hiring improves on the strong Missouri PMI (57.5) and national ISM expansion. Combined, these push the published average just above 280.5k. Benchmark revisions to state manufacturing of that size are plausible but not the norm, and their direction is uncertain. The Kalshi price of 28% (down 12 points this week) seems to overprice the revision path. I shade it to about 14% while keeping meaningful weight on revision uncertainty.
4. Final plain mean of 4 draws
14%
(64% confidence)
Yes: 14%
No: 86%
Mean of 4 draws (0.15, 0.15, 0.13, 0.14). (0) Not resolved. BLS has not published a 2026 annual average and will likely do so only after the benchmark revision around March 2027. The NSA series SMU29000003000000001 shows January–August 2026 averaging about 278.4k, below the fixed 280.5k threshold. (a) About 6.5 months remain before the April 30, 2027 close; four monthly prints (Sep–Dec) plus the annual benchmark revision are still to come. (b) Status quo: if September–December runs near the recent 278–280k range, as September–December 2025 did at about 278k, the preliminary annual average lands around 278.5–279k. That is No. (c) No: September–December stays flat or slips. Missouri WARN notices from Nature's Bakery and Cornerstone fall in the fourth quarter, monthly reports show manufacturing as a laggard (-1,000 in August, -500 year over year), and the benchmark revision is small or negative. (d) Yes: the realistic path is not a fourth-quarter surge, since September–December would need to average about 284.7k. It is the March 2027 benchmark revising 2026 levels up by roughly 2k or more across the year. State manufacturing benchmark revisions of 1–2% do happen, and Missouri's PMI at 57.5 and national ISM expansion offer mild support. The direction of that revision is unknown, and recent revisions have tended to be downward. The Kalshi anchor at 28% (down 12 points in a week) seems to price substantial revision risk. I shade below it because the arithmetic gap is large and the trend is negative, while keeping meaningful weight on the revision uncertainty.
5. Entry Decision Opus 5.5 trader
Side
no
Position Size
$800
Contracts
1096
Trader Confidence
Trade rationale
This is a with-favourite NO: the market prices YES at 28%, the forecast is 14.3%, and both sit below 50%. That is the book's profitable kind of trade (27 wins, 5 losses). The thesis rests on arithmetic I checked. January–August averaged about 278.4k, so September–December would have to average about 284.7k to clear the 280.5k line. That is well above the recent 278–280k range, and manufacturing is shrinking month over month and year over year, with fourth-quarter WARN notices pending. The only realistic route to YES is an upward benchmark revision of 2k or more in March 2027. That is possible but not the base case, since recent revisions have leaned downward. The four forecast draws agree closely (13–15%, confidence about 0.65). This market has no prior scans or positions in our book.
Allocation logic
I sized below the $1,000 baseline because the book is thin. A $1,000 NO order fills at 0.745, against a best price of 0.73. That cuts the edge to about 11pp, and there is only about $300 resting within 5 cents of the mid on each side. The price has also been very volatile (daily vol about 12pp, range 0.10–0.44 over 30 days), and the benchmark revision risk is real. $800 keeps slippage manageable while still sizing for a solid, uncorrelated edge.
Entry price:
$0.73
Current:
$0.60
Status:
OPEN
P&L:
-$157.59
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 103.5s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.