forecasting
agent
← back to scans

Will the number of new privately owned housing units authorized by building permits in Colorado in 2026 be above 32,000?

kalshiEconomics·2026-10-10·view on kalshi ↗
38%
Agent
35%
Market Price
+3.2%
Edge
59%
Confidence
30,718
Volume
28.0c
Spread
109
Days to resolution
5
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 5 draws (0.37, 0.40, 0.35, 0.35, 0.44). (0) Not resolved: the Census resolution source has monthly state files only through Aug 2026, and no full-year 2026 figure exists. (a) Sep–Dec 2026 permitting remains, with data released from late Oct 2026 into early 2027; the market closes Jan 27, 2027. (b) FRED COBPPRIV gives Jan–Aug 2026 unadjusted permits summing to 21,232, about 3% below Jan–Aug 2025 (~21,893, implied from the 33,754 final 2025 total). Sep–Dec needs more than ~10,770 units versus 11,861 in 2025, i.e. about 91% of last year's pace; the Apr–Aug seasonally adjusted average (~2,620/month) lands almost exactly on the line, while the softer Jun–Aug pace (~2,495) implies ~31,500. (c) No: the 7.03% mortgage-rate spike, a falling NAHB index, the Colorado Springs September single-family collapse (42 by mid-month vs 181 in Sep 2025) and code-change permit delays leave Q4 below 91% of 2025, for a total of about 31,000–31,800. (d) Yes: lumpy Denver multifamily approvals plus a strong December like 2025's 3,434 push the total to ~32,500. The Kalshi anchor of 35% (wide 30/58 spread, sharp recent drop) already reflects the late weakening; my run-rate math is near a coin flip, but the specific negative Q4 signals and uncertainty over how monthly sums map to the resolving annual release keep me slightly above the market at 37%.
price vs. prediction
market price agent forecast at t+0
8 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen: kalshi_direct resolution_source fred kalshi_related
Planner reasoning
The anchors are the Kalshi price and the Census state-level permits data (BPS). FRED has the Colorado monthly permits series (COBPPRIV), so I can sum the YTD 2026 figures through about August and compare them with prior years. kalshi_related covers the other strike levels in the same event.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports) Tools - kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Above 32,000** (KXCOBUILDPERMITS-27JAN27-T32000) - Current price (probability): 35.00% (live; bid 30% / ask 58%) - 7-day price change: -36.00% - 30-day price change: -45.00% - Average daily volume: 2194 contracts - Price range: 35.00% - 82.00% - Data points: 14 days - resolution_source: already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=September 24, 2026. The page lists monthly Permits-by-State data files through August 2026, but no annual 2026 total is available yet since the calendar year is not complete. - fred: Fetched 5 FRED series (lookback=1100d) (via search 'Colorado new private housing units authorized by building permits'). - kalshi_related: 1 related markets / summaries. series KXCOBUILDPERMITS: 0 markets (skipped 5 no-signal) | keyword 'Colorado building permits': ok Research loops, bottom lines - current state: Based on partial 2026 monthly Census/FRED data (six of eight months through August total ~14,956 units, with Feb and Mar missing), Colorado's building-permit pace in 2026 appears similar to or somewhat softer than 2025 (final total 33,754) and 2024 (32,185), both of which cleared 32,000; whether 2026 clears 32,000 depends heavily on the still-unreported Feb–Mar months and the magnitude of the typically strong Q4 (Oct–Dec 2025 alone totaled 9,472 units), making the outcome close but not clearly d - base rate: The reference class shows Colorado comfortably cleared 32,000 in the most recently finalized year (2025: 33,754) and far exceeded it in 2021-2022 boom years (~48,995 in 2022), but the trend since 2022 has been a multi-year decline driven mainly by a multifamily collapse; 2026 year-to-date monthly data trace a softer pace than 2025's, putting a naive run-rate extrapolation close to or modestly below the 32,000 threshold, making this a genuinely close call on the base-rate/trend dimension. - yes case: The strongest case for YES rests on (1) Colorado's two most recent complete years (2024: 32,185; 2025: 33,754) both already clearing 32,000, (2) mid-2026 seasonally-adjusted monthly permit levels (notably July's ~2,965) still tracking near 2025's pace rather than collapsing, and (3) localized acceleration in the Colorado Springs/Pikes Peak market (detached single-family YTD +6%, duplexes YTD +142%) plus a slightly positive year-over-year national/regional permitting trend that could lift the sta - no case: Colorado entered 2026 only marginally above the 32,000 threshold in both 2024 and 2025, and the strongest available evidence shows conditions have worsened materially since — a late-September mortgage-rate spike to 7.03% (a two-year-plus high), falling national/state builder sentiment, a documented September single-family permit collapse in Colorado Springs, new 2026 code-driven permit-timing disruptions, and still-active 2025 tariff cost pressure — all pointing to Q4 2026 permitting coming in s
tools
toolstatustimeitemssummary
kalshi_direct OK 0.2s 1 ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Above 32,000** (KXCOBUILDPERMITS-27JAN27-T32000) - Current price (probability): 35.00% (live; bid 30% / ask 58%) - 7-day price change: -36.00% - 30-day price change: -45.00% - Average daily volume: 2194 contracts - Price range: 35.00% - 82.00% - Data points: 14 days
resolution_source OK 2.9s 1 already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=September 24, 2026. The page lists monthly Permits-by-State data files through August 2026, but no annual 2026 total is available yet since the calendar year is not complete.
fred OK 7.8s 5 Fetched 5 FRED series (lookback=1100d) (via search 'Colorado new private housing units authorized by building permits').
kalshi_related OK 0.7s 1 1 related markets / summaries. series KXCOBUILDPERMITS: 0 markets (skipped 5 no-signal) | keyword 'Colorado building permits': ok
research loops · 4/4 ok · 16 searches · 10 page reads
dimensionstatustimesearchespage readsreport
current state OK 60s 6 5 4234 chars
base rate OK 50s 4 2 5274 chars
yes case OK 50s 2 2 4774 chars
no case OK 41s 4 1 6404 chars
report: current state
- [2026-09-24] FRED/Census data (series COBPPRIV, not seasonally adjusted) show Colorado monthly new privately-owned housing units authorized by building permits for 2026: Jan 1,652; Apr 3,299; May 2,991; Jun 2,374; Jul 2,740; Aug 1,900 (Feb and Mar 2026 figures were not available in the sources checked). https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COBPPRIV - [2026-09-24] The six available 2026 months (Jan, Apr–Aug) sum to 14,956 units authorized; Feb and Mar 2026 remain unaccounted for in the data retrieved. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COBPPRIV - [2026-09-17] The U.S. Census Bureau/HUD's September 17, 2026 "New Residential Construction" release reported August 2026 national permits at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1,394,000, 2.7% below the revised July rate; this is the most recent national permits print and the next release (covering September 2026) is scheduled for October 20, 2026. https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/newresconst.pdf - [undated, retrieved 2026-10-10] Census QuickFacts lists Colorado's final annual "Building Permits, 2025" figure at 33,754 units, the Bureau's own official annual count for the prior year (above the 32,000 threshold being tested for 2026). https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/CO - [undated, retrieved 2026-10-10] Census QuickFacts also shows Colorado's 2024 annual building-permits total at 32,185 units, meaning the last two full years (2024 and 2025) both finished just above 32,000. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/CO,US/RHI825218 (cross-checked via search snippet) - [2026-05-14] The Census Bureau's Building Permits Survey page confirms final annual 2025 estimates (state, CBSA, county, place level) were released on May 14, 2026, which is the type of release (complete Jan–Dec state data) that will determine this market's 2026 resolution once published in spring 2027. https://www.census.gov/permits - [per release schedule] The Census Building Permits Survey schedule shows monthly "Revised Building Permits" (state-level) released around the 17th workday of each month; September 2026 data is due October 27, 2026, and October 2026 data is due November 25, 2026 — both before the market's January 27, 2027 close, but the final complete-year 2026 state total will not be published until spring 2027 (historically mid-May), i.e., after the contract's trading close. https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/schedule.html - [2026-07-24/2026-08-25] Denver-Aurora-Lakewood MSA (Colorado's largest metro, roughly 60-65% of state permits historically) recorded NSA permits of 1,252 (Feb), 1,737 (Mar), 2,189 (Apr), 1,143 (May), and 905 (Jun) 2026, suggesting a cooling trend in the state's largest permitting market during mid-2026. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DENV708BPPRIV - [undated] Grand Junction, CO (MSA) NSA permits were comparatively small in 2026 (74 Mar, 47 Apr, 67 May, 90 Jun, 53 Jul), consistent with a modest-but-steady smaller-metro contribution to the statewide total. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GRAN308BPPRIV BOTTOM LINE: Based on partial 2026 monthly Census/FRED data (six of eight months through August total ~14,956 units, with Feb and Mar missing), Colorado's building-permit pace in 2026 appears similar to or somewhat softer than 2025 (final total 33,754) and 2024 (32,185), both of which cleared 32,000; whether 2026 clears 32,000 depends heavily on the still-unreported Feb–Mar months and the magnitude of the typically strong Q4 (Oct–Dec 2025 alone totaled 9,472 units), making the outcome close but not clearly decided by current data. The final determinative Census state-level annual release for 2026 is not expected until mid-2027 (after this February 2027 contest close), so resolution will likely rely on preliminary/cumulative monthly data published through the Revised Building Permits releases (next: Sept 2026 data on Oct 27, 2026; Oct 2026 data on Nov 25, 2026). NOT FOUND: Exact February and March 2026 statewide (COBPPRIV) NSA permit totals; a complete Jan–Sep or Jan–Dec 2026 cumulative state-level figure; any Census Bureau statement specifying exactly which release the market will treat as the "first complete Jan–Dec 2026" state data point (preliminary cumulative file vs. final annual release).
report: base rate
- [2026-10-10 as of Sep 24 update] FRED's official Census Bureau series shows Colorado new privately-owned housing units authorized by building permits (all structure types, not seasonally adjusted) for 2026 so far: Aug 2026: 1,900 | Units, Not Seasonally Adjusted | Monthly, Jul 2026: 2,740, Jun 2026: 2,374, May 2026: 2,991, Apr 2026: 3,299 , with January 2026 at 1,652 per an earlier FRED snapshot. Summing the six known months (Jan, Apr-Aug) gives ~14,956 units, an average pace of about 2,490/month; a naive 12-month extrapolation at that pace would land near ~29,900 — below the 32,000 threshold — though February and March 2026 values were not located. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COBPPRIV - [2026-10-10] The U.S. Census Bureau's QuickFacts page for Colorado reports Annual data for 2025 was released on May 14, 2026 , and the confirmed final figure is Final annual estimates for 2025 of housing units authorized by building permits for the U.S. and by Census Region, Census Division, state, core based statistical area, county, permit-issuing place, and island areas are now available — QuickFacts lists Colorado's 2025 Building Permits value at 33,754 units, already above the 32,000 strike. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/CO - [~2025-10 reported] A per-capita state ranking site citing the Census Building Permits Survey lists Total Units Authorized for Colorado in 2025 at 33,754 units, ranked #11 nationally, consistent with the QuickFacts figure above. https://statspanda.com/building-permits-per-capita-by-state - [2023-04-21 reported] A construction-industry recap noted that In 2015, the state surpassed the 30,000 permits threshold and now ranks eighth for the highest total number of permits issued in 2022: 48,995 , showing Colorado has historically cleared 32,000 with room to spare in strong years (2021-2022 boom). - [2023-04-21] The same report noted a sharp pullback already underway: Colorado follows the trend, with a Y-o-Y drop in permits of -13.32% from 2021 to 2022, and The number of permits issued in the state's largest metro, Denver-Aurora-Lakewood, decreased by -21.78% in that same period — illustrating how volatile annual totals can be relative to any fixed threshold. - [2025-03-14 reported] A Colorado policy analysis described the post-2022 slump concentrated in multifamily: Multifamily housing development projections showed a 47 percent drop in permits in 2024, the lowest level since the Great Recession... Multifamily permits, which previously accounted for over 50 percent of residential construction, fell to about one-third of new units in 2024 , while Single-family housing construction is rebounding after a slowdown. Permits were projected to increase nearly 8 percent from 2023 to 2024 and are expected to rise another 12 percent in 2025 . - [2025, Denver County only] County-level FRED data for Denver (a large share of the state total) shows a declining multi-year trend: 2024: 3,994, 2023: 5,725, 2022: 8,296, 2021: 10,000, 2020: 5,059 , reflecting the broader statewide cooling from 2021-2022 peaks seen across Colorado. - [2026-10-10, trend read] National single-family permitting has also weakened in 2025, per NAHB: After showing some resilience in 2024, permitting activity gradually lost momentum throughout 2025 as elevated mortgage rates and ongoing affordability constraints weighed on buyer demand. By year's end, the pace of single-family permit issuance was below the level recorded in 2024... Over the year, the number of single-family permits issued nationwide reached 909,280 , a macro headwind that plausibly extends into Colorado's 2026 pace. - [2026-07-14 reported, Denver metro only] A Redfin-sourced local report showed Denver metro monthly permit counts for 2025 ranging roughly 825–1,860/month with January 2026 at 825, suggesting city-level momentum has been choppy rather than strongly rising. https://krdo.com/stacker-denver/2026/07/14/how-many-homes-are-getting-built-in-denver-in-2026/ - [2026-10-10] No betting markets, prediction-market track record, or published expert point-forecasts specifically targeting "Colorado 2026 annual permits above 32,000" were found; the closest outside-view anchors are the Census Bureau's own historical annual series and state-level projections from Colorado housing-policy groups (e.g., Bell Policy Center) that expected single-family growth but a continued multifamily slump through 2025. NOT FOUND: Complete month-by-month 2026 NSA series (February and March 2026 values were not located); any formal 2026 full-year forecast/point-estimate for Colorado permits from Census, NAHB, or state demographer; any track record of similar Kalshi/other-market "building permits above X" contracts resolving historically. BOTTOM LINE: The reference class shows Colorado comfortably cleared 32,000 in the most recently finalized year (2025: 33,754) and far exceeded it in 2021-2022 boom years (~48,995 in 2022), but the trend since 2022 has been a multi-year decline driven mainly by a multifamily collapse; 2026 year-to-date monthly data trace a softer pace than 2025's, putting a naive run-rate extrapolation close to or modestly below the 32,000 threshold, making this a genuinely close call on the base-rate/trend dimension.
report: yes case
YES means: the U.S. Census Bureau's state-level Building Permits Survey data for Colorado show a 2026 calendar-year total of new privately-owned housing units authorized above 32,000 (as reported in whichever release the market treats as the "first complete Jan–Dec 2026" figure). - [2026-09-24, updated] FRED's seasonally-adjusted Colorado series (COBPPRIVSA) shows monthly levels holding in the 2,000–3,000 range through mid-2026 — Jan 2026 1,968.22125; Dec 2025 2,929.08320; Nov 2025 2,992.29324; Oct 2025 2,899.97345; Sep 2025 2,510.14734 — and the latest observations show Aug 2026: 2,073.69070; Jul 2026: 2,964.65832; Jun 2026: 2,447.50889; May 2026: 2,636.03801; Apr 2026: 2,978.08126 , meaning July's seasonally-adjusted pace (~2,965) nearly matched the strongest 2025 months, arguing against a collapse in permitting momentum. (fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COBPPRIVSA) - [2026-10-04] In the Pikes Peak region (Colorado Springs metro, Colorado's second-largest permitting market), year-to-date detached single-family home construction as of the end of August was 1,802 new homes, a 6% increase from the same period last year , a pocket of acceleration that could help offset softness reported elsewhere in the Denver metro. (gazette.com) - [2026-10-04] Within that same region, product mix is shifting toward denser, cheaper-to-build units: Townhome construction was down while duplex construction was up year-over-year between Jan. 1 and Aug. 31... One-hundred-sixty-one townhomes were permitted, a 32% decrease from the same period in 2025, while 121 duplexes were permitted, a 142% increase over last year , adding unit-count volume even if building counts fall. (gazette.com) - [2026-09-17] Nationally, permitting is not in freefall: the official Census release shows August's rate is 2.7 percent below the revised July rate of 1,433,000, but is 3.5 percent above the August 2025 rate of 1,347,000 , a year-over-year increase that, if mirrored in Colorado, would push the state above its 2025 pace (which itself cleared 32,000). (census.gov/construction/nrc) - [2026-09] NAHB's regional breakdown of 2026 year-to-date permits shows the West region (which includes Colorado) running ahead of a year ago: total permits were 12.5% higher in the Northeast, 2.7% higher in the Midwest, 3.5% lower in the South, and 1.7% higher in the West , a modest but positive regional tailwind rather than a regional decline. (eyeonhousing.org) - [2026-01-21] A statewide market-reset report anticipated improving demand conditions entering 2026, noting mortgage rates easing into the low 6% range may boost 2026 demand — a scenario that, had it materialized, would have supported higher permitting; single-family sales had already shown resilience, with single-family sales rose 3% even as median prices held flat across Denver metro in 2025. (coloradobiz.com) - [2025] State housing-policy analysis projected continued single-family growth into 2025 that could plausibly extend into 2026 if sustained: Permits were projected to increase nearly 8 percent from 2023 to 2024 and are expected to rise another 12 percent in 2025 , with a similar modest rebound... in 2025, with a projected 10 percent rise in permits for multifamily — a growth trajectory that, if it did not reverse sharply, keeps 2026 within reach of 32,000 given 2024 and 2025 already cleared that bar (per colleagues' QuickFacts figures). (bellpolicy.org) - [2026-09-24] Monthly seasonally-adjusted Colorado permits in 2026 have not fallen below ~1,968 units in any reported month, and five of six available months (Apr–Aug) exceeded 2,400, so a full-year total built from a ~2,500/month average (close to the observed Apr–Aug average) would land near 30,000 even before accounting for a typically stronger Q4 — meaning only a modest Q4 pickup (which colleagues note totaled 9,472 units in Oct–Dec 2025 alone) is needed to cross 32,000. (fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COBPPRIVSA) BOTTOM LINE: The strongest case for YES rests on (1) Colorado's two most recent complete years (2024: 32,185; 2025: 33,754) both already clearing 32,000, (2) mid-2026 seasonally-adjusted monthly permit levels (notably July's ~2,965) still tracking near 2025's pace rather than collapsing, and (3) localized acceleration in the Colorado Springs/Pikes Peak market (detached single-family YTD +6%, duplexes YTD +142%) plus a slightly positive year-over-year national/regional permitting trend that could lift the state over the threshold once the typically strong Q4 permitting season is counted. NOT FOUND: A complete Jan–Sep or Jan–Dec 2026 cumulative Colorado state-level total; February and March 2026 NSA state figures; any official Census or NAHB point forecast specifically for Colorado's full-year 2026 permit total.
report: no case
YES means: U.S. Census Bureau reports Colorado's 2026 calendar-year total of new privately-owned housing units authorized by building permits exceeds 32,000 units. The NO case argues this threshold will not be cleared. - [2026-10-01] National mortgage and financing conditions deteriorated sharply in Q4 2026: NAHB chief economist Robert Dietz noted long-term rates accelerated after the Fed raised (not cut) interest rates in September, and the 30-year fixed mortgage rate averaged 7.03% as of Sept. 24, reaching its highest level since January 2025 , directly undercutting the "rates easing" narrative colleagues found in spring 2026 reports. https://www.nahb.org/blog/2026/10/housing-headwinds-intensify - [2026-10-01] Builder sentiment is falling, not stabilizing: the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index fell three points to 32, its lowest level since September 2025, with builders citing higher mortgage rates, tight lending conditions, rising land, labor and construction costs, higher gas/diesel prices, and persistent labor shortages . https://www.nahb.org/blog/2026/10/housing-headwinds-intensify - [2026-10-01] National permits are already rolling over into Q4: overall housing starts decreased 2.6% in August to a 1.28 million seasonally adjusted annual rate, with multifamily starts falling 21.7% year over year while permits also softened, down 2.7% — a national deceleration that typically transmits to state-level permitting with a short lag. https://www.nahb.org/blog/2026/10/housing-headwinds-intensify - [2026-10-04] At the hyper-local level, Colorado Springs — the state's second-largest metro — is already showing a sharp September pullback: halfway through the month, the Pikes Peak Regional Building Department reported it had issued permits for only 42 new single-family homes so far, well under September 2025's total of 181 permits , a >75% year-over-year collapse in that partial-month comparison. https://gazette.com/2026/10/04/colorado-springs-housing-market-shifts-toward-buyers-3/ - [2026-10-04] New Colorado code mandates are compounding the slowdown: the Gazette reports builders are pulling fewer permits in anticipation of the Model Electric Ready/Solar Ready Code and Wildfire Resiliency Code that took effect in late June/early July 2026, with real-estate sources attributing the September permit drop partly to builders anticipating code changes that will add more time and money to construction . https://gazette.com/2026/10/04/colorado-springs-housing-market-shifts-toward-buyers-3/ - [2026-10-04] Townhome permitting in El Paso County is down sharply year-over-year: one-hundred-sixty-one townhomes were permitted (Jan 1–Aug 31), a 32% decrease from the same period in 2025 , showing multifamily-adjacent product types softening even where overall detached single-family counts look flat. https://gazette.com/2026/10/04/colorado-springs-housing-market-shifts-toward-buyers-3/ - [2026-10-05 reported] Statewide housing demand indicators point the same direction: Colorado led the nation with 32% of listings seeing price cuts in August 2026 as high mortgage rates reshape the housing market statewide , and by late September the 30-year rate had climbed to 7.03% versus 6.30% a year earlier — a headwind for builders deciding whether to pull new permits into a softening sales market. https://hoodline.com/2026/10/colorado-sellers-cut-prices-most-in-the-nation-as-buyers-gain-the-upper-hand/ - [2026-04-29] The national Census release for March 2026 confirms the permit slowdown predates the September rate spike: privately-owned housing units authorized by building permits in March were at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1,372,000, 10.8 percent below the revised February rate of 1,538,000 and 7.4 percent below the March 2025 rate , indicating 2026 was already tracking below 2025's pace well before mid-year. https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/newresconst_202603.pdf - [2026-07] National single-family data corroborate a multi-month downtrend that would need to reverse sharply for Colorado to clear 32,000: over the first five months of 2026 the number of single-family permits issued nationwide reached 380,130, a 6.1 percent decline compared with the May 2025 total of 404,977 . https://eyeonhousing.org/2026/07/single-family-permitting-continued-to-weaken-through-may/ - [2025, tariff mechanism] A Colorado-specific policy mechanism for sustained softness: the Bell Policy Center documents that tariffs implemented in October 2025, ranging from 10 to 25 percent on essential construction materials such as steel, aluminum, copper, lumber, cabinetry, and appliances/electronics, have driven up building costs and led to a decline in housing permits, adding roughly 4-6 percent to new-home prices — a cost shock still working through 2026 project pipelines. https://bellpolicy.org/housing-affordability-in-colorado-under-shifting-federal-policy/ - [2026-10-01] Forward-looking commentary (Housingwire, citing economist Hepp) describes a "perfect storm" for builders of rising costs, including their own borrowing costs, and labor shortages following a mortgage-rate spike that some economists now say could push starts negative "for the foreseeable future," reinforcing that Q4 2026 — the seasonally heaviest quarter needed to push Colorado over 32,000 — is entering on a weakening, not strengthening, trend. https://www.housingwire.com/articles/housing-starts-august-2026/ BOTTOM LINE: Colorado entered 2026 only marginally above the 32,000 threshold in both 2024 and 2025, and the strongest available evidence shows conditions have worsened materially since — a late-September mortgage-rate spike to 7.03% (a two-year-plus high), falling national/state builder sentiment, a documented September single-family permit collapse in Colorado Springs, new 2026 code-driven permit-timing disruptions, and still-active 2025 tariff cost pressure — all pointing to Q4 2026 permitting coming in softer than the strong Q4 2025 that pushed last year's total over the line, making a sub-32,000 outcome the more probable path absent a sudden reversal. NOT FOUND: A complete September or October 2026 Colorado statewide (COBPPRIV) permit figure; any state demographer or Census Bureau point-forecast specifically for Colorado's full-year 2026 total; confirmation of which exact 2027 release Kalshi will treat as resolution data.
3. Forecasters 5 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT-6 Astra + GPT-5.6 Sol · plain mean
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
50% conf
Yes 37%
No 63%
(0) Not resolved: the Census resolution source has monthly state files only through Aug 2026, and no full-year 2026 figure exists. (a) Sep–Dec 2026 permitting remains, with data released from late Oct 2026 into early 2027; the market closes Jan 27, 2027. (b) FRED COBPPRIV gives Jan–Aug 2026 unadjusted permits summing to 21,232, about 3% below Jan–Aug 2025 (~21,893, implied from the 33,754 final 2025 total). Sep–Dec needs more than ~10,770 units versus 11,861 in 2025, i.e. about 91% of last year's pace; the Apr–Aug seasonally adjusted average (~2,620/month) lands almost exactly on the line, while the softer Jun–Aug pace (~2,495) implies ~31,500. (c) No: the 7.03% mortgage-rate spike, a falling NAHB index, the Colorado Springs September single-family collapse (42 by mid-month vs 181 in Sep 2025) and code-change permit delays leave Q4 below 91% of 2025, for a total of about 31,000–31,800. (d) Yes: lumpy Denver multifamily approvals plus a strong December like 2025's 3,434 push the total to ~32,500. The Kalshi anchor of 35% (wide 30/58 spread, sharp recent drop) already reflects the late weakening; my run-rate math is near a coin flip, but the specific negative Q4 signals and uncertainty over how monthly sums map to the resolving annual release keep me slightly above the market at 37%.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
50% conf
Yes 40%
No 60%
(0) Not resolved. The Census state page has monthly files only through August 2026. Resolution waits on the first release with complete January–December 2026 data, probably the December cumulative file around late January 2027. (a) About 3.5 months of permitting (Sep–Dec) remain, plus the reporting lag. (b) Status quo: the FRED NSA data, which does include Feb (2,809) and Mar (3,467), puts Jan–Aug 2026 at 21,232. That is about 3% behind the implied Jan–Aug 2025 figure of roughly 21,893. To clear 32,000, Sep–Dec needs about 10,770 units, around 9% below Sep–Dec 2025's 11,861. That corresponds to a seasonally adjusted pace of about 2,630/month. The last five SA months average almost exactly that (about 2,620), but August's 2,074 is weak. (c) NO: the late-September rate spike to 7.03%, the Fed hike, builder sentiment at 32, and the September collapse in Colorado Springs (42 vs 181 permits mid-month) hold Q4 near an August-like pace, and the total lands around 30,500–31,500. (d) YES: lumpy multifamily approvals, especially in Denver, plus a normal seasonal Q4 at roughly 2025 levels push the total to about 32,500–33,000. The market's 35% (mid about 44%, wide spread), after falling from 82%, likely reflects the weak August print. My run-rate math puts this near a coin flip with a tilt toward NO from the worsening macro data. I also allow some risk that the cumulative-release sum differs from the FRED monthly sums.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
63% conf
Yes 35%
No 65%
The condition is not documented as met or impossible: the Census state-permits page, updated September 24, runs only through August, and resolution requires the first state-level release containing complete January–December 2026 data, not the later final annual revision. As of October 10, approximately 82 days remain in the measurement year and 109 days until the January 27 trading close. Crucially, raw FRED data include February's 2,809 and March's 3,467 units omitted from the research reports, bringing January–August to 21,232 and requiring at least 10,769 during September–December, or 2,692 per month. The status-quo eight-month run rate produces 31,848 units, narrowly NO, while continuing the weaker May–August pace produces 31,237. A NO scenario is persistent permitting weakness following August's 1,900 units and the financing headwinds reported by NAHB on October 1, although the recent rate claims and Colorado Springs half-month comparison deserve limited weight. A YES scenario is a rebound resembling September–December 2025's 11,861 units, which would produce 33,093, potentially helped by lumpy multifamily authorizations and localized Colorado Springs growth. I retain Kalshi's 35% YES anchor because the complete monthly arithmetic corrects the reports' bearish extrapolation but supplies no demonstrably unpriced edge against the market, whose 30%–58% spread also signals substantial pricing uncertainty. The forecast allows for unreported months and revisions incorporated into the first complete Census release to move a near-threshold total across 32,000; subsequent revisions cannot change settlement.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
62% conf
Yes 35%
No 65%
I anchor on Kalshi's 35% Yes price (30% bid/58% ask) and retain it because the research provides no clearly unpriced edge warranting a departure. The Census state-permits page, updated September 24, contains data only through August, so the event remains unresolved, with approximately 82 days left in the measurement year and 109 days until trading closes January 27. Unlike the incomplete research summaries, raw Census-derived FRED series COBPPRIV includes February and March: January–August totals 21,232 units, requiring at least 10,769 more during September–December, absent revisions. Maintaining the year-to-date monthly average produces 31,848 units, making the status-quo outcome a narrow No. A clearer No scenario follows if June–August's weaker average of 2,338 units persists, producing approximately 30,584 for the year, consistent with the financing and sentiment headwinds reported by NAHB on October 1. A Yes scenario requires a rebound to approximately 2,692 units monthly over September–December; repeating those months' 2025 total of 11,861 would produce 33,093, although a decline exceeding roughly 9.2% would eliminate that cushion. I discount the Gazette's claimed September collapse because it compares a partial month with a full month, and the recent rate-shock narrative is insufficiently corroborated to justify an aggressive bearish adjustment. Settlement depends on the first Census state release containing complete January–December data, not spring's final annual estimates, so revisions incorporated into that first complete release and lumpy multifamily authorizations create meaningful uncertainty around this close threshold.
gpt-5.6-sol · high effort
68% conf
Yes 44%
No 56%
(0) The condition is not already met or impossible: the Census resolution page contains data only through August, while raw Census/FRED series COBPPRIV totals 21,232 units for January-August, so September-December must contribute at least 10,769 units by December 31 for Yes. (a) There are 82 days left in calendar 2026 and 109 days until trading closes, with the first complete January-December state release still pending. (b) If the January-August average of 2,654 units per month simply continues, the year finishes near 31,848, making No the status quo projection. Kalshi's Yes anchor is 35%, but I price somewhat higher because the raw feed includes the previously omitted February and March figures and shows that the required final-four-month total is only about 9.2% below September-December 2025's 11,861 units. (c) No results if the August weakness, 7% mortgage rates, deteriorating builder sentiment, and Colorado code and cost pressures hold the remaining months below 10,769. (d) Yes results if seasonal strength or resilient Denver and Colorado Springs activity keeps the final four months within roughly 9% of last year's pace; the first-release-only resolution rule adds modest revision risk near the threshold.
4. Final plain mean of 5 draws
38% (59% confidence)
Yes: 38% No: 62%
Mean of 5 draws (0.37, 0.40, 0.35, 0.35, 0.44). (0) Not resolved: the Census resolution source has monthly state files only through Aug 2026, and no full-year 2026 figure exists. (a) Sep–Dec 2026 permitting remains, with data released from late Oct 2026 into early 2027; the market closes Jan 27, 2027. (b) FRED COBPPRIV gives Jan–Aug 2026 unadjusted permits summing to 21,232, about 3% below Jan–Aug 2025 (~21,893, implied from the 33,754 final 2025 total). Sep–Dec needs more than ~10,770 units versus 11,861 in 2025, i.e. about 91% of last year's pace; the Apr–Aug seasonally adjusted average (~2,620/month) lands almost exactly on the line, while the softer Jun–Aug pace (~2,495) implies ~31,500. (c) No: the 7.03% mortgage-rate spike, a falling NAHB index, the Colorado Springs September single-family collapse (42 by mid-month vs 181 in Sep 2025) and code-change permit delays leave Q4 below 91% of 2025, for a total of about 31,000–31,800. (d) Yes: lumpy Denver multifamily approvals plus a strong December like 2025's 3,434 push the total to ~32,500. The Kalshi anchor of 35% (wide 30/58 spread, sharp recent drop) already reflects the late weakening; my run-rate math is near a coin flip, but the specific negative Q4 signals and uncertainty over how monthly sums map to the resolving annual release keep me slightly above the market at 37%.
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 155.1s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.