forecasting
agent
← back to scans

Will the Iran war and foreign policy be the issue voters rank most important in the 2026 national U.S. House exit poll?

kalshiElections·2026-10-06·view on kalshi ↗
8%
Agent
39%
Market Price
-30.6%
Edge
78%
Confidence
12,882
Volume
36.0c
Spread
31
Days to resolution
7
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 5 draws (0.05, 0.05, 0.11, 0.12, 0.09) after one crux research pass. (0) The condition is not met yet. The 2026 exit poll does not exist; the resolution-source fetch returned only CNN's 2022 and 2024 pages. Resolution depends on CNN's 2026 national House exit poll as displayed at noon ET on November 6. (a) About four weeks remain until the November 3 election and the November 6 resolution snapshot. (b) If nothing changes, Economy and cost of living wins comfortably. Marquette's September poll shows inflation at 37% plus economy at 16%, against 10% for the Iran war, and Iran's share has fallen from 24% in April. Fox has cost of living at 34% vs Iran at 4%. Pew has economy at 29% vs foreign policy at 4%. CBS's own Battleground Tracker, a named backup source, says Iran ranks below the economy. The war's main effect on voters runs through gas prices, which push answers toward the Economy strike. Historically, foreign policy has scored about 4% in national exit polls since 2008, with 2004's Iraq war the only exception. (c) No scenario: the war keeps simmering, voters choose inflation, the economy and democracy, and the war choice lands around 5-12%. (d) Yes scenario: a dramatic late shock, such as mass U.S. casualties or a homeland attack, plus an exit-poll answer list that splits economic options thin while offering a broad war or national-security option, pushes the Iran strike to a plurality. The Kalshi 39% quote is not a credible anchor: the book is 2% bid / 38% ask with only two days of data, and the last daily close was 4%. The research supports something close to that close.
price vs. prediction
market price agent forecast at t+0
12 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen: kalshi_direct kalshi_related polymarket_related resolution_source wikipedia fred article_search
Planner reasoning
The Kalshi price on this strike and its sibling strikes (economy, democracy, immigration) is the main anchor. The resolution source is the CNN national House exit poll, and how its answer choices are worded drives the term mapping. The 2018, 2022 and 2024 exit polls give a reference class: the economy or inflation usually leads, and foreign policy rarely does. FRED inflation and sentiment data show how strong the economy issue is, and one targeted search can pick up recent 'most important issue' polling that includes the Iran war.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports) Tools - kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Iran war and foreign policy** (KXEXITPOLLISSUE-26NOV06-FPOL) - Current price (probability): 39.00% (live; bid 2% / ask 38%) - Last daily close (2026-09-27): 4.00% - 7-day price change: +37.00% - 30-day price change: +37.00% - Average daily volume: 6441 contracts - Price range: 2.00% - 4.00% - Data points: 2 days - resolution_source: already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=False; last_updated=unknown. The fetched pages are CNN's exit poll pages for the 2024 and 2022 House elections, not the 2026 election. No exit poll data for the 2026 U.S. House race is present on either page; the content is mostly navigation/menu text. - kalshi_related: 2 related markets / summaries. series KXEXITPOLLISSUE: 0 markets (skipped 7 no-signal) | keyword 'exit poll issue': ok | keyword 'Iran war': ok - polymarket_related: Polymarket search over 3 keyword(s), kept 5 matches. keyword 'exit poll': 0 markets | keyword 'most important issue': 5 markets | keyword 'Iran war': 0 markets - wikipedia: Fetched 2 Wikipedia entries (0 missing pages). - fred: Fetched 3 FRED series (lookback=365d). - article_search: Fetched 4 unique articles across 1 queries (lookback=45d). 'most important issue poll Iran war economy September 2026 Gallup': 8 articles Research loops, bottom lines - current state: Across every identified 2026 poll that asks a direct "most important issue" question (Fox News, Pew, Chicago Council, Emerson, AP-KFF), the economy/cost-of-living bucket leads overwhelmingly (29-41%+) while Iran war/foreign policy as a standalone answer choice draws only 1-4%, even though the war is ongoing, unresolved, and increasingly discussed as an election topic; current state strongly favors economy/cost-of-living, not Iran war/foreign policy, as the top exit-poll issue. - base rate: In every national exit poll since at least 2008 (presidential or midterm), "foreign policy/national security" has finished last or near-last among tested issues (4% in 2024, not separately tested or negligible in 2022); the single historical exception (2004, ~34% citing Iraq/War on Terror) required a year-plus of an active ground war with mounting casualties, a much higher salience event than the current Iran war. Nearly all 2026 pre-election polling (Emerson, Pew, Fox, NBC, Deseret/Hinckley, AP - yes case: The strongest path to YES is not current polling (which uniformly shows Iran/foreign policy at 1-4% on open-ended questions) but a structural and escalation-driven scenario: the war is historically unusual in scale (thousands of deaths, 750+ U.S. wounded, 220+ days), remains actively escalating with Trump threatening post-midterm strikes, and GOP leaders like Thune already describe it as having "trumped everything else" — so a major kinetic event or crisis in the final weeks, combined with the e - no case: Every current-cycle "most important issue" survey, including the CBS News Battleground Tracker (a named resolution-source outlet) and CNN's own reporting, explicitly subordinates Iran/foreign policy to the economy/cost-of-living bucket, and Iran's standalone salience has fallen (Marquette: 24%→10%) even as war-driven gas prices get rhetorically folded into "economy" answers that would map to the Economy strike, not the Iran strike, under the question's own mapping rules — strongly supporting NO. Crux follow-up - Every available national poll from spring through early October 2026 (Marquette tracked monthly, Fox, CBS, uspollingdata tracker) consistently shows economy/cost-of-living/inflation leading by a wide margin (30–50+ points combined) over Iran/foreign policy/national security (roughly 4–10%), and this gap has been stable or widening as Iran salience fell from 24% (April) to 10% (September) even as the war continues and escalates. The weight of evidence strongly favors No, absent a dramatic last-mi
tools
toolstatustimeitemssummary
kalshi_direct OK 0.7s 1 ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Iran war and foreign policy** (KXEXITPOLLISSUE-26NOV06-FPOL) - Current price (probability): 39.00% (live; bid 2% / ask 38%) - Last daily close (2026-09-27): 4.00% - 7-day price change: +37.00% - 30-day price change: +37.00% - Average daily volume: 6441 contracts - Pri
kalshi_related OK 13.5s 2 2 related markets / summaries. series KXEXITPOLLISSUE: 0 markets (skipped 7 no-signal) | keyword 'exit poll issue': ok | keyword 'Iran war': ok
polymarket_related OK 0.8s 5 Polymarket search over 3 keyword(s), kept 5 matches. keyword 'exit poll': 0 markets | keyword 'most important issue': 5 markets | keyword 'Iran war': 0 markets
resolution_source OK 4.2s 1 already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=False; last_updated=unknown. The fetched pages are CNN's exit poll pages for the 2024 and 2022 House elections, not the 2026 election. No exit poll data for the 2026 U.S. House race is present on either page; the content is mostly navigation/menu text.
wikipedia OK 0.5s 2 Fetched 2 Wikipedia entries (0 missing pages).
fred OK 1.7s 3 Fetched 3 FRED series (lookback=365d).
article_search OK 0.3s 4 Fetched 4 unique articles across 1 queries (lookback=45d). 'most important issue poll Iran war economy September 2026 Gallup': 8 articles
research loops · 4/4 ok · 20 searches · 5 page reads
dimensionstatustimesearchespage readsreport
current state OK 36s 5 2 4885 chars
base rate OK 31s 5 1 5634 chars
yes case OK 50s 5 1 4611 chars
no case OK 46s 5 1 6723 chars
report: current state
- [2026-10-06] The 2026 Iran war remains active and unresolved: ceasefire talks are stalled, with Iran's president calling U.S. negotiations "meaningless" and oil prices easing despite continued fighting in Yemen/Red Sea. Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian said negotiations with the U.S. were "meaningless" and only resulted in renewed attacks, with progress on ending the Middle East war stalled for months. (cbsnews.com) - [2026-10-05] Day 220 of the war: Trump said a decision on Iran is imminent, "the easy way or the hard way," while Iran's parliament speaker said the Strait of Hormuz stays closed until seven conditions are met. Trump has suggested renewed strikes "after midterms" are possible. (globalsecurity.org) - [2026-09-24] Fox News Poll (Sep 11–14, 2026): when asked to name the most important issue facing the country, in their own words, only 4% of voters say Iran and a miniscule 1% name foreign policy in general. By comparison, 34% mention the top issue of the cost of living. (foxnews.com) - [2026-09-24] Emerson College national poll (fielded Sep 21–22): forty-one percent of voters are most concerned about the economy, up four points from August. Threats to democracy follow at 17%, immigration at 13%, and healthcare at 12% — Iran war not among the top named "most concerned" issues, though on a separate 1–5 importance-rating scale the Iran War, jobs, and tariff policy ranked the highest, while data centers ranked the lowest among issues listed . (emersoncollegepolling.com) - [2026-10-01] Chicago Council Survey (fielded July 10-21, 2026) finds few Americans name the US-Iran war as their most important voting issue (2%), yet the war is a factor that has shaped the economic anxieties taking center stage in midterm decisions. (globalaffairs.org) - [2026-10-06] Christian Science Monitor summary of surveys: in a recent Pew Research Center poll, 29% of registered voters said the economy was their top issue heading into the midterms, while only 4% said it was foreign policy... several recent surveys, including from the Chicago Council, still show the economy is the unchallenged top priority for voters, with "foreign policy" falling well down the list. (csmonitor.com) - [2026-10-04] Juan Cole/FPIF piece notes rising salience of the war as an election issue but still subordinate to cost of living: an AP-KFF survey of more than 2,000 rural registered voters found that 42 percent considered it extremely important for midterm candidates to discuss the conflict with Iran... Cost of living ranked even higher overall, with 69 percent saying it was an extremely important issue for candidates to address. (juancole.com) - [2026-07-09] Pew Research Center survey (July 6–12): 29% of registered voters named an economic concern as the issue they most wanted congressional candidates to discuss... foreign policy by 4%. (meaww.com/Pew via secondary) - [2026-09-07] Fox News Power Rankings piece: midterm elections are eight weeks away, and polls show the economy is voters' top issue. No Iran-war or foreign-policy issue is cited among the top drivers. (foxnews.com) - [2024-11-05] Baseline from the last comparable national exit poll (2024 CNN exit poll, cited by NPR): for more than a third of voters, democracy was the top issue, followed by the economy (about 3 in 10 voters), abortion rights (1 in 7), and immigration (1 in 10). Foreign policy was in low single digits — less than 10% — as a top issue. This shows foreign policy has historically never topped a national House/presidential exit poll. - [2026-10-06] No poll found in which "Iran war," "foreign policy," or "national security" as a combined bucket outpolls the economy/cost-of-living bucket on a most-important-issue question; all trackers (Fox, Pew, Chicago Council, Emerson "most concerned" question, uspollingdata aggregator) place economy/cost-of-living first by wide margins, with the Iran-war/foreign-policy explicit answer choice typically in the low single digits (1-4%). BOTTOM LINE: Across every identified 2026 poll that asks a direct "most important issue" question (Fox News, Pew, Chicago Council, Emerson, AP-KFF), the economy/cost-of-living bucket leads overwhelmingly (29-41%+) while Iran war/foreign policy as a standalone answer choice draws only 1-4%, even though the war is ongoing, unresolved, and increasingly discussed as an election topic; current state strongly favors economy/cost-of-living, not Iran war/foreign policy, as the top exit-poll issue. NOT FOUND: No draft or preview of the actual 2026 CNN exit poll questionnaire/answer-choice wording was available (it will only be finalized on Election Day); no post-ceasefire data (none reached) showing a shift in salience; no polling specifically replicating the exact exit-poll answer-choice format with "Iran war" worded as its own option alongside "economy," "immigration," etc.
report: base rate
- [2026-09-27] AP/KFF rural voters survey: ahead of the midterms, rural voters rank pocketbook concerns above immigration, the conflict with Iran and several major domestic policy debates , with 69% citing cost of living as extremely important vs. foreign-policy-adjacent concerns far lower. https://www.axios.com/2026/09/27/rural-voters-cost-of-living-midterms - [2026-09-24] Emerson College September 2026 national poll: forty-one percent of voters are most concerned about the economy, up four points from August. Threats to democracy follow at 17%, immigration at 13%, and healthcare at 12% — foreign policy/Iran war not in top tier of the "most concerned" question. https://emersoncollegepolling.com/september-2026-national-poll-democrats/ - [2026-07-24] Pew Research (fielded July 6-12): most voters want to hear congressional candidates talk about economic issues, specifically prices and affordability , reinforcing economy's dominance months before the election. https://courthousenews.com/economic-issues-are-driving-voter-choice-in-2026-midterms/ - [2026-09-20] NPR/PBS/Marist poll found Democrats lead on handling issues including foreign policy, but voters also think Democrats would be better for the economy (42% to 38%), gas prices (40% to 27%) and foreign policy (42% to 36%); these four are top issues for the midterms — foreign policy is one of several competitive issues, not isolated as the top concern. https://www.wabe.org/poll-most-voters-agree-the-2026-midterms-are-all-about-trump-and-they-disapprove-2/ - [2026-09-28] Fox News Power Rankings: midterm elections are eight weeks away, and polls show the economy is voters' top issue by a wide margin, with healthcare second. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/fox-news-power-rankings-whats-economy - [2026-10-04] NBC/Meet the Press (NBC poll) found the economy is the number one issue for voters, including Latino voters who were critical to President Trump's 2024 victory ; combined cost-of-living/jobs/economy was 43% for Latinos. https://www.nbcnews.com/meet-the-press/transcripts/meet-press-october-4-2026-rcna601407 - [2026-09-21] NBC News national poll: when voters ranked the most important issue facing the country, government corruption was the second-most popular choice... Democrats also have a 7-point edge on controlling inflation, as well as slight leads on dealing with the war in Iran — implying inflation/economy-type issues outranked Iran war specifically. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2026-election/poll-voters-say-trump-hurt-economy-competitive-midterm-election-looms-rcna597868 - [2026-09-29] Deseret News/Hinckley poll (Morning Consult): with about five weeks to go until the 2026 November midterm elections, voters overwhelmingly say the issues most affecting their decision in the voting booth are inflation and the U.S. economy , even as war-driven gas prices are cited as a contributing factor to that economic concern, not a standalone top issue. https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/poll-shows-top-issues-voters-100000193.html - [2024-11-05] Historical base rate — 2024 presidential exit poll (CNN/NEP, most comparable "most important issue" format used for the 2026 House exit poll): Foreign policy (4%), Abortion (14%), The economy (32%), Immigration (12%), The state of democracy (34%) — foreign policy was last and far from leading. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2024-elections/exit-polls - [2022-11-09] Historical base rate — 2022 midterm NEP exit poll: the NEP asked voters which of five issues mattered most to voters. Inflation was the top issue (31 percent) followed closely by abortion (27 percent). Crime and separately gun policy followed at 11 percent. Ten percent mentioned immigration — foreign policy was not even listed as a top-tier option. https://www.aei.org/op-eds/the-2022-exit-polls-a-z/ - [2004-11-02] The one modern precedent for foreign policy/security leading: National security rightly emerged as the predominant issue of the 2004 election. Some 34 percent of the electorate cited either Iraq or the War on Terror as the policy issue of greatest concern — this required an active major ground war (Iraq) with sustained casualties dominating news cycles for over a year, a much higher salience than the current more limited/shorter Iran conflict. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/20050621.pdf - [2026-09-xx] Aggregated issue tracker across 2026 polls shows economy top at 72% say "very important," healthcare 64%, immigration 58%, democracy 52% with foreign policy/Iran not among the top five most-cited issues in any tracked survey. https://uspollingdata.com/polls/issue-polling-tracker/ BOTTOM LINE: In every national exit poll since at least 2008 (presidential or midterm), "foreign policy/national security" has finished last or near-last among tested issues (4% in 2024, not separately tested or negligible in 2022); the single historical exception (2004, ~34% citing Iraq/War on Terror) required a year-plus of an active ground war with mounting casualties, a much higher salience event than the current Iran war. Nearly all 2026 pre-election polling (Emerson, Pew, Fox, NBC, Deseret/Hinckley, AP/KFF) consistently places the economy/cost-of-living far ahead of foreign policy/Iran as the top issue, making a Yes resolution a strong historical outlier. NOT FOUND: No pre-election poll replicating CNN's exact 2026 House exit-poll issue list (with the Iran-war answer choice worded) was found; could not locate any forecast or betting market specifically modeling the exit-poll issue-ranking outcome (as opposed to generic "top issue" surveys).
report: yes case
YES means: on November 3, 2026, the CNN national U.S. House exit poll's most-important-issue question shows the combined "Iran war and foreign policy" answer-choice bucket (any choice containing Iran, war, foreign policy, national security, or terrorism) outscoring every other mapped bucket, including economy/cost-of-living. - [2026-10-05] The war is now in an unprecedented eighth month with a documented, large-scale human cost — CENTCOM/independent counts of 19–25 U.S. military dead and roughly 750–900+ wounded, and an estimated 8,000–10,600 total killed region-wide — a casualty profile approaching the scale that made foreign policy the top 2004 exit-poll issue. (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_2026_Iran_war) - [2026-10-05] Senate Majority Leader John Thune said bluntly that the Iran war has become an incredibly important issue for voters ahead of the November midterms , and that "Iran is sort of trumped everything else that's going on." (thehill.com) - [2026-10-05] Reporting frames the war's effect on gas/diesel prices as "the most direct channel through which the costs of the Iran war were transmitted to American voters," meaning any exit-poll answer choice that names the war itself (rather than generic "economy") could pull dissatisfied voters into the Iran bucket. (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_United_States_elections) - [2026-10-01] Trump himself has conceded the political risk, telling reporters it's "possible" the war could cost Republicans the midterms, while his daughter-in-law Lara Trump said Iran is "absolutely holding out" until the election and that the war "could cost him these midterms." (nationalsecurityjournal.org) - [2026-10-01] A fresh AP-NORC poll found only 28% approve of Trump's handling of the Iran war and only 17% approve of his cost-of-living handling, indicating the war and economic discontent are now politically fused rather than cleanly separable for many voters. (nationalsecurityjournal.org) - [2026-10-05] Trump told TIME that ramped-up bombing of Iran is "possible" after the midterms and that the U.S. has spent six months "stocking up" on weapons, meaning a major kinetic escalation remains live through Election Day and could generate a late-breaking surge in war salience that pre-election surveys (fielded weeks earlier) could not capture. (iranintl.com) - [2026-10-04] As of Day 220, the U.S. was still surging a third carrier strike group and up to 10,000 additional troops to the Middle East, with a suspected Iran-linked plot forcing withdrawal of bombers from a UK airbase — signs of an actively intensifying, newsworthy conflict in the final weeks before the vote. (globalsecurity.org, cfr.org) - [2026-10-04] An AP-KFF rural-voter survey found that fully 42% (57% among rural Democrats) called it "extremely important" for midterm candidates to discuss the Iran conflict — far higher salience than the 1-4% open-ended "most important issue" mentions, showing the war is a serious secondary concern that could convert to a leading choice if offered explicitly on a structured exit-poll ballot rather than recalled unprompted. (juancole.com) - [2026-10-06] Even NPR's Election Day-eve analysis, while naming the economy the top issue, explicitly credits "the war with Iran and Trump's tariffs" as the direct drivers of the cost increases voters are angry about, underscoring that any escalation event between now and Nov 3 would be plausibly coded by media and pollsters as a "war" issue rather than generic "economy." (npr.org) BOTTOM LINE: The strongest path to YES is not current polling (which uniformly shows Iran/foreign policy at 1-4% on open-ended questions) but a structural and escalation-driven scenario: the war is historically unusual in scale (thousands of deaths, 750+ U.S. wounded, 220+ days), remains actively escalating with Trump threatening post-midterm strikes, and GOP leaders like Thune already describe it as having "trumped everything else" — so a major kinetic event or crisis in the final weeks, combined with the exit poll's broad keyword-based bucket (capturing any "war," "national security," or "foreign policy" answer choice), is the one plausible mechanism that could push the combined Iran bucket above economy on Election Day itself, even though no current survey shows it ahead. NOT FOUND: No confirmed draft text of CNN's 2026 exit-poll answer-choice wording; no polling conducted after any hypothetical pre-election escalation event (none has yet occurred); no survey showing the Iran/foreign-policy bucket outright leading in any format, structured or open-ended, as of October 6, 2026.
report: no case
YES means: on the national CNN exit poll displayed at/after 12:00 PM ET Nov 6, 2026, the combined percentage of answer choices mapping to "Iran, war, foreign policy, national security or terrorism" exceeds the combined percentage of every other strike's mapped answer choices (including economy/cost-of-living, immigration, democracy, health care, abortion, crime), per the literal resolution rules. - [2026-10-05] CBS News's own Battleground Tracker, one of the four outlets named in the market's resolution waterfall, states directly: "While voters place relatively less importance on the conflict with Iran as a top issue relative to the economy, the two are connected." This is a primary-source admission from a named resolution-source outlet that Iran trails the economy. (cbsnews.com) - [2026-08-18] Marquette Law School national poll (July 22–29 field dates) shows Iran-war salience has been falling, not rising, over the campaign: "The war with Iran is chosen by 10%, a decline from April, when 24% said it was the most important issue." (today.marquette.edu) - [2026-09-28] The most recent Fox News Power Rankings poll puts cost of living far ahead with the war a distant single-digit option: "34% of registered voters say the cost of living is the top issue facing the country... Nothing else came close. Immigration was at 8%. The war with Iran, 4%." (foxnews.com) - [2026-09-27] AP-KFF's rural-voter survey, often cited as evidence the war is "becoming" salient, actually still subordinates it: "An AP-KFF survey of more than 2,000 rural registered voters found that 42 percent considered it extremely important for midterm candidates to discuss the conflict with Iran... Cost of living ranked even higher overall, with 69 percent saying it was an extremely important issue." That is an "importance to discuss" metric, not a "most important issue" vote share, and even on that softer metric Iran still loses. (juancole.com) - [2026-10-06] Even the Christian Science Monitor piece built around the thesis that foreign policy is unusually salient this cycle concedes the baseline framing hasn't flipped: a Chicago Council analyst is quoted that "It's true that foreign policy is traditionally well down the list of what's motivating voters, but these midterms are different," an assertion of a mechanism (gas-price pass-through), not of Iran actually leading any "most important issue" tally. (csmonitor.com) - [2026-09-29] Deseret News/Hinckley (Morning Consult) frames the war only as an input to the economy number, not a separate leading issue: gas prices "have jumped more than 40% since the U.S.-Iran war began," but the survey's conclusion is that "voters overwhelmingly say the issues most affecting their decision in the voting booth are inflation and the U.S. economy." (deseret.com) - [2026-09-25] CNN's own house poll/analysis (Harry Enten), relevant because CNN is the market's primary settlement source, frames Iran as a drag on Trump's approval but still subordinate to pocketbook concerns: "There is a real question whether Iran is as big an issue as Iraq was, given that unlike in Iraq, there aren't boots on the ground, and we haven't seen large numbers of US troops deaths. The main issue people complain about today is high domestic gas prices." This suggests CNN's own framing channels Iran salience through the "economy" bucket rather than a standalone "foreign policy" lead. (cnn.com) - [2026-10-01] Mechanically, the new 2026 "Voter Poll by SSRS" replaces the traditional single-sponsor Edison/NEP exit poll with a consortium design that "merges the methodologies of the Edison/NEP Exit Poll and AP VoteCast/FOX News Voter Analysis, bringing together the networks...for the first general election in a decade." A changed, broader-coalition instrument makes it more likely the issue list mirrors the pre-election polls above (economy-dominant) rather than skewing toward a narrow "Iran war" option gaining a plurality. (ssrs.com) - [2026-10-05] On-the-ground war status shows no resolution event (e.g., a ceasefire breakthrough or a dramatic escalation) that could spike salience before the election: "Trump said a decision on Iran is imminent, 'the easy way or the hard way,' while Iran's parliament speaker said the Strait of Hormuz stays closed until seven conditions are met." A continuing stalemate, absent a shock event, implies no last-minute jump in exit-poll salience for foreign policy specifically. (globalsecurity.org) - [2026-10-06] NPR's state-level midterm preview confirms the economy frame still dominates even where Iran-driven costs are discussed: "Across the political divide, one concern keeps rising to the top: the cost of living and what it means for people's economic futures. But this year, some of the forces driving those costs are coming from far beyond voters' own communities." Costs, not foreign policy, remain the named top concern. (npr.org) - [2026-09-28] Senate Majority Leader Thune's own comment, often cited for "Iran trumps everything," actually undercuts that framing when read in full: he immediately pivots to say "Well, right now, the races are — it's more about — it's, you know, it is affordability issues, it's the price of diesel in places like Iowa and Kansas and Nebraska and the Midwest, Minnesota." Even the politician credited with the "Iran trumps everything" quote frames the operative issue as affordability. (thehill.com) - Historical base rate (from prior reports, not restated in detail): in every NEP/Edison national exit poll since 2008, foreign policy/national security has finished last or near-last, and the single exception (2004) required a year-plus active ground war with mounting U.S. casualties — a higher-salience template than the current remote-strike/blockade-style Iran war, which produces no comparable domestic casualty count. BOTTOM LINE: Every current-cycle "most important issue" survey, including the CBS News Battleground Tracker (a named resolution-source outlet) and CNN's own reporting, explicitly subordinates Iran/foreign policy to the economy/cost-of-living bucket, and Iran's standalone salience has fallen (Marquette: 24%→10%) even as war-driven gas prices get rhetorically folded into "economy" answers that would map to the Economy strike, not the Iran strike, under the question's own mapping rules — strongly supporting NO. NOT FOUND: No poll or preview reproducing the exact 2026 SSRS/Voter Poll "most important issue" answer-choice wording (the instrument that will determine literal strike-mapping) was available; no evidence of any poll in which an Iran/foreign-policy/national-security answer choice outpolls the economy bucket under this question's defined mapping.
3. Forecasters 5 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT-6 Astra + GPT-5.6 Sol · plain mean · re-drawn after crux research
crux research
The first round disagreed: the draws' mean 0.09 sits 0.30 from the same-question market "this kalshi market" at 0.39. One more research loop went after the crux and every draw below was redone with its report.
first-round draws: 5%, 4%, 13%, 13%, 8% · crux loop: 4 searches, 2 page reads
report: crux
CRUX: Whether, despite the ongoing Iran war, pre-election and likely exit polls show voters naming the "economy/cost-of-living" bucket far ahead of "Iran/foreign policy/national security" as the single most important issue — i.e., is there any polling evidence the Iran war is actually competitive with the economy for the top spot, or is the gap consistently large (tens of points)? - 5 Oct 2026 (Marquette Law School Poll, Sept. survey, nationally released): inflation is "by far the most important issue for Americans, with 37% ranking it first among 10 issues considered," followed by the economy at 16%, with the war with Iran at 10%. Combined economy-strike terms (inflation+economy) ≈53% vs Iran ≈10%. - Aug 2026 Marquette trend: the war with Iran was picked as most important by 24% in April, the second most-cited issue , but by September concern over the war with Iran has declined from 24% in April to 10% as of September, while the importance of most other issues has remained relatively stable. - 4 Oct 2026 (CBS News Battleground Tracker, Sept 30–Oct 2 poll): while voters place relatively less importance on the conflict with Iran as a top issue relative to the economy, the two are connected… Most feel the conflict has contributed to higher gas prices, and those voters are backing Democrats for the House. This confirms that war-driven cost effects are folded into the "economy/prices" framing rather than boosting a separate "Iran/foreign policy" answer. - 7 Sept 2026 (Fox News Power Rankings): Midterm elections are eight weeks away, and polls show the economy is voters' top issue… the state of the economy will shape their choice: it's the top issue for voters by a wide margin. - Early Oct 2026, uspollingdata.com tracker: Economy 72% "very important," Healthcare 64%, Immigration 58%, Democracy & Elections 52% (foreign policy/Iran not in top tier). - Historical baseline: in the most recent comparable national exit polls, 34% of voters said democracy mattered most to their votes, while 31% said the economy… just 4% named foreign policy (2024), and in 2012 4 percent cited foreign policy as their top issue. - Live conflict status (5 Oct 2026, GlobalSecurity.org): the Iran war is ongoing at "Day 220," with Trump saying a decision on Iran is imminent, "the easy way or the hard way," while Iran's parliament speaker said the Strait of Hormuz stays closed until seven conditions are met — i.e., real escalation risk exists but has not yet translated into elevated "most important issue" salience in any poll through early October. - CBS News live blog (5 Oct 2026) shows continuing military escalation (carrier deployments, Hormuz tanker strikes, Camp David strategy meetings), but no poll yet shows this escalation lifting Iran above economy in "most important issue" framing. BOTTOM LINE: Every available national poll from spring through early October 2026 (Marquette tracked monthly, Fox, CBS, uspollingdata tracker) consistently shows economy/cost-of-living/inflation leading by a wide margin (30–50+ points combined) over Iran/foreign policy/national security (roughly 4–10%), and this gap has been stable or widening as Iran salience fell from 24% (April) to 10% (September) even as the war continues and escalates. The weight of evidence strongly favors No, absent a dramatic last-minute shock (e.g., mass U.S. casualties, homeland attack) that current data give no sign of. NOT FOUND: No October 2026 poll yet explicitly replicates the exact CNN exit-poll issue-list wording; no evidence of any poll in which Iran/war/foreign-policy approaches even 20%, let alone leads the economy bucket.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
80% conf
Yes 5%
No 95%
(0) The condition is not met yet. The 2026 exit poll does not exist; the resolution-source fetch returned only CNN's 2022 and 2024 pages. Resolution depends on CNN's 2026 national House exit poll as displayed at noon ET on November 6. (a) About four weeks remain until the November 3 election and the November 6 resolution snapshot. (b) If nothing changes, Economy and cost of living wins comfortably. Marquette's September poll shows inflation at 37% plus economy at 16%, against 10% for the Iran war, and Iran's share has fallen from 24% in April. Fox has cost of living at 34% vs Iran at 4%. Pew has economy at 29% vs foreign policy at 4%. CBS's own Battleground Tracker, a named backup source, says Iran ranks below the economy. The war's main effect on voters runs through gas prices, which push answers toward the Economy strike. Historically, foreign policy has scored about 4% in national exit polls since 2008, with 2004's Iraq war the only exception. (c) No scenario: the war keeps simmering, voters choose inflation, the economy and democracy, and the war choice lands around 5-12%. (d) Yes scenario: a dramatic late shock, such as mass U.S. casualties or a homeland attack, plus an exit-poll answer list that splits economic options thin while offering a broad war or national-security option, pushes the Iran strike to a plurality. The Kalshi 39% quote is not a credible anchor: the book is 2% bid / 38% ask with only two days of data, and the last daily close was 4%. The research supports something close to that close.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
80% conf
Yes 5%
No 95%
(0) Not resolved: the 2026 exit poll does not exist yet. CNN's 2022 and 2024 pages hold no 2026 data, so this will be decided by the poll displayed November 6. (a) About one month remains: the election is November 3 and the CNN figure is read at 12:00 PM ET on November 6. (b) Status quo strongly favors No. Every 2026 most-important-issue poll puts the economy-strike terms far ahead. Marquette's September poll has inflation at 37% plus economy at 16%, against Iran at 10%, and Iran has fallen from 24% in April. Fox has cost of living at 34% against Iran at 4%, Pew has foreign policy at 4%, and the CBS Battleground Tracker says Iran ranks below the economy. War-driven gas prices get folded into answers that map to the Economy strike. Historically, foreign policy took about 4% in the 2012 and 2024 exit polls, and 2004 is the only exception. (c) No: the exit poll lists economy/inflation, democracy, immigration, health care, abortion and foreign policy or Iran, and economy wins comfortably — the default path. (d) Yes: a dramatic late shock, such as mass U.S. casualties or a homeland attack, spikes war salience. Alternatively, the new SSRS instrument could word options so the Iran bucket absorbs war-related cost anger, though a choice like 'gas prices from the Iran war' would map to Economy because 'price' appears first. The Kalshi 39% looks like a stale ask on a 2%/38% book, against a last close of 4%, so I anchor nearer the traded level and the evidence. I put Yes at about 5%.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
77% conf
Yes 11%
No 89%
The condition is neither met nor impossible as of October 6: the resolution-source fetch returned only CNN’s 2022 and 2024 pages, not a resolving 2026 poll. There are 28 days until Election Day and 31 until the controlling CNN snapshot at noon ET November 6, with availability fallbacks extending through November 7. I anchor on Kalshi’s reported 39% YES price, but its 2% bid/38% ask spread makes that a weak consensus signal. My reduction to 11% reflects a specific polling gap that quote appears to underweight: Marquette’s October 5 release reports September preferences of 37% inflation plus 16% economy—53% under the aggregation rules—against 10% Iran, corroborated by Fox’s September survey showing 34% cost of living versus 4% Iran and 1% foreign policy, and CBS’s October 4 finding that Iran remains subordinate to the economy. If priorities remain unchanged, No is the status-quo forecast; continued fighting that voters primarily experience as higher gasoline prices also produces a straightforward NO scenario because price-related responses map to the economy bucket. YES could result from a major pre-election security shock or mass-casualty escalation that makes explicitly war-, terrorism-, or national-security-worded responses collectively exceed every competing bucket. I retain meaningful YES probability because the actual questionnaire is unavailable: a war-first mixed economic answer would map differently from a price-first answer, while the designated source’s displayed question, publication timing, and fallback availability—not broader polling or the war’s real-world importance—ultimately govern settlement.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
76% conf
Yes 12%
No 88%
The condition is not already met: the resolution-source fetch returned only CNN’s 2022 and 2024 pages, not the required 2026 national House exit poll. There are 28 days until November 3 voting and 31 until the governing November 6 noon ET CNN snapshot, with source-availability and fallback provisions extending through November 7. I anchor on Kalshi’s reported 39% YES, although its 2% bid/38% ask and inconsistent recent-price fields indicate a noisy consensus. The specific evidence I judge underweighted is the October 5 Marquette release showing inflation at 37% and economy at 16%, aggregating to 53% against Iran’s 10%, independently reinforced by CBS’s September 30–October 2 survey finding Iran less important than the economy. If current priorities persist, NO is the status-quo outcome: Fox’s September survey likewise showed 34% naming cost of living versus 4% Iran and 1% foreign policy. A straightforward NO scenario is continued fighting without a transformative shock, with voters selecting affordability answers even when the war caused those costs. YES could result from a major late military or homeland-security shock, or war-first wording in a popular combined answer choice, pushing the qualifying bucket above every competitor. My retained 12% explicitly allows for escalation, imperfect translation from pre-election surveys, and the unknown CNN questionnaire/display: literal wording, aggregation and first-keyword precedence—not the underlying cause of voters’ concerns—determine settlement.
gpt-5.6-sol · high effort
78% conf
Yes 9%
No 91%
(0) The condition is not already met: CNN has no 2026 House exit-poll results, so the Iran/war/foreign-policy bucket must still rank first in CNN’s November 6 display. (a) About 31 days remain until the specified November 6 resolution snapshot, although voters cast ballots on November 3. (b) If conditions remain broadly unchanged, the economy/cost-of-living bucket wins: September Marquette data put inflation plus economy near 53% versus 10% for the Iran war, while Fox found cost of living at 34% versus Iran at 4%. Kalshi’s 39% Yes price is the required anchor, but I move sharply lower because multiple recent independent polls—including CBS, a fallback resolution outlet—show a large economy lead, Iran salience declining from 24% in April to 10% in September, and war-driven gas costs being classified by voters as economic concerns; the market’s two-day history and exceptionally wide 2%/38% quote also suggest a weak consensus. (c) A NO scenario is that the war continues without a transformative shock and voters continue identifying inflation, prices, or the economy as most important, consistent with every located 2026 survey and the 2024 exit-poll baseline of 32% economy versus 4% foreign policy. (d) A YES scenario requires a major pre-election escalation—such as mass U.S. casualties, a homeland attack, or a severe national-security crisis—that rapidly moves voters from pocketbook framing into an explicitly war or national-security answer. The active conflict and unknown final questionnaire preserve meaningful tail risk, but no current poll has the Iran-related bucket close to first place.
4. Final plain mean of 5 draws · second round
8% (78% confidence)
Yes: 8% No: 92%
Mean of 5 draws (0.05, 0.05, 0.11, 0.12, 0.09) after one crux research pass. (0) The condition is not met yet. The 2026 exit poll does not exist; the resolution-source fetch returned only CNN's 2022 and 2024 pages. Resolution depends on CNN's 2026 national House exit poll as displayed at noon ET on November 6. (a) About four weeks remain until the November 3 election and the November 6 resolution snapshot. (b) If nothing changes, Economy and cost of living wins comfortably. Marquette's September poll shows inflation at 37% plus economy at 16%, against 10% for the Iran war, and Iran's share has fallen from 24% in April. Fox has cost of living at 34% vs Iran at 4%. Pew has economy at 29% vs foreign policy at 4%. CBS's own Battleground Tracker, a named backup source, says Iran ranks below the economy. The war's main effect on voters runs through gas prices, which push answers toward the Economy strike. Historically, foreign policy has scored about 4% in national exit polls since 2008, with 2004's Iraq war the only exception. (c) No scenario: the war keeps simmering, voters choose inflation, the economy and democracy, and the war choice lands around 5-12%. (d) Yes scenario: a dramatic late shock, such as mass U.S. casualties or a homeland attack, plus an exit-poll answer list that splits economic options thin while offering a broad war or national-security option, pushes the Iran strike to a plurality. The Kalshi 39% quote is not a credible anchor: the book is 2% bid / 38% ask with only two days of data, and the last daily close was 4%. The research supports something close to that close.
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 241.6s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.