← back to scans
Will Donald Trump's approval rating on approval rating be below 36% during Dec 2025 to Dec 2026 according to VoteHub?
70%
Agent
72%
Market Price
-1.6%
Edge
54%
Confidence
76,830
Volume
1.0c
Spread
94
Days to resolution
6
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 5 draws (0.70, 0.68, 0.72, 0.72, 0.70). (0) No confirmed VoteHub reading below 36%; last confirmed values are 38.5% (Sep 6) and 38% (Sep 23, net -22.4 record low), and the June 9 '35%' claim is unverified. The resolution-source fetch failed (403), so the current VoteHub value is unknown. (a) About 12 weeks remain until Dec 31, 2026, and only one daily reading below 36% is needed. (b) Status quo: VoteHub at about 38% needs roughly 2 more points of decline. Supporting the trend: AP-NORC 31%, CNN/SSRS 33%, Reuters/Ipsos 32%, Verasight 33% and Civiqs 34% are all low, and peer aggregators FiftyPlusOne and The Economist are at 35.0%. The Kalshi anchor rose 25 points in 7 days to 72%, implying traders see VoteHub near the line. (c) No: VoteHub runs at the higher end of trackers, steadier polls (ActiVote 37.7%, uspollingdata 37.3%) suggest a floor around 36-38%, and approval stabilises or rallies before year-end. (d) Yes: the low October polls roll into VoteHub's average and push it below 36% for at least one day. A related Polymarket tracker prices only about 5% on below 36.0% by Oct 9, so a crossing is not imminent, but the drift plus noise over nearly three months makes a single touch likely. I stay close to the market, slightly below it given VoteHub's higher-end lean.
price vs. prediction
market price
agent forecast at t+0
13 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen:
kalshi_direct
resolution_source
kalshi_related
polymarket_related
Planner reasoning
The Kalshi price is the anchor. The VoteHub tracker page decides resolution, both its current approval value and whether it has already dipped below 36% since Dec 11, 2025. Related Kalshi approval-threshold markets and Polymarket approval markets give cross-venue triangulation on the level and the path of the rating.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports)
Tools
- kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Below 36%** (KXTRUMPAPPROVALBELOW-26DEC31-36) - Current price (probability): 72.00% (live; bid 71% / ask 72%) - 7-day price change: +25.00% - 30-day price change: +38.00% - Average daily volume: 364 contracts - Price range: 26.00% - 72.00% - Data points: 114 days
- resolution_source (failed): https://votehub.com/polls/trump-approval-rating/: HTTP 403
- kalshi_related: 1 related markets / summaries. series KXTRUMPAPPROVALBELOW: 0 markets (skipped 4 no-signal) | series KXAPPROVAL: 0 markets (skipped 0 no-signal) | keyword 'Trump approval rating': ok
- polymarket_related: Polymarket search over 1 keyword(s), kept 5 matches. keyword 'Trump approval rating': 5 markets
Research loops, bottom lines
- current state: As of the most recent available VoteHub-specific data point (Sept. 23, 2026: 38% approve/60.4% disapprove, net -22.4), VoteHub's aggregate has not yet shown approval below 36%, even though several individual polls (AP-NORC 31%, Reuters/Ipsos low-30s, Civiqs 34%) and some rival aggregators (Economist, FiftyPlusOne) have already crossed below that level — meaning VoteHub's average could plausibly cross 36% soon given the broader downward trend, but has not been confirmed to have done so yet.
- base rate: Across 2025-2026, Trump's approval (both VoteHub's own average and closely comparable trackers) has trended steadily downward from the high-40s/50s at inauguration into the high-30s by late 2025 and the 36-39% band by September-October 2026, with individual polls and several sister aggregators already dipping into the low-to-mid 30s; the sustained, accelerating decline and lack of historical reversals make a sub-36% VoteHub reading at some point before Dec 31, 2026 consistent with the dominant t
- yes case: VoteHub's last confirmed reading (38% approve, Sept 23, 2026) sits only 2 points above the 36% threshold at a moment of record-low net approval (−22.4) with virtually every peer tracker and individual poll already at or below 36-37% and no sign of reversal — making a sub-36% VoteHub reading before Dec 31, 2026 a highly plausible, near-term continuation of the existing trend rather than a low-probability tail event.
- no case: Every confirmed, dated VoteHub-attributed reading from April through late September 2026 has stayed at or above 36% (range ~38-40%), AP-NORC's own input polls plateaued at exactly 36% for multiple months without breaching lower, and the term's single largest stress event (the record-length shutdown) only pushed aggregates into the low 40s — all consistent with a resilient floor near 36-38% rather than a confirmed sub-36% VoteHub crossing.
tools
| tool | status | time | items | summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| kalshi_direct | OK | 0.2s | 1 | ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Below 36%** (KXTRUMPAPPROVALBELOW-26DEC31-36) - Current price (probability): 72.00% (live; bid 71% / ask 72%) - 7-day price change: +25.00% - 30-day price change: +38.00% - Average daily volume: 364 contracts - Price range: 26.00% - 72.00% - Data points: 114 days |
| resolution_source | FAILED | 0.2s | 1 | https://votehub.com/polls/trump-approval-rating/: HTTP 403 |
| kalshi_related | OK | 0.9s | 1 | 1 related markets / summaries. series KXTRUMPAPPROVALBELOW: 0 markets (skipped 4 no-signal) | series KXAPPROVAL: 0 markets (skipped 0 no-signal) | keyword 'Trump approval rating': ok |
| polymarket_related | OK | 0.4s | 5 | Polymarket search over 1 keyword(s), kept 5 matches. keyword 'Trump approval rating': 5 markets |
research loops
·
4/4 ok ·
16 searches ·
8 page reads
| dimension | status | time | searches | page reads | report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current state | OK | 43s | 4 | 3 | 4536 chars |
| base rate | OK | 52s | 5 | 2 | 4676 chars |
| yes case | OK | 33s | 4 | 2 | 4429 chars |
| no case | OK | 48s | 3 | 1 | 5395 chars |
report: current state
- [2026-09-24] VoteHub's polling average placed Trump at
38 percent approval and 60.4 percent disapproval, also producing a net rating of minus 22.4
, per Newsweek's report on VoteHub's Sept. 23, 2026 average. This is the most recent VoteHub-specific figure found and sits well above the 36% threshold. https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-approval-rating-all-time-low-nate-silver-12482345
- [2026-09-24] Newsweek reported VoteHub's head of data science said
VoteHub's polling average also shows Trump's net approval at a record-low minus 22.4 points, worse than any president at this stage since polling began in 1945
, indicating a record-low net rating but an approval level still at 38%, not below 36%. https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-approval-rating-all-time-low-nate-silver-12482345
- [2025-11-30] Gallup (a separate pollster, not VoteHub) reported Trump's approval had fallen to 36%, the lowest of his second term to that point, as noted in a newsletter summary: "President Donald Trump's job approval rating has fallen five percentage points to 36%, the lowest of his second term" (Megan Brenan, Gallup, via Opinion Today). This shows individual polls were already near/at the 36% line by late Nov 2025, though this is Gallup's number, not VoteHub's aggregate. https://opiniontoday.substack.com/p/251130
- [2026-09-24] A Wikipedia aggregator table compiling multiple trackers (not including VoteHub directly) showed an average of 36.1% approval across FiftyPlusOne (34.7%), Silver Bulletin (37.4%), The Economist (35.0%) and The New York Times (37.0%) on Sept. 24, 2026, illustrating that some trackers (Economist, FiftyPlusOne) were already below 36% while others (Silver Bulletin, NYT) were above it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_on_the_second_Trump_presidency
- [2026-10-01] Individual national polls have dipped well under 36% recently: an AP-NORC poll released Oct. 1, 2026 found Trump's approval at just 31%, with 69% disapproving. https://politicalwire.com/2026/10/01/trump-approval-at-just-31/
- [2026-09-30] CNN's tracker showed a CBS News/YouGov poll (Sept. 30–Oct. 2, 2026) with Trump at 39% approval, 61% disapproval, indicating divergence among individual polls even in early October. https://www.cnn.com/polling/approval/trump-polls
- [2026-09-30] NBC News's own polling average (a separate aggregator from VoteHub) showed Trump at 39% approve / 59% disapprove as of Sept. 30, 2026, again above the 36% line. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2026-elections/presidential-approval-polls
- [2026-09-29] A "List Wire"/Yahoo roundup citing Civiqs put Trump's national approval at 34% entering October 2026, with 60% disapproving, again below 36% but from a tracker other than VoteHub. https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/americans-continue-disapprove-job-president-202526541.html
- [2026-10-02] Silver Bulletin (Nate Silver's tracker, frequently cross-validated against VoteHub) placed Trump's overall approval at 37.6% in its Sept. 23 average, with net approval at an all-time low of -22.7 to -23 as of Oct. 2, 2026 — still above the 36% approval threshold even as net approval hit record lows. https://www.natesilver.net/p/trump-approval-ratings-nate-silver-bulletin
- [2026-09-23] VoteHub's own homepage confirms it maintains live "Trump Approval," "Trump Approval: 2026 High," and "Trump Approval: 2026 Low" trackers, but the rendered page does not expose the current numeric values via static fetch; the most recent reported VoteHub number (38%/60.4%) comes via secondary reporting (Newsweek). https://votehub.com/
NOT FOUND: A direct, dated VoteHub numeric readout for approval in the past two weeks (i.e., after Sept. 23, 2026) could not be retrieved — VoteHub's site renders its live averages via JavaScript/API that did not return numeric values in a static fetch. Could not confirm whether VoteHub's own aggregate (as distinct from Gallup, Civiqs, Economist, or AP-NORC) has dipped below 36% at any single-day reading since the market opened Dec 11, 2025.
BOTTOM LINE: As of the most recent available VoteHub-specific data point (Sept. 23, 2026: 38% approve/60.4% disapprove, net -22.4), VoteHub's aggregate has not yet shown approval below 36%, even though several individual polls (AP-NORC 31%, Reuters/Ipsos low-30s, Civiqs 34%) and some rival aggregators (Economist, FiftyPlusOne) have already crossed below that level — meaning VoteHub's average could plausibly cross 36% soon given the broader downward trend, but has not been confirmed to have done so yet.
report: base rate
- [2026-09-06] Wikipedia's aggregator comparison table shows
VoteHub's approval average at 38.5% approve, 58.4% disapprove (net −19.9%)
as of Sept 6, 2026 — still above the 36% threshold but among the lower end of trackers that day (CNN and The Economist both already at 35.0%).
- [2026-09-23/24]
VoteHub separately placed Trump at 38 percent approval and 60.4 percent disapproval, producing a net rating of minus 22.4
, matching Nate Silver's tracker and described by VoteHub's head of data science as
a record-low minus 22.4 points, worse than any president at this stage since polling began in 1945
. VoteHub's own average was thus still just above 36% at this point, but closing in.
- [2026-04-17] VoteHub's own polling-average thread stated
Trump's approval rating has hit a record low in our polling average, falling into the 30s for the first time, with 39.9% approve and 56.6% disapprove (net -16.7, down 5 points in 6 weeks)
, showing VoteHub's average had been well above 36% through most of H1 2026.
- [2026-10-01] Ballotpedia's own tracker (close methodology cousin) found
approval polling averages showed Trump at 39% approval at the end of September, with September recording the lowest average approval rating of his second term at 38%
, indicating cross-tracker convergence just above, not below, 36%.
- [2026-09-21 to 09-29] Individual national polls have repeatedly dipped below 36% (Reuters/Ipsos 32%, American Research Group 29%, Quinnipiac 34%, CNN/SSRS 33%, Verasight/Strength in Numbers 33%, FT/Focaldata 33%), per
American Research Group, conducted September 16-20 among 1,100 American adults, showed the president with a 29 percent overall approval rating
and
Trump's 33% approval rating is a new low point for either of his terms, according to CNN/SSRS polling
— but these are individual polls, not the VoteHub composite average, which smooths such outliers.
- [2025-11-28] Gallup (a major input but not VoteHub itself) reported
President Donald Trump's job approval rating has fallen five percentage points to 36%, the lowest of his second term
, with
his all-time low was 34% in 2021, at the end of his first term after the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol
— establishing 36% as already a historically newsworthy threshold for Trump specifically.
- [2026-10-03] Wikipedia's summary characterizes the whole-term trend:
Throughout 2025 to 2026, Trump's approval rating has steadily declined to an average of 36 to 37%
, confirming the trajectory has been persistently downward with no sustained reversals.
- [2026-09-24] A multi-aggregator snapshot (not VoteHub, but comparable methodology) already showed several trackers below 36%:
FiftyPlusOne 34.7%, The Economist 35.0%, Silver Bulletin 37.4%, The New York Times 37.0%, Average 36.1%
, meaning VoteHub (not listed that day but tracking similarly) is operating in a band where small further erosion would cross 36%.
- Base-rate read: this is not a "rare tail event" question — approval tracking is already hovering in the 36-39% band with a clear, multi-month downward trend accelerating around the Sept–Oct 2026 shutdown/economy news cycle, and several comparable, methodologically similar trackers (Economist, FiftyPlusOne, CNN, Gallup) have already independently touched or breached sub-36% readings in the same window.
- Historically, once Trump's approval trend turns persistently negative it has not meaningfully recovered within the same term (per Silver Bulletin's observation that
short-term events have produced upward movements in Trump's numbers, but none has reversed the longer decline
), suggesting continuation rather than reversal is the more likely base-rate pattern for VoteHub crossing 36% at some point before Dec 31, 2026.
NOT FOUND: I could not directly access VoteHub's live approval tracker page (votehub.com/approval) to confirm its exact, most-recent (October 2026) numeric reading, nor could I find a specific VoteHub press release/tweet stating its own average fell below 36% at any discrete date; comparisons rely on secondary citations (Newsweek, Wikipedia, Ballotpedia) of VoteHub's reported figures.
BOTTOM LINE: Across 2025-2026, Trump's approval (both VoteHub's own average and closely comparable trackers) has trended steadily downward from the high-40s/50s at inauguration into the high-30s by late 2025 and the 36-39% band by September-October 2026, with individual polls and several sister aggregators already dipping into the low-to-mid 30s; the sustained, accelerating decline and lack of historical reversals make a sub-36% VoteHub reading at some point before Dec 31, 2026 consistent with the dominant trend rather than an outlier scenario.
report: yes case
YES means: VoteHub's Trump approval-rating aggregate reads below 36% approve on at least one day between Dec 11, 2025 and Dec 31, 2026.
- [2026-09-23] VoteHub itself confirmed that for the first time its disapproval crossed 60%, with
Trump's disapproval exceeding 60% for the first time in VoteHub's polling average, and his net approval falling to a record low of −22.4 points
, the lowest net reading of either term — showing the trajectory is still accelerating downward, not stabilizing.
- [2026-09-06] Wikipedia's aggregator-comparison table (sourced from Wikipedia's tracking of multiple pollsters) placed
VoteHub at 38.5% approve, 58.4% disapprove on September 6, 2026
, with CNN and The Economist already at 35.0% that same day — confirming VoteHub sits at the higher end of trackers but only ~2.5 points above the 36% line, a gap closing fast given the September 23 drop to 38%/net −22.4.
- [2026-10-02] Nate Silver's Silver Bulletin — whose September 23 average "independently pointed to the same net rating" as VoteHub — reported
overall approval at 37.6 percent in Silver Bulletin's September 23 average
, and Silver himself noted "Trump approval now at -22.4, his low point for the term and now lower than at any point in his first term, even after Jan. 6," underscoring that VoteHub's near-twin tracker is only 1.6 points above the 36% threshold.
- [2026-09-28] A new Wall Street Journal poll found
Trump's approval rating hit a record low of 37% ahead of the upcoming midterms
, the lowest pre-midterm reading for any president in the outlet's polling history since George H.W. Bush — another high-quality national poll feeding aggregators just 1 point above the line.
- [2026-10-02] Forbes reported that in a new NBC News survey,
Trump's 36% approval rating is one point below what it was in April, a record low in the group's polling during his second term
, with a "significant decline in his support among his base."
- [2026-10-04] FiftyPlusOne's own live tracker — a comparable "poll-of-polls" aggregator — now shows approval already below the threshold, at **35.0% approve / 62.2% disapprove** as of October 4, 2026, down from 35.9% on September 6.
- [2026-10-01] AP-NORC's national poll, released October 1, 2026, found Trump's approval at just 31%, with 69% disapproving — one of several individual high-quality polls now running 5+ points below VoteHub's own reading, which will continue to pull VoteHub's weighted average down as these polls roll in.
- [2026-09-20] Verasight/Strength in Numbers (G. Elliott Morris) found
33% of Americans approve of the job Donald Trump is doing as president and 63% disapprove, a net rating of −30, the worst reading in the 16 waves of this poll since May 2025
, with Republican approval itself falling sharply — evidence the erosion is now spreading into Trump's base, a leading indicator for aggregate declines.
- [2026-10-02] Forbes/AP-NORC also found Trump's approval on handling the economy fell to an all-time low of 26%, and his approval on Iran policy tied his all-time low of 28% — compounding issue-specific negatives that typically precede further overall-approval erosion in VoteHub's model.
- Mechanism for YES: VoteHub's aggregate (38% on Sept 23, no more-recent public number found) needs to fall only ~2-3 more points to cross 36%. Given that essentially every contemporaneous individual poll and comparable aggregator (WSJ 37%, NBC 36%, FiftyPlusOne 35.0%, Economist/CNN already at 35%, AP-NORC 31–36%, Verasight 33%) is now at or below 36-37%, and VoteHub's own September 23 net approval (−22.4) was its worst of either term with no reversal yet visible, continued decline of just a few tenths of a point per week would push VoteHub below 36% well before the Dec 31, 2026 deadline.
NOT FOUND: A VoteHub-specific numeric readout newer than September 23, 2026 (38% approve) could not be retrieved directly from votehub.com or via secondary reporting; no confirmed sub-36% VoteHub reading has yet been documented.
BOTTOM LINE: VoteHub's last confirmed reading (38% approve, Sept 23, 2026) sits only 2 points above the 36% threshold at a moment of record-low net approval (−22.4) with virtually every peer tracker and individual poll already at or below 36-37% and no sign of reversal — making a sub-36% VoteHub reading before Dec 31, 2026 a highly plausible, near-term continuation of the existing trend rather than a low-probability tail event.
report: no case
YES means: VoteHub's own published approval average dips below 36% approve on at least one reported reading between Dec 11, 2025 and Dec 31, 2026.
- [2026-09-20] A tracker built directly on "VoteHub API" data (trumptimer.us) shows the newest VoteHub-sourced poll record at Aug 28, 2026 reading approve 38%, disapprove 52%, net -14% — a figure comfortably above 36% and with a narrower net-negative spread than the -22-point net reported by Newsweek for the same late-summer window, indicating VoteHub's underlying poll mix still contains readings well north of 36%. https://trumptimer.us/approval-rating/
- [2026-10-01] ActiVote's Oct. 1, 2026 release found
ActiVote's October 1, 2026 presidential approval poll finds that President Trump's approval rating is at 37.7%, while his disapproval rating is at 55.4%, yielding a net disapproval of 17.7%.
This is a stabilization signal from a poll with a title explicitly framing approval as "holding steady," not in free-fall, as the shutdown-era news cycle continues. https://www.activote.net/analysis/trumps-approval-holds-steady-as-disapproval-eases/
- [2026-10-04] A separate Wikipedia-cross-sourced aggregator (uspollingdata.com), compiled from Gallup, Reuters/Ipsos, YouGov, Quinnipiac and Morning Consult — a methodology close kin to VoteHub's own poll-averaging approach — put
Trump approval rating October 2026: 37.3% approve, 60.3% disapprove (-23.0 net)
, still above the 36% line even as net approval sits at a record low, showing that headline net-negative records do not necessarily translate into a sub-36% approve reading. https://uspollingdata.com/polls/trump-approval/
- [2025-11/2025-12 to 2026-01] AP-NORC's own national polling — a key VoteHub input — held essentially flat at the 36-37% line for months rather than cascading lower:
Despite growing discontent with his management of the government, Trump's overall approval rating has remained steady. About 36% of Americans say they approve of his performance as president, roughly unchanged from 37% in an October AP-NORC survey.
This multi-month plateau at/just-above 36%, rather than continued decline, is evidence of a sticky floor rather than inevitable breach. https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-approval-rating-polls-republicans-government-shutdown-11035070
- [2025-11-13] The same AP-NORC data point recorded via Opinion Today newsletter confirms
Overall, 62% disapprove of the way Trump is handling his job as president, while 36% approve. This is largely unchanged from October, when 61% disapproved and 36% approved.
Two consecutive months at exactly 36% (not below it) during the most acute shutdown-driven stress-test of the whole period is a direct precedent for the floor holding rather than breaking. https://opiniontoday.substack.com/p/251113
- [2026-xx] Historical-mechanism evidence from a dedicated shutdown-impact analysis: after the record-length 2025 shutdown ended,
It 43% when it ended. After the government reopened, Trump's approval fell further to 42.4% and has remained below the pre-shutdown level
— i.e., even the single largest negative shock of the term only pushed the aggregate into the low 40s, not under 36%, reinforcing that a 36% VoteHub reading requires a materially larger or additional shock beyond what has already occurred. https://pollitik.substack.com/p/how-do-government-shutdowns-affect
- [2026-10-04] Narrower subgroup results, such as the NBC News/Telemundo poll showing Latino approval at just 27%, are being reported prominently, but these are demographic subgroups, not the national topline VoteHub tracks — a reminder that eye-catching sub-36% numbers in current coverage often refer to subsets, not VoteHub's overall average. https://nbcnews.com/meet-the-press/transcripts/meet-press-october-4-2026-rcna601407
- [2026-10-04] FiftyPlusOne's live tracker shows approve at 35.0% as of Oct. 4, 2026 — below 36% — but this is a different, more Democratic-leaning-weighted aggregator than VoteHub; VoteHub's most recent confirmed reading (Sept. 23-24) remained at 38%, a 2-3 point buffer above even this low-end rival tracker. https://fiftyplusone.news/polls/approval/president
- [2026-10-05] No VoteHub-specific numeric reading below 36% has been found in any dated, sourced report as of this writing; every directly-attributed VoteHub figure located (April 17 39.9%, June 9 35% [disputed secondary mention], Sept. 6 38.5%, Sept. 23-24 38%) has stayed at or above 36% except for one ambiguous June 9 "historic low of 35%" social post that lacks a primary VoteHub citation and could not be verified against VoteHub's own page.
BOTTOM LINE: Every confirmed, dated VoteHub-attributed reading from April through late September 2026 has stayed at or above 36% (range ~38-40%), AP-NORC's own input polls plateaued at exactly 36% for multiple months without breaching lower, and the term's single largest stress event (the record-length shutdown) only pushed aggregates into the low 40s — all consistent with a resilient floor near 36-38% rather than a confirmed sub-36% VoteHub crossing.
NOT FOUND: A primary, dated VoteHub.com screenshot or API pull showing a numeric reading below 36% at any point since Dec 11, 2025; VoteHub's live site renders values via JavaScript that did not return numbers on static fetch, and the "35%" figure attributed to VoteHub for June 9, 2026 lacks a verifiable primary citation.
3. Forecasters 5 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT-6 Astra + GPT-5.6 Sol · plain mean
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
50% conf
| Yes | 70% |
| No | 30% |
(0) No confirmed VoteHub reading below 36%; last confirmed values are 38.5% (Sep 6) and 38% (Sep 23, net -22.4 record low), and the June 9 '35%' claim is unverified. The resolution-source fetch failed (403), so the current VoteHub value is unknown. (a) About 12 weeks remain until Dec 31, 2026, and only one daily reading below 36% is needed. (b) Status quo: VoteHub at about 38% needs roughly 2 more points of decline. Supporting the trend: AP-NORC 31%, CNN/SSRS 33%, Reuters/Ipsos 32%, Verasight 33% and Civiqs 34% are all low, and peer aggregators FiftyPlusOne and The Economist are at 35.0%. The Kalshi anchor rose 25 points in 7 days to 72%, implying traders see VoteHub near the line. (c) No: VoteHub runs at the higher end of trackers, steadier polls (ActiVote 37.7%, uspollingdata 37.3%) suggest a floor around 36-38%, and approval stabilises or rallies before year-end. (d) Yes: the low October polls roll into VoteHub's average and push it below 36% for at least one day. A related Polymarket tracker prices only about 5% on below 36.0% by Oct 9, so a crossing is not imminent, but the drift plus noise over nearly three months makes a single touch likely. I stay close to the market, slightly below it given VoteHub's higher-end lean.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
50% conf
| Yes | 68% |
| No | 32% |
(0) Resolution check: the VoteHub page returned a 403, so I could not read it directly. The latest confirmed VoteHub reading is 38.0% approve, 60.4% disapprove (Sept 23, 2026, via Newsweek). No verified VoteHub reading below 36% exists. The one 'June 9, 35%' mention is unsourced, and the market trading at 72% rather than settled implies it is not a real resolution. (a) About 12 weeks remain until Dec 31, 2026, and a single day below 36% is enough. (b) If nothing changes, VoteHub sits around 37-38%, above the line, so the status quo is No. However, the trend is clearly downward: record-low net approval of -22.4, and recent polls below 36% (AP-NORC 31%, CNN/SSRS 33%, Reuters/Ipsos 32%, Verasight 33%). Rival aggregators are already there too: FiftyPlusOne at 35.0%, and The Economist and CNN at 35%. (c) No: approval plateaus near 37%, as AP-NORC did at 36-37% for months in late 2025. A midterm rally effect or the end of the shutdown news cycle then lifts it slightly, and VoteHub, which runs higher than FiftyPlusOne and The Economist, never prints below 36.0. (d) Yes: the low-30s polls keep entering the average, and VoteHub slides the remaining ~2 points sometime in Oct-Dec. A one-touch condition over three months of a declining series makes that plausible. The Kalshi anchor is 72%, up 25 points in a week, which suggests traders see VoteHub moving closer to the line than the Sept 23 figure. A related Polymarket daily market (unknown source) puts only about 5% on a reading below 36 on Oct 9, with the mode at 37.0-37.4. That points to a near-term buffer of 1-2 points. I shade slightly below the market for that buffer and for the possibility of a pre-midterm stabilization.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
58% conf
| Yes | 72% |
| No | 28% |
No qualifying VoteHub reading is documented: direct access returned HTTP 403, and the disputed June 9 claim of 35% lacks primary corroboration. About 87 days remain from October 5 until the December 31, 2026 deadline—not the January 7 trading close—for VoteHub to report approval strictly below 36% even once. Newsweek's September 24 report put VoteHub's September 23 average at 38%; if that persists, assuming no earlier qualifying dip, the status quo resolves No. The YES scenario is continued erosion, supported by VoteHub's reported decline from 38.5% on September 6 and AP-NORC's reported October 1 reading of 31%, eventually pulling the designated average below 36%. The NO scenario is stabilization or recovery, with ActiVote's October 1 reading of 37.7% and NBC's September 30 average of 39% showing that the evidence is not uniformly below the threshold. VoteHub's weighting, smoothing, and publication timing could prevent a qualifying crossing despite lower rival readings, while record-low net approval is not itself the resolving metric. I retain Kalshi's 72% YES anchor, with its 71–72% bid/ask, because the research reveals no demonstrably unpriced information warranting a departure; the October 9 Polymarket contracts have a different deadline and provide context only. Missing live VoteHub data and an unverified historical minimum materially limit confidence, so this is a forecast of a plausible crossing rather than recognition of an already-resolved event.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
54% conf
| Yes | 72% |
| No | 28% |
No verified source establishes that the condition has already been met: VoteHub returned HTTP 403, Newsweek's September 24 report cited 38% approval on September 23, and the alleged June 9 reading of 35% remains unverified. From October 5, approximately 87 days remain until the December 31, 2026 outcome deadline; the January 7 trading close does not extend the qualifying period. Assuming no earlier qualifying reading, an unchanged 38% produces No, and even exactly 36% would not satisfy the strict below-36% requirement. A Yes scenario is continued erosion pulling VoteHub below 36% once before year-end, supported by the reported October 1 AP-NORC reading of 31% and FiftyPlusOne's October 4 aggregate of 35%. A No scenario is stabilization or recovery around 37–39%, consistent with ActiVote's October 1 reading of 37.7% and the recent CBS/YouGov reading of 39%. VoteHub's poll selection, weighting, and update timing could keep its published average above the threshold despite lower individual polls or rival trackers, while record-low net approval does not itself establish sufficiently low approval. I retain Kalshi's 72% Yes anchor because its reported 25-point weekly increase already reflects substantial deterioration, and the research provides no demonstrated unpriced information warranting a departure. Confidence is limited by the inaccessible resolution source, incomplete historical coverage, and multiple reports repeating the same stale VoteHub observation rather than independently confirming its current level.
gpt-5.6-sol · high effort
58% conf
| Yes | 70% |
| No | 30% |
(0) The condition is not confirmed as already met: VoteHub’s site could not be read directly, while the latest reliable VoteHub-specific figure was 38% on September 23; an alleged June reading of 35% remains unverified. (a) About 87 days remain until the December 31, 2026 measurement deadline, after which trading closes January 7. (b) If VoteHub remains near its latest confirmed 38% reading, the market resolves No because the rule requires a reading strictly below 36%. (c) No results if approval stabilizes or rebounds, as suggested by the 37.7% ActiVote poll, the 39% NBC average, and VoteHub’s apparent 38–40% floor in confirmed readings. (d) Yes results if recent low polls such as AP-NORC’s 31% and peer aggregates around 35% feed into VoteHub, extending its decline from 38.5% on September 6 to 38% on September 23 by another two-plus points. I anchor on Kalshi’s 72% Yes price and move slightly lower to 70% because the direct resolution source is inaccessible, no sub-36% VoteHub reading is documented, and the related October 9 market implies a near-term crossing is unlikely despite the longer window and downward trend.
4. Final plain mean of 5 draws
70%
(54% confidence)
Yes: 70%
No: 30%
Mean of 5 draws (0.70, 0.68, 0.72, 0.72, 0.70). (0) No confirmed VoteHub reading below 36%; last confirmed values are 38.5% (Sep 6) and 38% (Sep 23, net -22.4 record low), and the June 9 '35%' claim is unverified. The resolution-source fetch failed (403), so the current VoteHub value is unknown. (a) About 12 weeks remain until Dec 31, 2026, and only one daily reading below 36% is needed. (b) Status quo: VoteHub at about 38% needs roughly 2 more points of decline. Supporting the trend: AP-NORC 31%, CNN/SSRS 33%, Reuters/Ipsos 32%, Verasight 33% and Civiqs 34% are all low, and peer aggregators FiftyPlusOne and The Economist are at 35.0%. The Kalshi anchor rose 25 points in 7 days to 72%, implying traders see VoteHub near the line. (c) No: VoteHub runs at the higher end of trackers, steadier polls (ActiVote 37.7%, uspollingdata 37.3%) suggest a floor around 36-38%, and approval stabilises or rallies before year-end. (d) Yes: the low October polls roll into VoteHub's average and push it below 36% for at least one day. A related Polymarket tracker prices only about 5% on below 36.0% by Oct 9, so a crossing is not imminent, but the drift plus noise over nearly three months makes a single touch likely. I stay close to the market, slightly below it given VoteHub's higher-end lean.
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 133.9s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.