← back to scans
Will there be at least 3 VEI4 eruptions worldwide in 2026?
6%
Agent
7%
Market Price
-1.2%
Edge
63%
Confidence
10,829
Volume
4.0c
Spread
268
Days to resolution
3
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 5 draws (0.04, 0.05, 0.07, 0.07, 0.06). (0) The condition is not met. GVP's resolution table shows its 2026 VEI columns still blank, and no source shows any 2026-started eruption confirmed at VEI4. Wikipedia lists Krakatau's 2026 VEI as '?', and a tracker rates its largest phase (5–6 Sept) as VEI 2. (a) About 3 months remain in the 2026 eruption window. Trading closes 29 June 2027. GVP finished reviewing 2025 eruptions only in August 2026, so 2026 VEI assignments may still be preliminary or blank at close, which adds NO risk. (b) Status quo is zero confirmed VEI4 eruptions, so NO. (c) NO: Krakatau, Ambae and the others are rated VEI 2–3, or at most one or two reach VEI4, consistent with the base rate of about 1 per year (2023–2025 each had exactly 1). (d) YES: GVP rates both Krakatau's 15 km plume and Ambae's 15 km column as VEI4, and a third qualifies (Lewotobi 2026, or a surprise large eruption in Q4). That requires several independent upgrades. The Kalshi anchor is about 7% (bid 3, ask 7; last close 2%). Polymarket's sibling markets price exactly 0 at 36% and exactly 1 at 46.5%, leaving about 17% for 2 or more and implying only a few percent for 3 or more. I land slightly below the Kalshi ask at about 4%.
price vs. prediction
market price
agent forecast at t+0
15 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen:
kalshi_direct
resolution_source
kalshi_related
polymarket_related
wikipedia
gdelt_news
Planner reasoning
The Kalshi price is the anchor, and the market resolves on the Smithsonian Global Volcanism Program (GVP) database, so that source has to be checked for 2026 eruptions already rated VEI 4. Wikipedia's lists of volcanic eruptions give the base rate for VEI4 events per year and the 2026 eruptions so far. GDELT can catch recent large eruptions that GVP has not yet rated.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports)
Tools
- kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **At least 3** (KXVEI4-26DEC31-A3) - Current price (probability): 7.00% (live; bid 3% / ask 7%) - Last daily close (2026-09-26): 2.00% - 7-day price change: -20.00% - 30-day price change: -3.00% - Average daily volume: 227 contracts - Price range: 1.00% - 41.00% - Data points: 33 days
- resolution_source (failed): https://volcano.si.edu/: HTTP 403; https://volcano.si.edu/reports_weekly.cfm: HTTP 403
- kalshi_related: 1 related markets / summaries. series KXVEI4: 0 markets (skipped 3 no-signal) | series KXVEI: 0 markets (skipped 0 no-signal) | keyword 'volcano': ok | keyword 'eruption': no matches
- polymarket_related: Polymarket search over 2 keyword(s), kept 5 matches. keyword 'volcano': 5 markets | keyword 'eruption': 0 markets
- wikipedia: Fetched 3 Wikipedia entries (1 missing pages).
- gdelt_news: GDELT: 0 articles across 3 queries (lookback=280d). 'VEI 4 eruption 2026': error GDELT rate-limited after retries (429) | 'major volcanic eruption ash column 2026': error GDELT rate-limited after retries (429) | 'plinian eruption 2026': error GDELT rate-limited after retries (429)
Research loops, bottom lines
- current state: As of early October 2026, the GVP's authoritative resolution page shows zero confirmed VEI4+ eruptions for 2026 (VEI columns still blank pending review), and no individual 2026 eruption — including the high-profile September Anak Krakatau event — has yet been classified at VEI4 or higher by GVP or independent trackers; reaching "at least 3" would require multiple as-yet-unclassified or future eruptions to be confirmed at VEI4+, which historically takes GVP months to finalize.
- base rate: The long-run GVP base rate for VEI4 eruptions is roughly 1 (occasionally 2) per year, with 2023-2025 each registering exactly one, so a year reaching "at least 3" is a historical outlier (occurring in only a minority of years even over decades); sibling 2026 prediction markets, even after a September cluster of Indonesian eruptions pushed "at least 2" sharply up, kept "at least 3" pinned in the single-digit-to-low-20s percent range, consistent with this being a tail outcome rather than the modal
- yes case: The strongest YES path does not require new eruptions between now and 2027 — it requires GVP's pending review to confirm VEI4 for at least three already-occurred 2026 events whose plume heights (15–18 km) and erupted volumes (Krakatau's new 32.8-hectare landmass, Lewotobi's history of 18 km columns in the same eruptive cluster, Ambae's unprecedented 15 km column) sit squarely in or near the VEI4 plume-height band, even though preliminary non-GVP trackers have so far rated them lower.
- no case: As of early October 2026, zero 2026-started eruptions carry a GVP-confirmed VEI4 rating, GVP's own database-update cadence shows it reviews each year's eruptions roughly a year late (completing 2025 review only in August 2026), and even the market closely tracking this question keeps "at least 3" priced in the single digits even after the year's most dramatic eruption cluster — all pointing toward NO barring a late, unexpected wave of VEI4 confirmations.
tools
| tool | status | time | items | summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| kalshi_direct | OK | 0.2s | 1 | ## This Market's Kalshi Data **At least 3** (KXVEI4-26DEC31-A3) - Current price (probability): 7.00% (live; bid 3% / ask 7%) - Last daily close (2026-09-26): 2.00% - 7-day price change: -20.00% - 30-day price change: -3.00% - Average daily volume: 227 contracts - Price range: 1.00% - 41.00% - Data |
| resolution_source | FAILED | 0.3s | 1 | https://volcano.si.edu/: HTTP 403; https://volcano.si.edu/reports_weekly.cfm: HTTP 403 |
| kalshi_related | OK | 0.8s | 1 | 1 related markets / summaries. series KXVEI4: 0 markets (skipped 3 no-signal) | series KXVEI: 0 markets (skipped 0 no-signal) | keyword 'volcano': ok | keyword 'eruption': no matches |
| polymarket_related | OK | 0.5s | 5 | Polymarket search over 2 keyword(s), kept 5 matches. keyword 'volcano': 5 markets | keyword 'eruption': 0 markets |
| wikipedia | OK | 0.3s | 3 | Fetched 3 Wikipedia entries (1 missing pages). |
| gdelt_news | OK | 214.6s | 0 | GDELT: 0 articles across 3 queries (lookback=280d). 'VEI 4 eruption 2026': error GDELT rate-limited after retries (429) | 'major volcanic eruption ash column 2026': error GDELT rate-limited after retries (429) | 'plinian eruption 2026': error GDELT rate-limited after retries (429) |
research loops
·
4/4 ok ·
20 searches ·
5 page reads
| dimension | status | time | searches | page reads | report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current state | OK | 62s | 6 | 1 | 5113 chars |
| base rate | OK | 49s | 5 | 1 | 4359 chars |
| yes case | OK | 50s | 5 | 1 | 4848 chars |
| no case | OK | 34s | 4 | 2 | 4628 chars |
report: current state
- [2026-03-31] The GVP's official "Eruptions by Year" statistics page, the primary resolution source cited by sibling VEI-market rules, shows for 2026: 6 new eruptions, 47 total eruptions, 47 volcanoes active, 25 countries — but all VEI-tier columns (VEI≤2, VEI3, VEI4, VEI5, VEI6) are shown as "—" (not yet populated) because
the 2026 row currently reads: Eruptions Started (New) 6, Eruptions Ended 7, Eruptions Total 47, Volcanoes Active 47, Countries 25, with all VEI columns blank
, source https://volcano.si.edu/faq/index.cfm?question=eruptionsbyyear
- [2026-08-07] GVP's database was updated to version 5.4.0 on 7 August 2026, but this update was explicitly focused on reviewing 2025 (not 2026) data:
"7 August 2026 Database updated (5.4.0). Completed review of 2025 eruptions. General revisions to volcano information."
— meaning 2026 VEI assignments remain pending review, source https://volcano.si.edu/
- [2026-03-31] GVP's homepage weekly-highlights box still reflects March data:
"Current Eruptions (31 Mar 2026):40, Eruptions in 2026 (New/Total):6 / 47, Eruptions in 2025 (New/Total):29 / 71, Eruptions Avg 2000-2025 (N/T):36 / 78"
, source https://volcano.si.edu/
- [2026-09-04/06] The largest confirmed eruption so far in 2026, Anak Krakatau (Krakatau), produced a ~25-hour continuous eruption with ash to 15 km that closed Indonesian airports, but a specialized tracking page dated 9 September 2026 classified its largest phase (5–6 Sept) as only
"VEI 2. The largest activity of the 2026 cycle."
, source https://volcanodb.com/krakatoa-eruption
- [2026-10-02] Wikipedia's running list of 21st-century VEI≥4 eruptions lists Krakatoa's 2026 eruption with its VEI marked unresolved:
"? | Krakatoa | Indonesia | 2026 | 15 | ... | 4 | Hayli Gubbi | Ethiopia | 2025 | 14"
— i.e., no 2026 eruption has yet been confirmed at VEI4 on this tracker; the most recent confirmed VEI4 entry is from 2025 (Hayli Gubbi), source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_volcanic_eruptions_in_the_21st_century
- [2026-09-30] GDACS flagged Krakatau with a "Max Volc. Explosivity Index VEI: 6" field, but this appears to reflect the volcano's historical maximum (1883 eruption) rather than a GVP classification of the September 2026 event, source https://gdacs.org/report.aspx?eventid=1000148&episodeid=2&eventtype=VO
- [2026-09-30] GVP's Weekly Volcanic Activity Report for 24–30 September 2026 described only continuing, lower-level Krakatau activity (new islets, Alert Level 2/4) with no VEI4-scale explosivity reported that week:
"The Pusat Vulkanologi dan Mitigasi Bencana Geologi (PVMBG) reported that two small islands near Krakatau were newly visible after the larger eruption in early September... The Alert Level remained at 2 (on a scale of 1-4)."
, source https://volcano.si.edu/reports_weekly.cfm
- [2026-07-09] The ongoing 2024–2026 Kanlaon (Philippines) eruption sequence added an 8th major eruption phase on 9 July 2026, but all previously assigned VEI values for this sequence are VEI 2–3, not 4:
"VEI: 3 (2024 June eruption); 2 (2024 October–December eruption)"
, source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024%E2%80%932026_Kanlaon_eruptions
- [2026-10-02] Indonesian monitoring (MAGMA Indonesia/PVMBG) continues to report frequent small-to-moderate eruptions at Ili Lewotolok, Ibu, Dukono, Karangetang, Marapi and Semeru through early October 2026, but these are routine low-level (VEI 1–2) explosions, not VEI4-scale events, source https://databoks.katadata.co.id/en/demographics/statistics/218fec0002fd4eb/alert-mount-ili-lewotolok-erupts-again-tonight-friday-02-october-2026
- [2026-09-01] A third-party market-tracking aggregator summarized the situation as of early September 2026:
"Three or more VEI4 events are less certain due to a lack of confirmed prior VEI4 activity."
and noted regional 2026 activity at Etna and Fuego without confirmed VEI4 classification, source https://www.octagonai.co/markets/climate-and-weather/natural-disasters/major-volcano-eruption-in-2026
- [2026-01-03] A sibling Polymarket contract ("How many large volcano eruptions (VEI≥4) in 2026?") uses the identical GVP resolution page and methodology as this Kalshi market, confirming the shared primary source, source https://polymarket.com/event/how-many-large-volcano-eruption-vei-4-in-2026-657
BOTTOM LINE: As of early October 2026, the GVP's authoritative resolution page shows zero confirmed VEI4+ eruptions for 2026 (VEI columns still blank pending review), and no individual 2026 eruption — including the high-profile September Anak Krakatau event — has yet been classified at VEI4 or higher by GVP or independent trackers; reaching "at least 3" would require multiple as-yet-unclassified or future eruptions to be confirmed at VEI4+, which historically takes GVP months to finalize.
NOT FOUND: No GVP volcano-specific page yet lists a finalized VEI value of 4 or higher for any 2026-started eruption; no confirmation of how/when GVP will complete 2026 VEI classification (the database's 2026-focused update, analogous to the August 2026 "2025 review," had not yet been announced as of the latest search).
report: base rate
- [2026-03-31 data snapshot] GVP's official annual table shows recent years with 2023, 2024, and 2025 each recording only
VEI 4 counts of 1 (with VEI 3 counts of 4 and VEI<=2 counts around 22-26) for 2023, 2024, and 2025
, and in 2020 and 2010 the count was 2, while 2000 had 1 — https://volcano.si.edu/faq/index.cfm?question=eruptionsbyyear
- [2026 n/d] A USGS-derived frequency table independently used by multiple sources states VEI4 eruptions occur at a rate of roughly
"tens per decade"
, i.e., averaging somewhat above 1 but well below 3 per year — https://geology.com/stories/13/volcanic-explosivity-index/
- [2026 n/d] Another widely cited frequency table (John Seach / VolcanoLive) pegs VEI4 eruptions at about
"1 per year"
globally, consistent with the GVP annual counts of 1-2 — https://volcanolive.com/vei.html
- [2026 n/d, historical] An academic compilation of USGS-reported VEI≥4 events found
"there was no eruption of VEI 4 or greater reported between 1994 and 2000"
, illustrating that years with zero VEI4 events are not uncommon, further underscoring that "≥3 in a year" is a historically rare upper-tail outcome — https://www.researchgate.net/figure/List-of-Volcanic-Eruptions-of-VEI-4-Between-1984-and-2010-as-Reported-by-the-US_tbl1_234091710
- [2026 n/d] A volcano database compilation of 11,079 GVP-catalogued eruptions found only
754 eruptions of VEI 4 or greater, from 10,335 BCE onward to today
out of thousands of recorded eruptions, confirming VEI≥4 is a small minority of all eruptions and reinforcing the "tens per decade" (i.e., roughly 1-2/yr average) base rate — https://volcanodb.com/eruption-timeline
- [2026-01-03] A sibling Polymarket market, "How many large volcano eruptions (VEI ≥4) in 2026?", uses the same GVP table/methodology as the reference class for this question, confirming the resolution source and base-rate framing used by prediction markets — https://polymarket.com/event/how-many-large-volcano-eruption-vei-4-in-2026-657
- [2026-09-22] Following a cluster of eruptions in Indonesia (Semeru, Ibu, Ili Lewotolok) plus a notable Anak Krakatau event, a tracking site reported that the "at least 2" VEI4+ outcome on a related prediction market
surged by 66.0 percentage points, from 5.0% to 71.0%
, while
"the probability of 'at least 3' remain[ed] stable at 9%"
— https://www.octagonai.co/news/major-volcano-eruption-probability-2026/
- [2026-08-25 to 09-01] An earlier snapshot of the same tracker showed market odds of
22.0% for "at least 3"
VEI4 eruptions in 2026, versus a model estimate of 14.4%, with the tracker noting
"Three or more VEI4 events are less certain due to a lack of confirmed prior VEI4 activity"
at that time — https://www.octagonai.co/markets/climate-and-weather/natural-disasters/major-volcano-eruption-in-2026
- [2026 n/d] GVP itself cautions that
"overall volcanism has not increased, but...the apparent rise over recent decades is due to reporting bias issues, where recent improvements in communication and technology...have allowed observation of low-level activity that went unrecorded in the past"
, implying the VEI≥4 rate itself (unlike total eruption counts) has stayed roughly flat historically — https://volcano.si.edu/faq/index.cfm?question=eruptionsbyyear
- [2026 n/d] Separately, GVP's own long-run analysis states that for large eruptions (VEI≥4),
"only the larger eruptions generating at least 0.1 km^3 of tephra (VEI >= 4)...The frequency of these events has remained impressively constant for more than a century"
— https://volcano.si.edu/faq/index.cfm?question=historicalactivity
BOTTOM LINE: The long-run GVP base rate for VEI4 eruptions is roughly 1 (occasionally 2) per year, with 2023-2025 each registering exactly one, so a year reaching "at least 3" is a historical outlier (occurring in only a minority of years even over decades); sibling 2026 prediction markets, even after a September cluster of Indonesian eruptions pushed "at least 2" sharply up, kept "at least 3" pinned in the single-digit-to-low-20s percent range, consistent with this being a tail outcome rather than the modal one.
NOT FOUND: A complete year-by-year GVP VEI4 count for every year 1960-2026 (only a sampled subset of years was retrievable); an explicit historical frequency (% of years) in which VEI4 count ≥3 occurred, computed directly from GVP's full dataset.
report: yes case
YES means: the GVP's "Eruptions by Year" table for 2026, once VEI tiers are finalized, lists at least 3 volcanoes with new eruption start dates in 2026 at Max VEI 4 (or higher).
- [2026-03-31] GVP's own year-2026 table (fetched in full) already flags three ongoing eruptions at Max VEI 4 — Semeru (started 2019), Manam (started 2018) and Sheveluch (started 1999) — showing GVP is comfortable assigning VEI4 to multi-year effusive/explosive sequences; this sets precedent that any 2026-started sequence reaching comparable scale could likewise be tagged VEI4, even if activity is intermittent rather than one giant blast, source https://volcano.si.edu/faq/index.cfm?question=eruptionsbyyear&checkyear=2026
- [2026-09-05/06] Anak Krakatau's ~25-hour continuous paroxysm produced
ash that reached about 6,000 m on the Java side and a plume that climbed to around 15,000 m on the Sumatra side, accompanied by lava fountaining
, a plume height squarely in the 10–25 km band GVP associates with VEI4, giving a plausible path to upward revision from the "VEI 2" preliminary estimate once PVMBG/GVP finish review, source https://volcanodb.com/krakatoa-eruption
- [2026-09-30] GVP's own weekly bulletin confirms the eruption also built new land, noting
the continuous eruption during 4-6 September produced lava fountains, widespread ashfall, and lava flows... increased the size of the island by 32.8 hectares
— substantial erupted volume is a second VEI criterion (alongside plume height) that could support a VEI4 rating, source https://volcano.si.edu/volcano.cfm?vn=262000
- [2026-08-25] A separate, independently newsworthy candidate emerged in Vanuatu: Ambae's Manaro Voui
on August 25, 2026 threw an ash column that reached about 15 km (49,000 ft), large enough that Japan's Meteorological Agency investigated whether it had generated a tsunami
— far above Ambae's historical VEI2–3 norm and its largest event since the 2017-18 VEI3 crisis, a plausible VEI4 candidate once GVP reviews it, source https://volcanodb.com/ambae-volcano
- [2026-03-03/ongoing] GVP's table already carries a distinct, newly-started 2026 Lewotobi eruption (2026 Mar 3, continuing, VEI blank) separate from the 2023–2025 sequence that GVP's own history page rates as a VEI4 "sub-plinian eruption," confirming Lewotobi's magma system is capable of VEI4-scale output within the same recent eruptive episode cluster, source https://volcano.si.edu/faq/index.cfm?question=eruptionsbyyear&checkyear=2026 and https://www.volcanodiscovery.com/lewotobi.html
- [2026-07-05 to 08-04] Kamchatka's Sheveluch, whose ongoing 1999-eruption is already GVP-tagged VEI4, generated a fresh intensification in mid-2026 with
ash to 12.2 km (40,000 ft) on July 5 and Aviation Color Code raised to RED
, and continued producing 27,000 ft (8.2 km)-plus plumes into August, 2026-07-09 — if GVP's eventual 2026 review treats any of these high-plume pulses as a fresh VEI4-scale episode (rather than folding it into the pre-existing 1999 eruption), it strengthens the count, source https://www.volcanodiscovery.com/shiveluch/news/322772/vaac-advisory-2026-323.html
- [2026-10-02] Wikipedia's tracker, while still marking Krakatoa's 2026 VEI as unresolved ("?"), nonetheless lists its
Max plume height (km) of 15
in the same column format used for confirmed VEI4 entries like Hayli Gubbi (14 km) and Lewotobi (18 km), implying editors/trackers already judge the scale comparable to confirmed VEI4 events pending only formal classification, source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_volcanic_eruptions_in_the_21st_century
- [2026-08-07] The only GVP database update since the question opened (v5.4.0) was explicitly restricted to finishing the 2025 backlog, meaning the 2026 VEI review has not even begun — so the current "0 confirmed" count reflects a reporting lag, not a ceiling, and all four candidates above (Krakatau, Ambae, Lewotobi, Sheveluch) remain live possibilities for retroactive VEI4 tagging, source https://volcano.si.edu/
BOTTOM LINE: The strongest YES path does not require new eruptions between now and 2027 — it requires GVP's pending review to confirm VEI4 for at least three already-occurred 2026 events whose plume heights (15–18 km) and erupted volumes (Krakatau's new 32.8-hectare landmass, Lewotobi's history of 18 km columns in the same eruptive cluster, Ambae's unprecedented 15 km column) sit squarely in or near the VEI4 plume-height band, even though preliminary non-GVP trackers have so far rated them lower.
NOT FOUND: No GVP volcano-specific page has yet published a finalized VEI value of 4 for Krakatau, Ambae, Lewotobi's 2026 eruption, or any Sheveluch 2026 pulse specifically (as opposed to its pre-existing 1999-tagged VEI4 eruption); no announced timeline for when GVP will complete its 2026 VEI review (only the 2025-focused August update was found).
report: no case
YES means: the real-world outcome where this market resolves NO — i.e., GVP records fewer than 3 (0, 1, or 2) VEI4-rated eruptions with a 2026 start date by the time the contract is finally scored. (My assignment is to argue the NO case, i.e., that fewer than 3 VEI4 eruptions get confirmed for 2026.)
- [2026-09-22] Even after the highest-profile cluster of the year — simultaneous eruptions at Semeru, Ibu, and Ili Lewotolok plus the early-September Anak Krakatau event — a market-tracking analysis reported the probability of "at least 3" VEI4+ events
remaining stable at 9%
while "at least 2" jumped, showing traders see the *third* confirmed VEI4 as the much harder bar to clear.
- [2026-09-22] The same analysis explicitly cautions that "
The lack of confirmed VEI4 events makes achieving three or more major eruptions less certain
," underscoring that zero 2026 eruptions carry a GVP-finalized VEI4 rating as of late September.
- [2026-09-30] GVP's own Weekly Volcanic Activity Report for 24-30 September — the most current primary-source eruption narrative available — describes Krakatau only in terms of alert level and new islets, Marapi only as "ash plume that rose 1 km above the summit," Etna's plume as "about 4 km (13,000 ft) a.s.l.," and Fuego's as "as high as 1.2 km above the summit," none of which meet the ~10 km, 0.1 km³ VEI4 threshold.
- [2026-09-30] The same report lists Ambrym, Chikurachki, Krakatau, Marapi, Masaya, Nevados de Chillán, and Sangay as "New Eruptive Activity" for the week — a large batch of newly starting eruptions that, per the Weekly Report's own criteria, are provisional and have not yet received any VEI determination, illustrating how much pending data must still clear review before GVP's annual table can be finalized.
- [2026-09-01] An eruption at Sinabung on 31 August was still described by GVP's Daily/Weekly reports through mid-September purely in alert-level terms ("Level 3 - Standby," plumes of 500 m-1 km), not as a VEI4 cataclysmic event, despite press coverage calling it dramatic.
- [2026-10-ndr] Shiveluch (Kamchatka) — historically GVP's single most prolific VEI4+ volcano with "43 eruptions of VEI 4 or greater" on record — has erupted almost daily through 2026 with ash plumes up to ~12 km, yet no source found assigns any of these individual 2026 explosions a confirmed VEI4 rating; GVP treats it as one continuing eruption sequence rather than discrete VEI4 events, which historically dilutes rather than multiplies the "count" used for this market.
- [2026-09-22] Octagon's own market-context note states plainly that the recent Indonesian eruptions "have not yet been officially rated" for VEI, and that traders are pricing probability based on "the intensity of the recent Anak Krakatau event" rather than on any actual GVP classification — a clear acknowledgment that the "at least 3" claim currently rests on zero confirmed cases.
- [2026-08-07] GVP's most recent database update (5.4.0) was devoted to finishing the 2025 eruption review, not 2026, reinforcing the pattern (seen also in the 16 May 2026 "5.3.6" update) that GVP works through VEI classification roughly a year in arrears — meaning final 2026 VEI4 tallies are unlikely to be confirmed until well into 2027, closer to or after the 2027-06-29 close.
- [2026-10-02] Wikipedia's maintained 21st-century VEI≥4 list still shows no confirmed 2026 entries, with Krakatoa's VEI marked "?" and the last confirmed entry being 2025's Hayli Gubbi — status-quo inertia favors zero confirmed VEI4 eruptions persisting for most of the remaining question window.
- [2026-10-ndr] No GVP volcano-profile Bulletin report (the vetted, peer-reviewed long-form product, as opposed to the preliminary Weekly Report) has yet published a finalized VEI4 assignment for any 2026-started eruption, and Bulletin publication for an eruption typically lags the event by many months to over a year.
BOTTOM LINE: As of early October 2026, zero 2026-started eruptions carry a GVP-confirmed VEI4 rating, GVP's own database-update cadence shows it reviews each year's eruptions roughly a year late (completing 2025 review only in August 2026), and even the market closely tracking this question keeps "at least 3" priced in the single digits even after the year's most dramatic eruption cluster — all pointing toward NO barring a late, unexpected wave of VEI4 confirmations.
NOT FOUND: No GVP Bulletin or volcano-profile page yet assigns a finalized numeric VEI to any individual 2026 eruption (Krakatau, Sinabung, Shiveluch, Sangay, etc.); no official GVP timeline stating when 2026 VEI classifications will be completed.
3. Forecasters 5 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT-6 Astra + GPT-5.6 Sol · plain mean
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
72% conf
| Yes | 4% |
| No | 96% |
(0) The condition is not met. GVP's resolution table shows its 2026 VEI columns still blank, and no source shows any 2026-started eruption confirmed at VEI4. Wikipedia lists Krakatau's 2026 VEI as '?', and a tracker rates its largest phase (5–6 Sept) as VEI 2. (a) About 3 months remain in the 2026 eruption window. Trading closes 29 June 2027. GVP finished reviewing 2025 eruptions only in August 2026, so 2026 VEI assignments may still be preliminary or blank at close, which adds NO risk. (b) Status quo is zero confirmed VEI4 eruptions, so NO. (c) NO: Krakatau, Ambae and the others are rated VEI 2–3, or at most one or two reach VEI4, consistent with the base rate of about 1 per year (2023–2025 each had exactly 1). (d) YES: GVP rates both Krakatau's 15 km plume and Ambae's 15 km column as VEI4, and a third qualifies (Lewotobi 2026, or a surprise large eruption in Q4). That requires several independent upgrades. The Kalshi anchor is about 7% (bid 3, ask 7; last close 2%). Polymarket's sibling markets price exactly 0 at 36% and exactly 1 at 46.5%, leaving about 17% for 2 or more and implying only a few percent for 3 or more. I land slightly below the Kalshi ask at about 4%.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
70% conf
| Yes | 5% |
| No | 95% |
(0) Not met. The GVP 2026 row still has blank VEI columns. The August 2026 database update (5.4.0) only completed the 2025 review. No 2026-started eruption has a confirmed VEI4: Wikipedia marks Krakatau as '?', and a tracker rated Krakatau's September peak only VEI 2. (a) About 3 months of 2026 remain for new eruptions. GVP classification has until the 2027-06-29 close, and GVP's roughly year-in-arrears cadence means 2026 tiers may not be finalized by then, which favours NO. (b) Status quo is zero confirmed VEI4s, so the market resolves No. (c) NO: GVP rates Krakatau, Ambae (15 km column) and Lewotobi at VEI 2–3, or folds them into earlier eruption starts. Late 2026 brings at most one or two large events, consistent with the 2023–2025 base rate of one VEI4 per year. (d) YES: GVP upgrades three of the candidates (Krakatau's 15 km plume plus new land, Ambae's 15 km column, Lewotobi's new 2026 eruption) to VEI4 with 2026 start dates, or new large eruptions occur before year-end. That path needs several uncertain upgrades at once. The Kalshi anchor is 7% (bid 3%, last close 2%). Polymarket's exactly-0 (36%) and exactly-1 (46.5%) prices imply about 17% for two or more, so three or more is plausibly about 5%. Base rates make three or more a historical outlier, so I price Yes slightly below the Kalshi ask.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
54% conf
| Yes | 7% |
| No | 93% |
I anchor on Kalshi’s live 7% YES price (3% bid/7% ask), with no sufficiently verified informational edge to justify moving away. As of October 3, neither fulfillment nor impossibility is documented: direct GVP access failed with HTTP 403, the reported March 31 annual-table snapshot has blank rather than zero VEI counts, and Wikipedia’s October 2 tracker leaves Krakatau unclassified. Approximately three months remain for qualifying 2026 eruption starts and 269 days until the June 29, 2027 close, by which assessment GVP would need to record at least three qualifying VEI4 eruptions with 2026 start dates. An unchanged source record favors No, and a straightforward NO scenario is that candidate eruptions receive lower ratings or remain grouped into pre-2026 sequences, as currently reported for Semeru, Manam, and Sheveluch. YES could arise through retrospective qualifying classifications for Krakatau and Ambae plus Lewotobi or a late-2026 eruption, without requiring three entirely new eruptions after today. However, VolcanoDB’s reported 15-km plumes and Krakatau’s lava-built acreage do not establish VEI4 tephra volumes, and the candidate claims lack sufficient independent verification to make that scenario likely. The reported August 7 GVP update completing the 2025 review creates a material risk that qualifying 2026 classifications arrive after the market’s assessment window, although no official review timetable establishes this. Roughly annual historical VEI4 occurrence supports a low-probability third-event tail, but incomplete historical counts, stale authoritative data, and unresolved candidate classifications limit confidence.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
53% conf
| Yes | 7% |
| No | 93% |
I retain Kalshi’s 7% Yes anchor (3% bid/7% ask), because the research provides no sufficiently verified informational edge to justify moving away. The condition is neither documented as met nor impossible: the direct GVP read failed with HTTP 403, and the reported March annual-table blanks represent missing classifications, not a confirmed zero. Approximately 89 days remain for eligible eruption starts through December 31, 2026, and 269 days until the June 29, 2027 trading close, by which time the resolving record must establish three qualifying eruptions. Without qualifying additions or retrospective classifications, the reported record does not satisfy Yes, making No the status-quo forecast. A No scenario is routine late-year activity followed by only zero to two eligible VEI4 assignments, consistent with the sampled GVP annual counts and frequency estimates around one to two annually. A Yes scenario is retrospective VEI4 classification of Krakatau and Ambae, each with a qualifying 2026 start, plus Lewotobi or another eligible eruption. That path remains speculative: the prominent 15-km plume claims largely rely on VolcanoDB, plume height and newly formed lava land do not establish VEI4, and Sheveluch’s reported 1999-started sequence cannot simply count as a new 2026 eruption. GVP’s reported August 7, 2026 completion of its 2025 review creates material risk that relevant classifications arrive after this market’s close, while the failed direct-source check and uncertain start-date assignments limit forecast confidence.
gpt-5.6-sol · high effort
68% conf
| Yes | 6% |
| No | 94% |
(0) The condition is not already met: GVP's 2026 VEI columns remain blank, its 7 August update completed review of 2025 rather than 2026, and the 2 October tracker shows no confirmed 2026 VEI4 eruption. (a) About 89 days remain for eruptions to receive GVP-attributed 2026 start dates, followed by roughly another 180 days for classification before the 29 June 2027 close. (b) If nothing changes, fewer than three qualifying eruptions are recorded and the market resolves No. (c) The clearest No scenario is that Krakatau retains its preliminary VEI2 assessment, Ambae and Lewotobi remain below VEI4, and Sheveluch's activity remains part of its 1999-started sequence. (d) Yes could occur if GVP retroactively assigns VEI4 to at least three pending candidates, or if additional qualifying eruptions begin before year-end and are later classified VEI4. Kalshi's live Yes anchor is 7%, while the roughly one-per-year historical rate, zero finalized 2026 cases, and weaknesses in the candidate list justify only a slight downward move to 6%. Classification lag prevents greater certainty because GVP may ultimately revise events whose plume heights reached approximately 15 km.
4. Final plain mean of 5 draws
6%
(63% confidence)
Yes: 6%
No: 94%
Mean of 5 draws (0.04, 0.05, 0.07, 0.07, 0.06). (0) The condition is not met. GVP's resolution table shows its 2026 VEI columns still blank, and no source shows any 2026-started eruption confirmed at VEI4. Wikipedia lists Krakatau's 2026 VEI as '?', and a tracker rates its largest phase (5–6 Sept) as VEI 2. (a) About 3 months remain in the 2026 eruption window. Trading closes 29 June 2027. GVP finished reviewing 2025 eruptions only in August 2026, so 2026 VEI assignments may still be preliminary or blank at close, which adds NO risk. (b) Status quo is zero confirmed VEI4 eruptions, so NO. (c) NO: Krakatau, Ambae and the others are rated VEI 2–3, or at most one or two reach VEI4, consistent with the base rate of about 1 per year (2023–2025 each had exactly 1). (d) YES: GVP rates both Krakatau's 15 km plume and Ambae's 15 km column as VEI4, and a third qualifies (Lewotobi 2026, or a surprise large eruption in Q4). That requires several independent upgrades. The Kalshi anchor is about 7% (bid 3, ask 7; last close 2%). Polymarket's sibling markets price exactly 0 at 36% and exactly 1 at 46.5%, leaving about 17% for 2 or more and implying only a few percent for 3 or more. I land slightly below the Kalshi ask at about 4%.
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 252.9s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.