← back to scans
Will the temperature in San Jose drop below 40°F in December 2026?
91%
Agent
88%
Market Price
+3.2%
Edge
70%
Confidence
4,591
Volume
2.0c
Spread
93
Days to resolution
1
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 5 draws (0.91, 0.91, 0.90, 0.93, 0.91). (0) Nothing has resolved: December 2026 data does not exist yet, so at least one hourly KSJC reading strictly below 40°F must be published between Dec 1 and Dec 31, 2026. (a) About two months until the window opens, then a 31-day observation period ending at the Jan 1, 2027 close. (b) Status quo favours YES: the 1991-2020 December average minimum at KSJC is about 41.7°F with roughly 14 days per December at or below 40°F, and even the 3.3°F-warm December 2025 hit 38°F, so sub-40°F nights occur in nearly every December. (c) NO: the very strong El Niño keeps December persistently cloudy and mild, the Bay Area warm-lean outlooks for Oct-Dec and Dec-Feb lift minimums 1-3°F, and cold nights bottom at exactly 40°F or fall between hourly snapshots. (d) YES: a single clear, calm post-frontal night, routine even in mild Decembers and seen in strong El Niño Decembers like 1997 and 2015, drops KSJC into the upper 30s; the regional fire-weather outlook even leans below normal for Oct-Dec. Kalshi at 88% is the anchor; the strong base rate supports moving modestly above it, but hourly-snapshot versus true-minimum risk, the El Niño warm lean and possible missing hours keep me below the mid-90s.
price vs. prediction
market price
agent forecast at t+0
19 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen:
kalshi_direct
resolution_source
kalshi_related
wikipedia
article_search
Planner reasoning
This is a climatology question: how often KSJC records an hourly temperature below 40°F in December. That base rate is high, since San Jose Decembers usually have a few cold nights in the 30s. The Kalshi price is the anchor and the resolution source is the weather.com page. Related Kalshi temperature markets and a winter-outlook lookup (ENSO state and the CPC December outlook) can adjust the base rate, and Wikipedia's San Jose climate table gives December record and mean lows.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports)
Tools
- kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Below 40°F** (KXSJCLOWT-26DEC31-40) - Current price (probability): 88.00% (live; bid 86% / ask 88%) - Last daily close (2026-09-28): 86.00% - 7-day price change: -1.00% - 30-day price change: -5.00% - Average daily volume: 143 contracts - Price range: 17.00% - 97.00% - Data points: 32 days
- resolution_source: already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=unknown. The fetched page is only the generic Kalshi weather data portal landing page listing categories like Hourly Temps, Daily Climate, etc., with no actual temperature data for KSJC or December 2026 shown.
- kalshi_related: 2 related markets / summaries. series KXSJCLOWT: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal) | keyword 'San Jose temperature': ok | keyword 'lowest temperature December': ok
- wikipedia: Fetched 2 Wikipedia entries (1 missing pages).
- article_search: Fetched 4 unique articles across 1 queries (lookback=45d). 'NOAA CPC December 2026 temperature outlook California La Nina ENSO': 5 articles
Research loops, bottom lines
- current state: No December 2026 KSJC data exists yet (market resolves on data not yet generated), and short-range forecasts don't reach into December; the dimension therefore rests on seasonal outlook and climatology. NOAA's very-strong-El-Niño DJF outlook leaves California in an "equal chances"/mildly-above-normal temperature category (not a strong warm signal) while regional fire-weather outlooks even lean below-normal for Oct–Dec, and historical KSJC December records show sub-40°F hourly readings occurring
- base rate: Historical NOAA climate normals and NWS station records for KSJC show that hourly/daily minimum temperatures dropping below 40°F in December are a routine, near-annual occurrence (averaging ~14 such days per December over 1991-2020), and the most recent comparable December (2025) — despite running 3+°F warmer than normal — still recorded a sub-40°F reading (38°F). This base rate strongly favors a "Yes" outcome for December 2026 under normal conditions.
- yes case: The most current (Aug 27) regional fire-weather/seasonal outlook explicitly calls for below-normal October–December temperatures driven by the developing very-strong El Niño's storm track, and even NOAA's own DJF outlook leaves inland/interior California in a weak or "equal chances" temperature category rather than a strong warm lock — a pattern of increased Pacific storminess with post-frontal cold air intrusions, layered on San Jose's near-universal historical occurrence of sub-40°F hourly rea
- no case: The most locally specific, most recent (Sept 17, 2026) seasonal-outlook read explicitly favors warmer-than-normal Bay Area temperatures for both October–December and December–February under the strengthening El Niño, a stronger and more decisive local signal than the generic statewide "equal chances" characterization; combined with historical analog Decembers (e.g., Dec 2024 inland CA) showing warm/dry El-Niño-adjacent patterns can suppress cold-tail nights even at colder stations, and with KSJC
tools
| tool | status | time | items | summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| kalshi_direct | OK | 0.2s | 1 | ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Below 40°F** (KXSJCLOWT-26DEC31-40) - Current price (probability): 88.00% (live; bid 86% / ask 88%) - Last daily close (2026-09-28): 86.00% - 7-day price change: -1.00% - 30-day price change: -5.00% - Average daily volume: 143 contracts - Price range: 17.00% - 97.00% |
| resolution_source | OK | 3.6s | 1 | already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=unknown. The fetched page is only the generic Kalshi weather data portal landing page listing categories like Hourly Temps, Daily Climate, etc., with no actual temperature data for KSJC or December 2026 shown. |
| kalshi_related | OK | 2.7s | 2 | 2 related markets / summaries. series KXSJCLOWT: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal) | keyword 'San Jose temperature': ok | keyword 'lowest temperature December': ok |
| wikipedia | OK | 0.3s | 2 | Fetched 2 Wikipedia entries (1 missing pages). |
| article_search | OK | 46.1s | 4 | Fetched 4 unique articles across 1 queries (lookback=45d). 'NOAA CPC December 2026 temperature outlook California La Nina ENSO': 5 articles |
research loops
·
4/4 ok ·
17 searches ·
7 page reads
| dimension | status | time | searches | page reads | report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current state | OK | 41s | 4 | 2 | 4436 chars |
| base rate | OK | 39s | 5 | 2 | 4266 chars |
| yes case | OK | 42s | 3 | 1 | 4943 chars |
| no case | OK | 52s | 5 | 2 | 6531 chars |
report: current state
- [2026-09-10] NOAA's Climate Prediction Center ENSO discussion states
"El Niño is strengthening, with a greater than 90% chance of a very strong event during the Northern Hemisphere fall and winter 2026-27."
Source: CPC ENSO Diagnostic Discussion.
- [2026-09-17] NOAA's updated seasonal outlook (issued Sept 17, 2026, covering Dec 2026–Feb 2027)
favors above-normal precipitation across much of the southern United States, including California, the Southwest, southern Rockies and Southeast
, per Unofficial Networks' summary of the CPC release.
- [2026-08-20] The CNN/Newsweek coverage of NOAA's Aug 20 DJF 2026-27 outlook notes that while warm signals dominate the northern tier,
"above-normal temperatures are also favored across much of the southern U.S., although the outlook is less decisive in parts of California and the Southwest."
California is not in a strong "above normal" temperature category for winter.
- [2026-08-20] NOAA's precipitation outlook for coastal California shows
"coastal California, above 50 percent through late winter"
chance of wetter-than-normal conditions, with the wet pattern
"peaking in January through March 2027"
rather than December — implying December itself may see a more transitional, mixed pattern rather than persistent storminess.
- [Sept 2026, ~2 weeks old] A California/Southern-Ops fire-weather outlook (GACC) states
"The strong El Nino will likely bring below normal temperatures and above normal rainfall to the region October through December"
— a competing regional forecast suggesting near-term (Oct–Dec) cooling, in some tension with the CPC's "equal chances"/slightly-warm national temperature outlook for California.
- [historical baseline, through 2023] KSJC (San Jose Airport) December daily-average low temperatures over 2010–2023 ranged mostly 35–48°F, with several Decembers averaging a low right at or below 40°F (2020: 40°F, 2017: 40°F, 2013: 35°F, 2011: 38°F), per Current Results/NOAA GSOM data. Since these are *average* daily lows, individual overnight hours in nearly every December have dropped below 40°F.
- [historical baseline] Extreme cold events are on record for the Bay Area in December, e.g. a December 2013 cold snap where
"the lows of 29 in San Jose and 40 in San Francisco tied the marks in those cities"
, illustrating that sub-40°F readings at KSJC are a normal, recurring December phenomenon, not a rare tail event.
- [2026-09-29, today] Live 10-day/hourly forecasts for KSJC (Weather Underground, timeanddate) as of late September show nighttime lows in the mid-to-upper 40s°F, consistent with early autumn; no December-specific cold-snap forecast exists yet since skill for day-level forecasts does not extend to December from a Sept 29 vantage point.
- [Site status] The designated resolution source, weather.com/kalshi (KSJC hourly feed), is operational but naturally shows no December 2026 data yet since the month has not begun; December 2026 hourly KSJC data will only populate starting Dec 1, 2026.
- [2026-01-02] For context, NOAA's CPC noted that the prior winter (Dec 2025) saw
"multiple atmospheric rivers resulted in above-normal precipitation and flooding across California and the Pacific Northwest during mid to late December"
under a weak La Niña — illustrating that even wet/mild-leaning winter patterns in the Bay Area have not historically prevented cold, clear-night radiational cooling episodes from occurring in the same month.
BOTTOM LINE: No December 2026 KSJC data exists yet (market resolves on data not yet generated), and short-range forecasts don't reach into December; the dimension therefore rests on seasonal outlook and climatology. NOAA's very-strong-El-Niño DJF outlook leaves California in an "equal chances"/mildly-above-normal temperature category (not a strong warm signal) while regional fire-weather outlooks even lean below-normal for Oct–Dec, and historical KSJC December records show sub-40°F hourly readings occurring in nearly every recent year — together these point toward a high likelihood of at least one qualifying cold hour in December 2026.
NOT FOUND: An official NWS/NOAA point forecast or climate-normals table giving exact historical frequency of hourly (not daily-average) sub-40°F readings at KSJC in December; a December-specific (rather than DJF three-month) CPC temperature outlook; and any weather.com/Kalshi December 2026 data (none can exist yet as of today).
report: base rate
- [2026-01-01] The NWS San Francisco Bay Area office's official December 2025 climate summary for San Jose airport (KSJC) shows
record high 79°F on 12/12/1958, record low 19°F on 12/23/1990, and the observed lowest temperature for December 2025 was 38°F on 12/29
, which is below the 40°F threshold used by this market. https://forecast.weather.gov/product.php?site=ARX&issuedby=SJC&product=CLM&format=CI&version=1&glossary=1
- [2026-01-01] That same official NWS report shows
December 2025 average minimum was 45.0°F versus a 1991-2020 normal of 41.7°F (3.3°F above normal)
, indicating December 2025 was milder than average yet still produced at least one sub-40°F hourly reading. https://forecast.weather.gov/product.php?site=ARX&issuedby=SJC&product=CLM&format=CI&version=1&glossary=1
- [2026-01-01] Despite the sub-40°F dip, the report shows
days with max ≤32 = 0, days with min ≤32 = 0
for December 2025, confirming freezes (≤32°F) are rare even though sub-40°F readings still occur.
- [2025-10-16] NOAA's 1991-2020 U.S. Climate Normals (the current 30-year reference period) are the officially used dataset for airport-station climatology, including KSJC. https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/land-based-station/us-climate-normals
- [2025-10-16] Using this NOAA 1991-2020 normals data, a secondary compilation (Current Results) reports that San Jose (KSJC) averages 14 days per December with a minimum temperature at or below 40°F, and about 1 day per December at or below 32°F, out of 31 days — indicating sub-40°F occurrences are a routine, near-certain feature of a typical December, not a rare tail event. https://www.currentresults.com/Weather/California/Places/san-jose-temperatures-by-month-average.php
- [2025-10-16] The same normals-based table shows a 30-year (1991-2020) average December high/low of 60°F/42°F for San Jose, consistent with lows regularly approaching the high-30s to low-40s range on cold, clear nights. https://www.currentresults.com/Weather/California/Places/san-jose-temperatures-by-month-average.php
- [1999-04] The NWS San Diego office's "Climate of San Jose" technical memorandum describes typical winter overnight conditions:
"Mid-summer high temperatures... normally range from 80 to 85 degrees. Lows are consistently between 55 and 60"
for summer, contrasted with winter, where the same document states nighttime lows away from the bay-moderated flats "average between 35 and 40 degrees," and the bay-flat/airport zone lows "average between 40 and 45 degrees" — placing the airport very close to the 40°F threshold on an average winter night, meaning any minor cold snap easily pushes readings below it. https://www.weather.gov/media/mtr/climate/SJC_CLIMATE.pdf
- [2026-01-01] The NWS climate record period for KSJC spans 1893-2025, and the December record low of 19°F occurred in 1990, illustrating that San Jose winters can occasionally see much colder outbreaks than the typical mild "40s" pattern, adding further support that sub-40°F readings are common, not exceptional. https://forecast.weather.gov/product.php?site=ARX&issuedby=SJC&product=CLM&format=CI&version=1&glossary=1
- [2026-09-29] No explicit betting-market or expert forecast track record for this specific Kalshi contract (or its prior-year equivalent) was found in search results; only the underlying climate data and one resolved comparable month (December 2025) were available.
NOT FOUND: A direct historical tally of how many of the last 10-15 individual Decembers had at least one qualifying hourly KSJC reading below 40°F (only the 30-year normals-based average of "14 days/month" and the single confirmed December 2025 data point were available); no Kalshi/other-venue sibling market prices or explicit meteorologist seasonal outlook for December 2026 were found.
BOTTOM LINE: Historical NOAA climate normals and NWS station records for KSJC show that hourly/daily minimum temperatures dropping below 40°F in December are a routine, near-annual occurrence (averaging ~14 such days per December over 1991-2020), and the most recent comparable December (2025) — despite running 3+°F warmer than normal — still recorded a sub-40°F reading (38°F). This base rate strongly favors a "Yes" outcome for December 2026 under normal conditions.
report: yes case
YES means: at least one hourly KSJC (San Jose Airport) temperature observation between Dec 1–31, 2026 is strictly below 40°F, as published on weather.com/kalshi by market close.
- [2026-08-27] The Southern California/South Ops (GACC) Monthly/Seasonal Outlook, issued August 27, 2026 (a newer edition of the "~2 weeks old" outlook colleagues cited), reaffirms that
"the strong El Nino will likely bring below normal temperatures and above normal rainfall to the region October through December"
, directly tying the cooling call to elevated Pacific coastal sea-surface temperatures shown in the accompanying SST anomaly figure — a mechanism (cooler, wetter storm-track pattern) that favors more clear-night radiational-cooling opportunities in December.
- [2026-08-27] The same GACC outlook explicitly forecasts
"Temperatures will likely be above normal in September and then below normal October through December" and "a below normal amount of Santa Ana wind events October through December"
, indicating forecasters expect a pattern shift from the warm early-fall setup toward a colder, stormier winter exactly in the window that matters for this market.
- [2026-09-17] NOAA's September 17 CPC update, as summarized by Unofficial Networks, shows the West's warm signal is uneven:
"Warmer-than-normal conditions are also favored across parts of the West," but "Colorado, Utah and portions of the Southwest are closer to equal chances in the latest temperature outlook"
— meaning inland/interior California, including the South Bay, sits in a weaker or "equal chances" temperature category rather than a strong warm lock, leaving room for cold nights.
- [2026-09-17] The precipitation side of that same update states
"California, the Southwest and southern Rockies: above normal, the strongest and most consistent signal on the map. This is the El Niño storm track doing exactly what it is expected to"
. A more active winter storm track means more frontal passages, and cold post-frontal air behind Pacific systems is a classic trigger for below-40°F overnight lows at inland-influenced stations like KSJC.
- [2026-08-10] An independent seasonal-outlook aggregator (El Niño Guide) frames California's winter as
"Near normal to slightly above normal. Coastal areas see the strongest warming; inland valleys near baseline"
— explicitly noting that inland valley locations (where San Jose/KSJC sits, away from the immediate coast) are expected to track near the historical baseline rather than sharing in the stronger coastal warm anomaly, supporting a normal-or-better chance of routine cold nights.
- [2026-09-17] The same CPC-based summary also flags that
"The Northeast has a particularly notable combination of above-normal precipitation and above-normal temperatures... the amount of snow that reaches the ground will depend heavily on whether individual storms can maintain sufficient cold air"
, illustrating the general pattern this winter: even wetter, El Niño-driven storm tracks are not synonymous with uniformly mild temperatures, since individual storm systems still import cold air behind their frontal passages — the same dynamic applies to California's December cold outbreaks between storms.
- [2026-08-26] NOAA's own official winter outlook has not yet been released; a secondary source notes NOAA's flagship Winter Outlook "has not yet been published as of late August 2026" and is expected around mid-October 2026, meaning the most authoritative month-specific (rather than 3-month DJF) guidance for December is still forthcoming and could sharpen either the warm or cold signal. Source: https://usahousinginformation.com/el-nino-snow-map/
- [historical corroboration] Combined with the base-rate report's independently sourced NOAA 1991–2020 normals showing San Jose averages roughly 14 days per December with a minimum at/below 40°F, the mechanism above (increased storminess, post-frontal cold intrusions, inland valley temperatures near baseline) reinforces rather than contradicts that high historical frequency for December 2026.
BOTTOM LINE: The most current (Aug 27) regional fire-weather/seasonal outlook explicitly calls for below-normal October–December temperatures driven by the developing very-strong El Niño's storm track, and even NOAA's own DJF outlook leaves inland/interior California in a weak or "equal chances" temperature category rather than a strong warm lock — a pattern of increased Pacific storminess with post-frontal cold air intrusions, layered on San Jose's near-universal historical occurrence of sub-40°F hourly readings in December, makes a qualifying cold hour at KSJC in December 2026 highly probable.
NOT FOUND: NOAA's flagship October/November 2026-27 Winter Outlook (not yet published as of this research); any December-specific (single-month) CPC temperature outlook for San Jose/Bay Area; and any December 2026 KSJC hourly data (unavailable until the month occurs).
report: no case
YES means: at least one hourly temperature reading at KSJC (San Jose Airport) during Dec 1–31, 2026 is strictly below 40°F.
- [2026-09-17] A Bay-Area-specific seasonal forecast built directly from NOAA's Sept 17 CPC update states plainly:
"Warmer-than-normal temperatures are more likely in October-December and December-February, while spring temperatures have equal chances of finishing above, near, or below normal."
This is a more decisive, localized warm signal for the Bay Area than the "equal chances/less decisive" characterization colleagues found for California broadly, strengthening the case that December 2026 nights will run mild. https://www.sfbayweather.com/learn/el-nino-and-la-nina-what-they-mean-for-bay-area-weather
- [2026-09-17] The same source frames the winter rain signal as moderate, not extreme, for December itself:
"NOAA says above-normal rainfall is more likely in the Bay Area during winter 2026-27 and spring 2027, while October-December rainfall remains equally likely to finish above, near, or below normal."
A near-normal-to-uncertain December rain signal (versus a clearly wet one) means fewer nights with insulating cloud cover, but combined with the explicit warm-temperature lean, the net effect argues for milder minimum temperatures rather than sharp radiational cooling events.
- [2026-08-24] Local Bay Area reporting on this same El Niño confirms the baseline mechanism cited by forecasters:
"Usually, El Niño brings warmer weather to northern and central California during fall and winter."
This is the operative seasonal mechanism working against a sub-40°F reading occurring.
- [2026-09-23] A national explainer on the winter outlook cautions that "warmer" categorization doesn't equal a mild month outright —
"if January normally averages 35 degrees where you live, an El Niño winter might average 38"
— but this example is from the colder half of the country; applied to San Jose's much milder ~42°F average December low, an analogous few-degree upward shift would push many nights further away from, not closer to, the 40°F threshold.
- [2026-08-20] Newsweek's coverage of the Aug 20 CPC map notes California sits in a less decisive warm category, but crucially for the fall shoulder season, an Sept 17 CPC fall-specific product shows
"equal chances for above-normal, near-normal or below-normal temperatures"
only for the southern Rockies/Plains, not California — for California the September product leans warm into Oct-Dec, reinforcing the NO case's warmer-than-average expectation for the month in which December falls.
- [2024-12, NWS Hanford region, an analog inland-California warm December] The December 2024 regional climate summary (a recent warm/dry December analog for interior/coastal-adjacent California, albeit not KSJC itself) reported the month
"generally much warmer than average with below average precipitation"
and zero freezing nights at multiple stations against a multi-day average — illustrating that in a warm/dry December pattern, cold-tail events can be sharply suppressed even well inland, where cold outbreaks are typically more common than at the bay-moderated KSJC site.
- [2024-12, NWS Hanford region] That same December 2024 report tallied
"Bakersfield 52.0 +2.8 15th highest... Fresno 51.4 +3.9 3rd highest... Hanford 51.5 +5.5 2nd highest"
monthly average temperature departures, showing that a warm-leaning December (as forecast for 2026) can produce among the warmest Decembers on record even at inland stations that are climatologically colder than KSJC — suggesting KSJC, which rarely gets as cold as these inland sites, could plausibly stay above 40°F all month in an analogous warm year.
- [2026-09-10 / 2026-09-17] NOAA's very-strong El Niño strength probabilities, as compiled from the CPC's Sept discussion, show the event near or above 90-98% strong-to-very-strong through the entire Oct 2026–Jan 2027 window (per the sfbayweather.com summary of NOAA CPC data), meaning the season-long warm bias (not just a brief early-winter blip) is expected to persist through all of December, increasing the plausibility of a full month without a qualifying cold hour. https://www.sfbayweather.com/learn/el-nino-and-la-nina-what-they-mean-for-bay-area-weather
- [historical technicality] KSJC's official 1991–2020 normal average December low is only marginally below 40°F (colleagues cite ~41.7°F normal minimum), meaning the threshold sits extremely close to the average night; a modest, El-Niño-driven upward shift of just 1–3°F in nightly minimums — consistent with the "warmer than normal" DJF/OND categorical forecast — could be enough to keep every single hourly reading at or above 40°F for the entire month, unlike in colder-leaning or La Niña years.
- [resolution-mechanics technicality] Because the contract requires strictly-below-40°F on an hourly (not daily-average) basis and disregards any later data revisions, any borderline cold night that only reaches exactly 40°F, or that isn't captured due to an hour with "no reported value" (per the rules' explicit "no qualifying value" clause), resolves NO for that instance — giving the NO side extra technical cover beyond pure climatology, since KSJC's normal December low sits right at the 40–42°F boundary where marginal warm bias or a missing-hour gap could avoid triggering.
BOTTOM LINE: The most locally specific, most recent (Sept 17, 2026) seasonal-outlook read explicitly favors warmer-than-normal Bay Area temperatures for both October–December and December–February under the strengthening El Niño, a stronger and more decisive local signal than the generic statewide "equal chances" characterization; combined with historical analog Decembers (e.g., Dec 2024 inland CA) showing warm/dry El-Niño-adjacent patterns can suppress cold-tail nights even at colder stations, and with KSJC's climatological low sitting only marginally below the 40°F threshold, there is a coherent, evidence-based case that December 2026 could see every hourly KSJC reading stay at or above 40°F, resolving NO.
NOT FOUND: A KSJC-specific December 2023 (the most recent comparable moderate/strong-El-Niño December) NWS climate summary confirming whether that month's minimum stayed above or dipped below 40°F; any explicit statement from NOAA CPC of a December-only (rather than seasonal DJF/OND) temperature category for San Jose specifically; and any analog-year statistic on the number of El Niño Decembers historically that produced zero sub-40°F hourly readings at KSJC.
3. Forecasters 5 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT-5.6 Sol · plain mean
claude-opus-5-5
66% conf
| Yes | 91% |
| No | 9% |
(0) Nothing has resolved: December 2026 data does not exist yet, so at least one hourly KSJC reading strictly below 40°F must be published between Dec 1 and Dec 31, 2026. (a) About two months until the window opens, then a 31-day observation period ending at the Jan 1, 2027 close. (b) Status quo favours YES: the 1991-2020 December average minimum at KSJC is about 41.7°F with roughly 14 days per December at or below 40°F, and even the 3.3°F-warm December 2025 hit 38°F, so sub-40°F nights occur in nearly every December. (c) NO: the very strong El Niño keeps December persistently cloudy and mild, the Bay Area warm-lean outlooks for Oct-Dec and Dec-Feb lift minimums 1-3°F, and cold nights bottom at exactly 40°F or fall between hourly snapshots. (d) YES: a single clear, calm post-frontal night, routine even in mild Decembers and seen in strong El Niño Decembers like 1997 and 2015, drops KSJC into the upper 30s; the regional fire-weather outlook even leans below normal for Oct-Dec. Kalshi at 88% is the anchor; the strong base rate supports moving modestly above it, but hourly-snapshot versus true-minimum risk, the El Niño warm lean and possible missing hours keep me below the mid-90s.
claude-opus-5-5
66% conf
| Yes | 91% |
| No | 9% |
(0) The condition is not met yet: December 2026 has not begun, and the weather.com/kalshi page shows no December data. A Yes needs at least one hourly KSJC reading of 39°F or lower between Dec 1 and Dec 31. (a) About 2 months remain before the window opens, and the window itself runs 31 days. (b) The status quo is climatology. KSJC averages about 14 December days with a minimum at or below 40°F (1991-2020 normals), and a sub-40 reading happens in nearly every December. December 2025 ran 3.3°F warmer than normal and still bottomed out at 38°F. (c) NO scenario: the very strong El Niño keeps December cloudy, wet and mild, as the Sept 17 CPC-derived Bay Area outlook suggests with its warm lean for OND/DJF. Nights would stay in the 40s, or the coldest hours would land at exactly 40°F or fall in gaps in the hourly feed. (d) YES scenario: one clear, calm night after a front, which is routine between El Niño storms, drops KSJC to the upper 30s. A regional GACC outlook even leans below normal for Oct-Dec. The market sits at 88% (bid 86 / ask 88). I edge slightly above it because the base rate from recent Decembers, including a warm one, looks at least 90-95%. I discount it somewhat for the El Niño warm bias, hourly-sampling technicalities and the strict-below-40 rule.
claude-opus-5-5
70% conf
| Yes | 90% |
| No | 10% |
(0) Not yet resolved. December 2026 has not started, so the weather.com/kalshi KSJC feed has no qualifying data. At least one hourly reading strictly below 40°F must be published between Dec 1 and Dec 31. (a) The window opens in about two months and runs the full 31 days, closing Jan 1, 2027. (b) Status quo is climatology. KSJC's 1991-2020 normal December minimum is about 41.7°F, with roughly 14 days per December at or below 40°F, so a single sub-40 hour is close to routine. Even December 2025, which ran 3.3°F warmer than normal, bottomed at 38°F. (c) NO path: the very strong El Niño keeps the month cloudy, wet and mild, with nightly minimums shifted 2-3°F warmer. Every hour then stays at or above 40°F, helped by hourly sampling missing the true minimum and exact-40 readings not counting. (d) YES path: a single clear, calm night between storms, or a post-frontal cold intrusion, drops KSJC into the upper 30s for an hour or two, which happens in nearly every December. The market sits at 88% (86/88 spread). El Niño outlooks lean mildly warm for the Bay Area, while the GACC outlook calls for below-normal Oct-Dec temperatures, so they roughly offset. I stay near the market at 0.90, keeping about 10% for a warm El Niño December and hourly-data technicalities.
gpt-5.6-sol
74% conf
| Yes | 93% |
| No | 7% |
(0) The condition has not already been met: the designated weather.com/kalshi source currently shows no December 2026 KSJC observations, so at least one reported hourly value below 40°F must appear during December and be published by expiration. (a) There are about 63 days until December begins and roughly 93 days until the January 1, 2027 close, leaving no skillful day-level forecast yet. (b) If nothing changes and no qualifying observation is published, the rules resolve the market No. (c) No could result from a persistently warm or cloudy El Niño December keeping every hourly value at 40°F or above, with missing observations also unable to qualify; the localized September 17 outlook favors warmer-than-normal Bay Area temperatures. (d) Yes results from even one routine cold night, and the NOAA-normals-based estimate of roughly 14 December days per year at or below 40°F, plus December 2025 reaching 38°F despite being 3.3°F warmer than normal, makes that highly likely. I therefore move above Kalshi's 88% Yes anchor to 93%, while retaining resolution-feed risk and the possibility of an unusually mild month because the exact historical annual hit rate and December-specific forecast are unavailable.
gpt-5.6-sol
74% conf
| Yes | 91% |
| No | 9% |
(0) The condition has not already been met or made impossible: the weather.com/kalshi resolution-source page contains no December 2026 KSJC observations, so at least one reported hourly value below 40°F must occur during December and be published by expiration. (a) From September 29, about 63 days remain until the observation window begins and roughly 94 days until the January 1 expiration, so no skillful hourly forecast is yet available. (b) If nothing unusual changes, climatology favors Yes: NOAA-normal-based data indicate roughly 14 December days per year with minima at or below 40°F, and even the 3.3°F-warmer-than-normal December 2025 reached 38°F. (c) No would result from an exceptionally mild December under the forecast very strong El Niño, with every reported hourly value remaining at least 40°F; missing observations or an exact 40°F minimum would also fail to qualify. (d) Yes requires only one ordinary cold or post-frontal night, and the regional outlook calling for below-normal October–December temperatures provides a plausible supporting scenario despite conflicting Bay Area warm-seasonal guidance. I anchor on Kalshi's 88% Yes price but raise it modestly to 91% because the high climatological frequency and the warm-December-2025 example outweigh the seasonal warm signal, while retaining resolution-feed and strict-threshold risk.
4. Final plain mean of 5 draws
91%
(70% confidence)
Yes: 91%
No: 9%
Mean of 5 draws (0.91, 0.91, 0.90, 0.93, 0.91). (0) Nothing has resolved: December 2026 data does not exist yet, so at least one hourly KSJC reading strictly below 40°F must be published between Dec 1 and Dec 31, 2026. (a) About two months until the window opens, then a 31-day observation period ending at the Jan 1, 2027 close. (b) Status quo favours YES: the 1991-2020 December average minimum at KSJC is about 41.7°F with roughly 14 days per December at or below 40°F, and even the 3.3°F-warm December 2025 hit 38°F, so sub-40°F nights occur in nearly every December. (c) NO: the very strong El Niño keeps December persistently cloudy and mild, the Bay Area warm-lean outlooks for Oct-Dec and Dec-Feb lift minimums 1-3°F, and cold nights bottom at exactly 40°F or fall between hourly snapshots. (d) YES: a single clear, calm post-frontal night, routine even in mild Decembers and seen in strong El Niño Decembers like 1997 and 2015, drops KSJC into the upper 30s; the regional fire-weather outlook even leans below normal for Oct-Dec. Kalshi at 88% is the anchor; the strong base rate supports moving modestly above it, but hourly-snapshot versus true-minimum risk, the El Niño warm lean and possible missing hours keep me below the mid-90s.
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 112.6s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.