← back to scans
Will Max Miller be out as U.S. representative before Nov 3, 2026?
6%
Agent
7%
Market Price
-1.4%
Edge
73%
Confidence
137,196
Volume
2.0c
Spread
43
Days to resolution
1
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 5 draws (0.06, 0.05, 0.06, 0.05, 0.06). (0) Resolution check: not met — the House Clerk page and maxmiller.house.gov (updated Sept 10) plus Congress.gov activity through Sept 16 show Miller still serving; nothing indicates resignation, expulsion, or death. For YES he would have to resign, be expelled, or otherwise vacate before Nov 3. (a) About 43 days remain, much of which the House spends in pre-election recess, leaving little floor time for any expulsion/censure vote. (b) Status quo is NO: Miller let the Aug 9 Ohio ballot-replacement deadline pass, self-loaned $1M to his campaign, denies wrongdoing, and the Ethics Committee's 60-day window lapsed Sept 4 so no findings come before the election; Speaker Johnson, Conference Chair McClain, and the NRCC ($450k ad buy from Sept 7) are backing him, and Democrats have said their energy is on beating him electorally with due-process concerns cited by both parties. (c) NO scenario: he campaigns through Nov 3 with no new legal development, the race is decided at the ballot box, and any Ethics action comes after the election. (d) YES scenario: a sudden escalation — criminal charges, new corroborated allegations, or Trump publicly abandoning him — triggers a resignation within weeks, as happened with Swalwell/Gonzales earlier in 2026; expulsion itself is historically near-impossible absent conviction on this timeline. The Kalshi anchor is 7% (flat over 7 days, down from a 37% peak); the Polymarket Dec 31 market at 27.5% is a different deadline and not an anchor. I shade slightly below the venue price to 6% given every forcing deadline has already passed and all parties are treating this as an electoral rather than removal question, while keeping meaningful tail weight for a scandal-driven abrupt resignation.
price vs. prediction
market price
agent forecast at t+0
27 follow-ups
1. Planner Fable 5.1 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen:
kalshi_direct
resolution_source
kalshi_related
polymarket_related
wikipedia
article_search
Planner reasoning
Kalshi-sourced question, so kalshi_direct is the mandatory price anchor and resolution_source is required (no URL given; use House Clerk/official roster). Max Miller (R-OH) is a sitting congressman; resignations before an election are rare, so wikipedia gives background on his status (reelection bid, any scandals, appointments) and kalshi_related/polymarket_related check sibling 'out' markets for cross-venue signal. One targeted article_search for any resignation/appointment reporting that general loops may miss.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports)
Tools
- kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Before Nov 3, 2026** (KXMILLEROUT-26JUL-26NOV03) - Current price (probability): 7.00% - 7-day price change: +0.00% - 30-day price change: -4.00% - Average daily volume: 2858 contracts - Price range: 4.00% - 37.00% - Data points: 48 days
- resolution_source: already_resolved=no; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=September 10, 2026. Max Miller's official House website shows him actively serving as U.S. Representative for Ohio's 7th District, with news posts as recent as September 10, 2026, describing him as 'Congressman Max Miller' introducing legislation. No indication of resignation, death, or departure from office.
- kalshi_related: 3 related markets / summaries. series KXMILLEROUT: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal) | keyword 'Max Miller': ok | keyword 'representative out': ok | keyword 'resign Congress': ok
- polymarket_related: Polymarket search over 2 keyword(s), kept 7 matches. keyword 'Max Miller': 5 markets | keyword 'resign House': 2 markets
- wikipedia: Fetched 2 Wikipedia entries (0 missing pages).
- article_search: Fetched 11 unique articles across 2 queries (lookback=60d). 'Max Miller resign Congress': 10 articles | 'Max Miller Ohio congressman appointment nomination administration': 10 articles
Research loops, bottom lines
- current state: As of September 21, 2026, Max Miller remains the sitting U.S. Representative for Ohio's 7th District, has passed the deadlines to withdraw from the ballot, faces an Ethics Committee probe that by its own 60-day deadline (Sept. 4) will not produce findings before the election, and continues normal legislative and campaign activity with GOP leadership/NRCC support — all pointing toward no departure from office before Nov. 3, 2026 absent a sudden resignation, expulsion vote, or criminal charge, non
- base rate: The reference class of House members facing serious scandal shows outcomes split between rare-but-real quick resignations (when accusers are numerous/credible and GOP/Dem leadership abandons the member, as with Swalwell/Gonzales in April 2026) and much more common cases of members clinging to office through the election, especially absent criminal charges (Santos stayed ~1 year before expulsion; expulsion itself remains historically very rare, requiring conviction). Miller fits the latter patter
- yes case: The strongest YES path is continued bipartisan pressure (two Ohio GOP senators, gun-safety groups, some House Democrats floating expulsion) combined with an open House Ethics Committee investigation and reported private doubts from Trump — any of which could still tip into a resignation or a surprise expulsion/censure vote before Nov 3, though as of early September the party leadership (Speaker Johnson, NRCC) is instead backing his campaign with ad money rather than pushing him out.
- no case: All hard deadlines that could have forced Miller off the ballot or out of office (Ohio's ballot-replacement window, the Ethics Committee's 60-day report deadline) have already passed without removing him, Republican leadership (Johnson, Trump, NRCC) continues to back him rather than push expulsion, and Miller has consistently and repeatedly refused to resign — all pointing toward status-quo inertia keeping him in office through Nov 3, 2026 absent a sudden new development (e.g., criminal charges
tools
| tool | status | time | items | summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| kalshi_direct | OK | 0.2s | 1 | ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Before Nov 3, 2026** (KXMILLEROUT-26JUL-26NOV03) - Current price (probability): 7.00% - 7-day price change: +0.00% - 30-day price change: -4.00% - Average daily volume: 2858 contracts - Price range: 4.00% - 37.00% - Data points: 48 days |
| resolution_source | OK | 6.0s | 1 | already_resolved=no; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=September 10, 2026. Max Miller's official House website shows him actively serving as U.S. Representative for Ohio's 7th District, with news posts as recent as September 10, 2026, describing him as 'Congressman Max Miller' introducing legislat |
| kalshi_related | OK | 4.3s | 3 | 3 related markets / summaries. series KXMILLEROUT: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal) | keyword 'Max Miller': ok | keyword 'representative out': ok | keyword 'resign Congress': ok |
| polymarket_related | OK | 0.8s | 7 | Polymarket search over 2 keyword(s), kept 7 matches. keyword 'Max Miller': 5 markets | keyword 'resign House': 2 markets |
| wikipedia | OK | 0.5s | 2 | Fetched 2 Wikipedia entries (0 missing pages). |
| article_search | OK | 0.5s | 11 | Fetched 11 unique articles across 2 queries (lookback=60d). 'Max Miller resign Congress': 10 articles | 'Max Miller Ohio congressman appointment nomination administration': 10 articles |
research loops
·
4/4 ok ·
18 searches ·
7 page reads
| dimension | status | time | searches | page reads | report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current state | OK | 33s | 5 | 2 | 4975 chars |
| base rate | OK | 35s | 4 | 2 | 5325 chars |
| yes case | OK | 31s | 5 | 1 | 4977 chars |
| no case | OK | 32s | 4 | 2 | 5350 chars |
report: current state
- [2026-08-04] Miller requested a House Ethics Committee investigation into himself over allegations he "may have engaged in domestic violence and abuse or illegal drug use," and the Committee opened a formal review that same day. Source: https://ethics.house.gov/press-releases/statement-of-the-chairman-and-ranking-member-of-the-committee-on-ethics-regarding-representative-max-miller/
- [2026-08-09]
Max Miller appeared to let a crucial Saturday withdrawal cutoff pass in Ohio's 7th Congressional District, effectively closing Republicans' last practical window to replace the embattled incumbent on the November ballot.
Source: https://www.axios.com/2026/08/09/ohio-gop-max-miller-7th-district-moreno-2026
- [2026-08-12]
Miller, who has been facing increased scrutiny and calls for resignation amid domestic violence allegations, will remain the Republican nominee for Ohio's 7th U.S. Congressional District. He neglected to drop out by the 4 p.m. deadline in order for local party officials to replace him on the ballot.
Source: https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2026/08/12/ohio-republican-us-rep-max-miller-stays-in-his-race-with-or-without-national-gop-support/
- [2026-09-04] The Spectrum News report confirms that Friday (Sept. 4) marked the Ethics Committee's 60-day deadline, and "the House Ethics Committee launched an investigation into Miller, at his own request, last month. However, Friday marks the 60-day deadline for the committee to release its findings or recommend any punishments until after the election." Source: https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-09-04] House Speaker Mike Johnson signaled no censure vote was imminent, saying "I have supported Max Miller's reelection... He has been a great member of Congress. He has some issues in his personal life he's working through. The House Ethics Committee is looking into that." Source: https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-09-06] House GOP Conference Chair Lisa McClain stated on CBS's Face the Nation that "he's our nominee right now," reaffirming Republican leadership continues to back Miller for reelection despite the allegations. Source: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/max-miller-house-republican-conference-chair-lisa-mcclain-face-the-nation-09-06-2026/
- [2026-09-01] Miller continued normal legislative activity, introducing H.R.10213 to name a VA clinic in Medina County, Ohio, indicating he remains actively serving in the House. Source: https://maxmiller.house.gov/posts/u-s-congressman-max-miller-thanks-departing-chief-of-staff-announces-successor and https://www.congress.gov/member/max-miller/M001222
- [2026-09-07] The National Republican Congressional Committee began a $450,000 ad campaign supporting Miller's reelection, per the Spectrum News report, signaling continued party investment in his candidacy rather than a push for exit. Source: https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-09-14] Miller was still actively campaigning, touting an "A" grade from Moms For America on his voting record via a September 14 post on X. Source: https://www.mediaite.com/media/news/max-miller-whose-ex-wife-accuses-him-of-severe-abuse-touts-a-grade-from-moms-for-america/
- [2026-09-15] Democratic challenger Brian Poindexter launched a six-figure TV ad campaign centering the race on the domestic violence allegations, indicating the matter is being fought out electorally rather than resolved via resignation/expulsion. Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/09/15/max-millers-challenger-launches-attack-ad-based-domestic-violence-allegations/
- [2026-09-16] Congress.gov shows continued legislative activity tied to Miller (e.g., H.R.9500, with Senate action recorded September 16, 2026), confirming he remains a sitting member of Congress as of that date. Source: https://www.congress.gov/member/max-miller/M001222
- [2026-08-04 report] Sources describe "no criminal charges" against Miller and note the ethics process is "highly unlikely" to produce a report before November, per The Hill's reporting. Source: https://thehill.com/homenews/house/6008402-max-miller-ethics-committee/
BOTTOM LINE: As of September 21, 2026, Max Miller remains the sitting U.S. Representative for Ohio's 7th District, has passed the deadlines to withdraw from the ballot, faces an Ethics Committee probe that by its own 60-day deadline (Sept. 4) will not produce findings before the election, and continues normal legislative and campaign activity with GOP leadership/NRCC support — all pointing toward no departure from office before Nov. 3, 2026 absent a sudden resignation, expulsion vote, or criminal charge, none of which have occurred.
NOT FOUND: No evidence of any resignation announcement, House expulsion vote, indictment/criminal charges, or Ethics Committee final report/recommendation against Miller as of September 21, 2026.
report: base rate
- [2026-08-07] Miller
appeared to let a crucial Saturday withdrawal cutoff pass in Ohio's 7th Congressional District, effectively closing Republicans' last practical window to replace the embattled incumbent on the November ballot
, showing the resignation/withdrawal process for House members facing scandal is not automatic and depends on the member's own choice. Source: axios.com/2026/08/09/ohio-gop-max-miller-7th-district-moreno-2026
- [2026-08-12] Despite sustained pressure,
Miller, who has been facing increased scrutiny and calls for resignation amid domestic violence allegations, will remain the Republican nominee... He neglected to drop out by the 4 p.m. deadline in order for local party officials to replace him on the ballot
. Source: ohiocapitaljournal.com/2026/08/12
- [2026-09-04] The House Ethics Committee's own 60-day review window has lapsed without punitive action:
Congress appears unlikely to take any actions against Miller before the election
, and
Friday marks the 60-day deadline for the committee to release its findings or recommend any punishments until after the election
. Source: spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04
- [2026-09-04] Speaker Mike Johnson signaled no intent to push Miller out, telling reporters he has "supported Max Miller's reelection" and calling him "a great member of Congress" with "some issues in his personal life he's working through," while a fellow Ohio Republican suggested a censure vote is unlikely given controversy over the Democratic opponent. Source: spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04
- [2026-09-06] Even amid ongoing scrutiny, GOP House Conference Chair Lisa McClain reaffirmed backing for Miller's campaign, saying
"Divorces are ugly... I support anybody with an R behind their name... we gotta let the process play out"
. Source: sg.news.yahoo.com/house-gop-conference-chair-excuses
- [2026-08-04] Base-rate context on expulsion:
a total twenty Members of Congress have been expelled from their respective bodies—five in the House and fifteen in the Senate
(later six in the House after Santos, 2023), making expulsion an extremely rare outcome historically, generally requiring criminal conviction. Source: law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/article-1/section-5/clause-2
- [2023-11-30] The most recent House expulsion (George Santos) came only
by a 311-114 vote, including 105 Republicans, to become only the sixth House member to be removed in U.S. history
, and it followed roughly a year of scandal, an indictment, and an Ethics Committee report finding wrongdoing—showing the process typically takes many months even in extreme cases. Source: ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/politics/2023/11/30/george-santos-expulsion-vote
- [2026-04-14] A relevant recent base-rate comparison: in April 2026,
Democrat Eric Swalwell resigned after misconduct allegations, while Republican Tony Gonzales said he would retire following pressure over an affair with a former aide
, showing some scandal-hit members do resign quickly (within days) once evidence/political pressure becomes overwhelming — but that outcome required either credible sexual-assault allegations with multiple accusers or a criminal case, not just political pressure.
- [2026-04-21] Analysis after that wave of resignations noted
pushing a colleague out involves high stakes when the chamber is so thinly-divided... That leaves the GOP with a slightly larger margin -- the party can now lose two members on any vote
, meaning GOP leadership has strong incentive to avoid losing Miller's seat before the election, disincentivizing forced removal now.
- [2026-08-04] Miller has denied wrongdoing throughout and has faced no criminal charges:
Miller has not faced criminal charges related to the allegations and vehemently denied them and has vowed to stay in the race
, distinguishing his situation from expulsion precedents (Santos, Traficant, ABSCAM) which all involved criminal convictions or indictments. Source: nbcnews.com/politics/congress/jim-banks-max-miller-resign-reelection-bid-moreno-ohio-rcna591571
- [2026-09-16] Congress.gov records show Miller remains active in legislative work as of mid-September 2026, cosponsoring and introducing bills, indicating continued service in office with no sign of imminent departure. Source: congress.gov/member/max-miller/M001222
BOTTOM LINE: The reference class of House members facing serious scandal shows outcomes split between rare-but-real quick resignations (when accusers are numerous/credible and GOP/Dem leadership abandons the member, as with Swalwell/Gonzales in April 2026) and much more common cases of members clinging to office through the election, especially absent criminal charges (Santos stayed ~1 year before expulsion; expulsion itself remains historically very rare, requiring conviction). Miller fits the latter pattern more closely — no charges filed, GOP leadership publicly still backing him, Ethics Committee deadline lapsed without action before the election — making a pre-election departure a low-base-rate outcome absent a major new development.
NOT FOUND: No polling or betting-market odds specifically on Miller's departure were found; no evidence of any resignation announcement, expulsion vote, or new criminal charge as of the most recent search (mid-September 2026).
report: yes case
- [2026-08-04] The House Ethics Committee opened a formal investigation, at Miller's own request, into whether he "may have engaged in domestic violence and abuse or illegal drug use in violation of the Code of Official Conduct or any other applicable standard of conduct."
The committee said it was reviewing allegations that Miller "may have engaged in domestic violence."
Source: https://www.npr.org/2026/08/04/g-s1-137389/max-miller-congress-house-ethics-committee-investigation
- [2026-08-03]
House Democrats were privately mulling whether to force a vote to expel Rep. Max Miller (R-OH) from Congress over domestic abuse allegations, which he denies
, and analysts noted
"the mere threat of expulsion has been enough to precipitate multiple resignations this year."
Source: https://politicalwire.com/2026/08/03/democrats-mull-whether-to-push-max-miller-expulsion/
- [2026-08-06] Ohio's two GOP senators — Bernie Moreno (Miller's ex-father-in-law) and Jon Husted — both publicly called for Miller's resignation, with Husted saying
"I believe Max would be making the right decision to step aside as a candidate and resign from Congress to focus on what is in the best interest of his daughter."
Source: https://www.cnn.com/2026/08/06/politics/max-miller-calls-to-resign
- [2026-07-29] Advocacy group GIFFORDS explicitly called on the House to remove him if he wouldn't quit:
"Max Miller needs to resign now — and if he refuses, the House should expel him," Emma Brown, Giffords executive director, wrote, adding "If Republicans in Congress use their power to shield dangerous abusers from consequences it will give voters yet another reason to take away their majority this November."
Source: https://thehill.com/homenews/house/5997482-giffords-gun-advocacy-group-max-miller-domestic-violence-allegations/
- [2026-08-11] An ethics/political analyst noted that a punishment track leading to expulsion is legally possible but slow:
the House panel will consider documents, gather data, possibly hold hearings, and then decide on the appropriate level of punishment, from no punishment at all, to censure or full House expulsion, and the source "wouldn't be surprised if the investigation stretches past November."
This shows the expulsion path exists but is not expected to conclude before Nov 3. Source: https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2026/08/11/ohioans-in-u-s-rep-max-millers-district-want-action-consequences-as-house-ethics-probe-continues/
- [2026-08-04] Trump himself has reportedly expressed private doubts about Miller's viability, per Axios:
Republicans privately expect that Miller will drop his reelection bid, according to two sources, while Trump has publicly expressed sympathy for Miller but privately expressed doubts about his viability.
This ongoing pressure from the party's highest levels keeps a voluntary-resignation path alive. Source: https://www.axios.com/2026/08/06/max-miller-republicans-bernie-moreno-trump-ohio
- [2026-09-04] Despite the ethics probe's 60-day self-imposed deadline passing without action, a House censure vote (short of expulsion but sometimes a precursor to resignation pressure) remains theoretically possible per precedent:
The House Ethics Committee launched an investigation into Miller, at his own request, last month; however, Friday marks the 60-day deadline for the committee to release its findings or recommend any punishments until after the election.
Congress had just censured another member (Chuck Edwards) for misconduct days earlier, showing the mechanism is active in the current Congress. Source: https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-08-09] Miller already missed Ohio's Aug. 9 deadline to withdraw and let the GOP replace him on the ballot, meaning any future exit would now have to occur via resignation, expulsion, or (post-election) simply losing — not via a clean ballot substitution.
Rep. Max Miller appeared to let a crucial Saturday withdrawal cutoff pass in Ohio's 7th Congressional District, effectively closing Republicans' last practical window to replace the embattled incumbent on the November ballot.
Source: https://www.axios.com/2026/08/09/ohio-gop-max-miller-7th-district-moreno-2026
BOTTOM LINE: The strongest YES path is continued bipartisan pressure (two Ohio GOP senators, gun-safety groups, some House Democrats floating expulsion) combined with an open House Ethics Committee investigation and reported private doubts from Trump — any of which could still tip into a resignation or a surprise expulsion/censure vote before Nov 3, though as of early September the party leadership (Speaker Johnson, NRCC) is instead backing his campaign with ad money rather than pushing him out.
NOT FOUND: No evidence found of an actual resignation, expulsion vote, or Ethics Committee final report/recommendation as of the most recent (mid-September 2026) sources; no confirmed date for any House floor action against Miller.
report: no case
- [2026-08-04] House Ethics Committee announced it was reviewing allegations that
Miller "may have engaged in domestic violence and abuse or illegal drug use" in violation of the Code of Official Conduct or any other applicable standard of conduct
, launched at Miller's own request. https://ethics.house.gov/press-releases/statement-of-the-chairman-and-ranking-member-of-the-committee-on-ethics-regarding-representative-max-miller/
- [2026-08-09] The Ohio GOP deadline for local party officials to replace Miller on the ballot passed without action:
Miller "appears almost certain to remain on the ballot in November after a key deadline in the process to replace him passed Saturday."
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/08/09/window-closes-ohio-gop-replace-rep-max-miller-ballot/
- [2026-08-10] Confirmed Miller stays on as GOP nominee:
Miller "will remain the Republican nominee for Ohio's 7th U.S. Congressional District," having "neglected to drop out by the 4 p.m. deadline in order for local party officials to replace him on the ballot."
https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2026/08/12/ohio-republican-us-rep-max-miller-stays-in-his-race-with-or-without-national-gop-support/
- [2026-08-03] Even amid expulsion talk, Democratic leadership prioritized beating Miller electorally over removing him:
a Democratic leadership source suggested the party's energy is primarily focused on helping Democrat Brian Poindexter unseat Miller in November rather than expelling him before then, and lawmakers cautioned there was "no real prospect of action before September."
https://www.axios.com/2026/08/03/max-miller-expel-congress-democrats-allegations
- [2026-08-03] Both parties cited due-process concerns as a barrier to fast action:
a senior House Democrat said "due process" concerns make penalizing Miller a "sensitive issue," and Republicans "have also raised due process concerns, with several GOP lawmakers telling Axios not to expect any immediate action from their side against Miller."
https://www.axios.com/2026/08/03/max-miller-expel-congress-democrats-allegations
- [2026-09-04] The Ethics Committee's 60-day self-imposed deadline passed with no findings before the election:
Congress appears unlikely to take any actions against Miller before the election; the House Ethics Committee launched an investigation into Miller, at his own request, last month, and Friday marked the 60-day deadline for the committee to release its findings or recommend any punishments — pushing action until after the election.
https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-09-04] Speaker Johnson signaled no censure vote imminent and continued backing Miller:
House Speaker Mike Johnson this week suggested no censure vote was imminent for Miller, saying "I have supported Max Miller's reelection... He has been a great member of Congress. He has some issues in his personal life he's working through. The House Ethics Committee is looking into that and any implications it may have."
https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-09-04] Ohio GOP Rep. Michael Rulli suggested a censure vote is now less likely given new allegations against Miller's Democratic opponent. https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-09-04] National GOP is investing in Miller's campaign rather than distancing itself: the NRCC agreed to a $450,000 ad campaign for Miller beginning Sept. 7, 2026. https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2026/09/04/ethics-censure-max-miller
- [2026-08-04] Despite numerous GOP senators (Husted, Sheehy, Banks, Marshall, Britt) and Bernie Moreno publicly urging Miller to resign,
Miller has said he intends to stay in the race for the northeast Ohio seat, but has faced pressure to dropout
, and no House Republican has publicly demanded his resignation or an expulsion vote as of the most recent reporting. https://www.npr.org/2026/08/04/g-s1-137389/max-miller-congress-house-ethics-committee-investigation
- [2026-08-10] Miller has repeatedly denied wrongdoing and vowed to fight the allegations rather than step down, self-funding his campaign with a $1 million personal loan. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/08/10/max-miller-remains-gop-nominee-ohio-house-race/
- [2026-09-01] Miller's office continues normal congressional business (e.g., introducing legislation, VA clinic naming bill), indicating no interruption to his sitting service as of early September 2026. https://maxmiller.house.gov/
BOTTOM LINE: All hard deadlines that could have forced Miller off the ballot or out of office (Ohio's ballot-replacement window, the Ethics Committee's 60-day report deadline) have already passed without removing him, Republican leadership (Johnson, Trump, NRCC) continues to back him rather than push expulsion, and Miller has consistently and repeatedly refused to resign — all pointing toward status-quo inertia keeping him in office through Nov 3, 2026 absent a sudden new development (e.g., criminal charges or an unexpected expulsion vote).
NOT FOUND: No evidence of any criminal charges filed against Miller, no scheduled House floor vote on expulsion or censure, and no indication of any resignation announcement as of the most recent (September 2026) reporting.
3. Forecasters 5 draws · Fable 5.1 + GPT-5.6 Sol · plain mean
claude-fable-5-1
66% conf
| Yes | 6% |
| No | 94% |
(0) Resolution check: not met — the House Clerk page and maxmiller.house.gov (updated Sept 10) plus Congress.gov activity through Sept 16 show Miller still serving; nothing indicates resignation, expulsion, or death. For YES he would have to resign, be expelled, or otherwise vacate before Nov 3. (a) About 43 days remain, much of which the House spends in pre-election recess, leaving little floor time for any expulsion/censure vote. (b) Status quo is NO: Miller let the Aug 9 Ohio ballot-replacement deadline pass, self-loaned $1M to his campaign, denies wrongdoing, and the Ethics Committee's 60-day window lapsed Sept 4 so no findings come before the election; Speaker Johnson, Conference Chair McClain, and the NRCC ($450k ad buy from Sept 7) are backing him, and Democrats have said their energy is on beating him electorally with due-process concerns cited by both parties. (c) NO scenario: he campaigns through Nov 3 with no new legal development, the race is decided at the ballot box, and any Ethics action comes after the election. (d) YES scenario: a sudden escalation — criminal charges, new corroborated allegations, or Trump publicly abandoning him — triggers a resignation within weeks, as happened with Swalwell/Gonzales earlier in 2026; expulsion itself is historically near-impossible absent conviction on this timeline. The Kalshi anchor is 7% (flat over 7 days, down from a 37% peak); the Polymarket Dec 31 market at 27.5% is a different deadline and not an anchor. I shade slightly below the venue price to 6% given every forcing deadline has already passed and all parties are treating this as an electoral rather than removal question, while keeping meaningful tail weight for a scandal-driven abrupt resignation.
claude-fable-5-1
72% conf
| Yes | 5% |
| No | 95% |
(0) Resolution check: the resolution source (clerk.house.gov and maxmiller.house.gov, updated Sept 10) and congress.gov activity through Sept 16 show Miller still serving; nothing indicates resignation, expulsion, or death, so the condition is unmet and would require a departure in the next ~6 weeks. (a) Roughly 43 days remain until the Nov 3 close. (b) Status quo is NO: Miller has passed every forcing deadline (Aug 9 Ohio ballot-replacement window, Sept 4 Ethics Committee 60-day report deadline), has repeatedly refused to resign despite calls from Moreno, Husted and other GOP senators, faces no criminal charges, and is backed by Speaker Johnson, Conference Chair McClain, and a $450k NRCC ad buy starting Sept 7. (c) NO scenario: he campaigns through Election Day while the ethics probe sits until after November, Democrats fight him electorally via Poindexter's ads rather than an expulsion vote, and he remains in office on Nov 3. (d) YES scenario: a sudden new development—criminal charges, a damaging new accuser, or Trump publicly abandoning him—triggers a resignation, or Democrats force a privileged expulsion vote that unexpectedly draws enough GOP support; both are possible but historically rare (expulsion has essentially required indictment/conviction) and would need to happen quickly. The Kalshi anchor is 7% and has drifted down 4 points over 30 days; the Polymarket 'out by Dec 31' market at 27.5% is a different deadline and not an anchor. I shade slightly below the venue price to 5% because the concrete forcing mechanisms have all lapsed and the research surfaces no pending action, while retaining tail risk for a surprise resignation or charge.
claude-fable-5-1
66% conf
| Yes | 6% |
| No | 94% |
(0) Resolution check: the resolution source (clerk.house.gov and maxmiller.house.gov, last updated Sept 10) and congress.gov activity through Sept 16 show Miller still serving; no resignation, expulsion, or indictment has occurred, so YES would still require a departure between now and Nov 3. (a) About six weeks remain until the Nov 3 close. (b) Status quo is NO: Miller has passed the Ohio ballot-replacement deadline (Aug 9-10), the Ethics Committee's 60-day window lapsed Sept 4 with action deferred until after the election, Speaker Johnson and Conference Chair McClain publicly back him, the NRCC is spending $450k on his race, and he is self-funding and actively campaigning. (c) NO scenario: Miller keeps campaigning through Election Day, the ethics probe stays dormant, and the contest is decided by voters on Nov 3 — the clear modal path. (d) YES scenario: a sudden new development (criminal charges, new accusers, a Trump-driven collapse of GOP support) triggers a resignation, or Democrats force a surprise expulsion vote that GOP defections carry — possible but no expulsion in House history has occurred without a criminal case or ethics report, and no floor action is scheduled. The Kalshi anchor is 7% (down from a 37% peak, flat over 7 days); the Polymarket Dec 31 market at 27.5% covers post-election exit and is context only. I shade slightly below the anchor to 6% because every forcing mechanism has already lapsed and leadership has moved toward supporting rather than pushing him out, while keeping tail room for a shock resignation.
gpt-5.6-sol
82% conf
| Yes | 5% |
| No | 95% |
(0) The condition has not already been met: the House Clerk and Miller’s official House website still show him serving, while Congress.gov records activity through September 16 and no source reports a resignation, expulsion, or death. (a) About 43 days remain until the November 3, 2026 deadline, so Yes still requires Miller to leave office during a short window. (b) If nothing changes, he remains the representative and the market resolves No; he is actively campaigning, missed the ballot-replacement deadline, and retains support from Speaker Johnson and a $450,000 NRCC ad campaign. (c) A No scenario is that the Ethics Committee continues its review beyond the election, leadership avoids action, and Miller follows through on his repeated refusal to resign. (d) A Yes scenario would require a major new development—such as criminal charges, compelling new evidence that collapses GOP support, a surprise expulsion vote, or a voluntary resignation. Kalshi’s 7% Yes price is the primary anchor, but I shade it to 5% because the September evidence shows continued official activity and party backing, while the Ethics Committee’s pre-election action window passed without findings and House expulsion is exceptionally rare.
gpt-5.6-sol
79% conf
| Yes | 6% |
| No | 94% |
(0) The condition has not already been met: the House Clerk, Miller's official website, and Congress.gov activity through September 16 show him still serving, with no resignation, expulsion, or criminal charge reported. (a) About 43 days remain until the November 3 deadline, so a resignation, death, or House expulsion would need to occur during that short window. (b) If nothing changes, Miller remains representative and the market resolves No. (c) The No scenario is continued status-quo inertia: Miller keeps campaigning, GOP leadership and the NRCC maintain support, and the Ethics Committee takes no pre-election action after its September deadline passed without findings. (d) A Yes scenario would require a major new allegation, criminal charge, or abrupt loss of party support that induces resignation, with expulsion less plausible given its rarity and the lack of a scheduled vote. Kalshi's current Yes price is 7%, and I move slightly below it because the latest specific evidence includes continued legislative activity, a $450,000 NRCC campaign commitment, Speaker Johnson's support, and Miller's decision to remain after the replaceable-ballot deadline. The open ethics investigation and resignation demands from both Ohio senators preserve a meaningful tail risk, preventing a lower Yes estimate.
4. Final plain mean of 5 draws
6%
(73% confidence)
Yes: 6%
No: 94%
Mean of 5 draws (0.06, 0.05, 0.06, 0.05, 0.06). (0) Resolution check: not met — the House Clerk page and maxmiller.house.gov (updated Sept 10) plus Congress.gov activity through Sept 16 show Miller still serving; nothing indicates resignation, expulsion, or death. For YES he would have to resign, be expelled, or otherwise vacate before Nov 3. (a) About 43 days remain, much of which the House spends in pre-election recess, leaving little floor time for any expulsion/censure vote. (b) Status quo is NO: Miller let the Aug 9 Ohio ballot-replacement deadline pass, self-loaned $1M to his campaign, denies wrongdoing, and the Ethics Committee's 60-day window lapsed Sept 4 so no findings come before the election; Speaker Johnson, Conference Chair McClain, and the NRCC ($450k ad buy from Sept 7) are backing him, and Democrats have said their energy is on beating him electorally with due-process concerns cited by both parties. (c) NO scenario: he campaigns through Nov 3 with no new legal development, the race is decided at the ballot box, and any Ethics action comes after the election. (d) YES scenario: a sudden escalation — criminal charges, new corroborated allegations, or Trump publicly abandoning him — triggers a resignation within weeks, as happened with Swalwell/Gonzales earlier in 2026; expulsion itself is historically near-impossible absent conviction on this timeline. The Kalshi anchor is 7% (flat over 7 days, down from a 37% peak); the Polymarket Dec 31 market at 27.5% is a different deadline and not an anchor. I shade slightly below the venue price to 6% given every forcing deadline has already passed and all parties are treating this as an electoral rather than removal question, while keeping meaningful tail weight for a scandal-driven abrupt resignation.
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 81.7s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.