forecasting
agent
← back to metaculus scans

Who will be awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize?

post 45383·question 45572·multiple_choice·metaculus-cup-fall-2026·2026-09-07T18:09:57.394072·view on metaculus ↗
Other individual
Top option (36%)
weighted_average
Fermi logic
politics
Domain

Plan 37.69s

Use the org/individual base rate and the historical 'favorite hit rate' to set a large prior mass on 'Other individual'/'Other organization', then distribute the remaining mass across named options in proportion to current market odds and expert shortlists, discounting Trump heavily for committee-tendency reasons and boosting candidates aligned with the 2025-26 dominant themes (Sudan, Gaza, press freedom, democracy).

Sub-questions (4)

sq1
Will the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize be awarded to an organization (rather than solely to individuals)?
Roughly 30% of prizes go to organizations historically; organizational favorites (UNRWA, Sudan Emergency Response Rooms, ICJ/ICC, RSF, CPJ, UN agencies) are perennial shortlist entries, and this split determines whether 'Other organization' or a named org option is live.
w=0.25
sq2
Will the 2026 laureate be the pre-announcement betting-market favorite or appear on the PRIO director's shortlist / top-5 of oddsmakers?
Historically the eventual laureate is on prediction lists only ~30-40% of the time (2025 Machado was a favorite; 2024 Nihon Hidankyo was not; 2023 Mohammadi was). This calibrates how much weight to put on named options vs 'Other'.
w=0.30
sq3
Will Donald Trump be awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize?
Trump is the most heavily discussed candidate given Gaza ceasefire and other diplomatic claims, yet the Norwegian committee's institutional tendencies (rule-of-law, multilateralism) make this unlikely; nonetheless he likely carries large market weight and must be explicitly assessed.
w=0.20
sq4
Will the 2026 prize relate primarily to one of the headline conflicts/themes of 2025-26 (Sudan, Gaza/Middle East, Ukraine/Russia, press freedom, or democracy defenders)?
The committee often signals on the year's dominant crises; identifying the thematic direction narrows the plausible laureate pool among named options (e.g., Sudanese ERRs, Navalnaya, UNRWA, RSF) versus a surprise nuclear-disarmament or humanitarian pick.
w=0.25

Tool requests (4)

wikipedia_lookup sq1, sq2, sq4 {"queries": ["2026 Nobel Peace Prize", "List of Nobel Peace Prize laureates", "2025 Nobel Peace Prize", "Norwegian Nobel Committee"]}
claude_news sq2, sq3, sq4 {"brief": "Find the latest 2026 Nobel Peace Prize speculation: current betting odds (Polymarket, Kalshi, bookmakers) and implied favorites, the PRIO director Nina Graeger\u0027s shortlist, Henrik Urdal/other expert predictions, Norwegian Nobel Committee composition and any statements, and reporting on Donald Trump\u0027s candidacy prospects. List the top 8-10 named candidates with approximate probabilities.", "max_searches": 5, "question_title": "Who will be awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize?"}
article_search sq2, sq3, sq4 {"lookback_days": 60, "queries": ["Nobel Peace Prize 2026 favorites odds", "Nobel Peace Prize Trump nomination committee", "Nobel Peace Prize 2026 shortlist PRIO Sudan UNRWA"]}
code_execution sq1, sq2, sq3 {"code": "import numpy as np\n# Laureate type 2000-2025: 1=org involved, 0=individual-only\nrecent = {2000:0,2001:1,2002:0,2003:0,2004:0,2005:1,2006:1,2007:1,2008:0,2009:0,2010:0,2011:0,2012:1,2013:1,2014:0,2015:1,2016:0,2017:1,2018:0,2019:0,2020:1,2021:0,2022:1,2023:0,2024:1,2025:0}\nvals=np.array(list(recent.values()))\nprint(\u0027Org share 2000-2025:\u0027, vals.mean(), \u0027n=\u0027,len(vals))\nprint(\u0027Org share all-time approx:\u0027, 31/143, \u0027prizes with org approx:\u0027, 31/106)\n# Sitting heads of state/government winning (approx list): Roosevelt 1906, Wilson 1919, Sadat/Begin 1978, Arias 1987, Gorbachev 1990, Kim Dae-jung 2000, Obama 2009, Abiy 2019, Santos 2016, de Klerk/Mandela 1993\nprint(\u0027Sitting leader wins ~10-12 of 106 prizes:\u0027, 11/106)\n# Favorite hit rate: 2015 no,2016 no,2017 no,2018 partial(Murad yes),2019 no,2020 no,2021 no,2022 partial,2023 yes,2024 no,2025 yes\nhits=np.array([0,0,0,0.5,0,0,0,0.5,1,0,1])\nprint(\u0027Bookmaker top-5 hit rate 2015-2025 approx:\u0027, hits.mean())\n# Bayesian shrink: with ~35% chance laureate is on typical lists, remaining mass to Other\nfor p_list in [0.3,0.4,0.5]:\n print(\u0027P(on list)\u0027,p_list,\u0027-\u003e P(Other individual+Other org) ~\u0027,1-p_list)", "description": "Base rates from Nobel Peace Prize history: share of prizes to organizations vs individuals (all-time and last 25 years), share to sitting heads of state/government, and rough historical hit rate of pre-announcement favorites."}

Research 46.55s · 4 tool(s) · 0 error(s)

wikipedia_lookup ok 3 pages 1.64s
claude_news ok 20 citations 46.55s
article_search ok 29 articles 0.43s
code_execution ok Base rates from Nobel Peace Prize history: share of prizes t 0.18s
Cross-market signals
## Cross-Market Signals

### No signal found

Evidence Synthesis 37.44s · 12 items

Direction mix: UP 1 DOWN 2 NEUTRAL 9
sq1 code_execution STRONG cred 85 NEUTRAL DATED
Organizations received roughly 42% of Peace Prizes from 2000-2025, versus ~22-29% across the prize's full history.
sq1 question_description MODERATE cred 90 NEUTRAL DATED
Of 287 nominees for 2026, 79 (28%) are organizations and 208 are individuals.
sq1 wikipedia_lookup MODERATE cred 95 NEUTRAL DATED
The 2025 prize went to an individual, María Corina Machado, cited for civilian courage in Latin America.
sq2 code_execution MODERATE cred 70 DOWN DATED
Bookmaker top-5 favorites contained the eventual laureate only ~27% of the time from 2015-2025.
sq2 article_search WEAK cred 40 NEUTRAL VERY_RECENT
Article search (Jul-Sep 2026) returned no coverage of 2026 Nobel Peace Prize shortlists, PRIO picks, or bookmaker odds.
sq3 code_execution MODERATE cred 75 NEUTRAL DATED
Sitting heads of state or government have won roughly 10% of all Peace Prizes historically.
sq3 article_search STRONG cred 85 DOWN RECENT
The US completed nine consecutive nights of strikes on Iran in July 2026; Iran launched drones at Kuwait, Bahrain, Jordan.
sq3 article_search MODERATE cred 75 NEUTRAL RECENT
Trump received FIFA's inaugural Peace Prize before the World Cup, a decision reported as triggering widespread international ridicule.
sq3 article_search MODERATE cred 75 NEUTRAL RECENT
2025 laureate Machado gifted Trump her Nobel medal before US military action against Maduro; Venezuelan opposition was later largely sidelined.
sq3 article_search WEAK cred 70 NEUTRAL RECENT
US Ambassador Rose cut all contact with Poland's parliamentary speaker for saying Trump did not deserve the Nobel Peace Prize.
sq4 article_search MODERATE cred 85 UP RECENT
Russia launched one of its largest ballistic missile attacks on Kyiv in July 2026 amid escalating Russia-Ukraine conflict.
sq4 article_search WEAK cred 60 NEUTRAL RECENT
Trump's foreign policy is characterized by CNN as transactional ('get America paid'), including opaque Venezuelan oil arrangements.

Information gaps

Key uncertainties

Forecast 32.54s · opus, secondary

Rationale

(a) The prize is announced October 9, 2026, so only a few weeks/months remain; the nomination pool (287 candidates) is fixed and the committee's deliberations are largely complete. (b) The status quo outcome is an unheralded laureate: historically the bookmaker/expert top-5 contains the winner only ~27-40% of the time, so 'Other individual' (with ~58-70% of prizes going to individuals) is the single most likely bucket, followed by 'Other organization' given the ~42% recent organizational share. (c) A surprising but plausible outcome would be Donald Trump—heavily lobbied and discussed—but nine consecutive nights of US strikes on Iran in July 2026, transactional foreign policy, and the committee's traditional aversion to rewarding coercive great-power leaders make this unlikely despite the FIFA prize and Machado's medal gift. Among named options, the Sudan Emergency Response Rooms fit the committee's pattern of spotlighting neglected humanitarian crises via grassroots actors, UNRWA/ICC-ICJ fit a 'defend international law' theme but are politically fraught, and Navalnaya, Pope Leo XIV, and Kuleba are plausible but face either repeat-theme (Russia dissent already awarded 2021-22) or institutional headwinds. MSF and Save the Children are prior or near-prior winners, lowering their odds. I keep modest floors on all named options given real uncertainty about late-breaking peace deals (Iran, Ukraine, Gaza).
Evidence brief shown to forecaster
1. [sq1 | code_execution | STRONG cred 85 | NEUTRAL | DATED] Organizations received roughly 42% of Peace Prizes from 2000-2025, versus ~22-29% across the prize's full history.
2. [sq1 | question_description | MODERATE cred 90 | NEUTRAL | DATED] Of 287 nominees for 2026, 79 (28%) are organizations and 208 are individuals.
3. [sq1 | wikipedia_lookup | MODERATE cred 95 | NEUTRAL | DATED] The 2025 prize went to an individual, María Corina Machado, cited for civilian courage in Latin America.
4. [sq2 | code_execution | MODERATE cred 70 | DOWN | DATED] Bookmaker top-5 favorites contained the eventual laureate only ~27% of the time from 2015-2025.
5. [sq2 | article_search | WEAK cred 40 | NEUTRAL | VERY_RECENT] Article search (Jul-Sep 2026) returned no coverage of 2026 Nobel Peace Prize shortlists, PRIO picks, or bookmaker odds.
6. [sq3 | code_execution | MODERATE cred 75 | NEUTRAL | DATED] Sitting heads of state or government have won roughly 10% of all Peace Prizes historically.
7. [sq3 | article_search | STRONG cred 85 | DOWN | RECENT] The US completed nine consecutive nights of strikes on Iran in July 2026; Iran launched drones at Kuwait, Bahrain, Jordan.
8. [sq3 | article_search | MODERATE cred 75 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] Trump received FIFA's inaugural Peace Prize before the World Cup, a decision reported as triggering widespread international ridicule.
9. [sq3 | article_search | MODERATE cred 75 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] 2025 laureate Machado gifted Trump her Nobel medal before US military action against Maduro; Venezuelan opposition was later largely sidelined.
10. [sq3 | article_search | WEAK cred 70 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] US Ambassador Rose cut all contact with Poland's parliamentary speaker for saying Trump did not deserve the Nobel Peace Prize.
11. [sq4 | article_search | MODERATE cred 85 | UP | RECENT] Russia launched one of its largest ballistic missile attacks on Kyiv in July 2026 amid escalating Russia-Ukraine conflict.
12. [sq4 | article_search | WEAK cred 60 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] Trump's foreign policy is characterized by CNN as transactional ('get America paid'), including opaque Venezuelan oil arrangements.

## Cross-Market Signals

### No signal found

Information gaps:
  - No current 2026 betting odds or Polymarket/Kalshi favorites
  - No PRIO director shortlist or expert speculation for 2026
  - No status update on Sudan, Gaza ceasefire, or press-freedom candidates
  - No data on Norwegian Nobel Committee statements or composition changes

Key uncertainties:
  - Whether any major peace deal (Iran, Ukraine, Gaza) is concluded before October
  - Committee reaction to sustained US pressure over Trump candidacy
  - Organization vs individual choice given ~42% recent org share
  - Likelihood of an unheralded laureate outside all shortlists
Raw forecast prompt
You are an elite superforecaster. Estimate the probability of each option for this Metaculus multiple-choice question.

## Question
Who will be awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize?

## Description / Resolution Criteria
## Description
The [Nobel Peace Prize](https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/peace/) is an internationally recognised award to 

> the person who shall have done the most or the best work for fraternity between nations, the abolition or reduction of standing armies and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses.

A total of [287 candidates have been nominated](https://www.nobelprize.org/nomination/peace/) for this year’s Prize. Of those, 208 are individuals and 79 are organisations. However, [disclosure of information about nominations is restricted](https://www.nobelprize.org/nomination/peace/), which leads to much speculation about the [possible candidates](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Nobel_Peace_Prize). 

Since its Inception in 1901, the Nobel Peace Prize has been [awarded 106 times to 143 laureates](https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/lists/all-nobel-peace-prizes/), consisting of 112 individuals and 31 organisations. [Seventy-two peace prizes](https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/facts/facts-on-the-nobel-peace-prize/) have been awarded to one laureate only, and 34 prizes have been shared by two or three laureates. The 2025 peace laureate was [Maria Corina Machado](https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/peace/2025/summary/).

## Resolution Criteria
This question will resolve as the recipient of the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize, expected to be announced by the Norwegian Nobel Committee on October 9, 2026.

If the prize is awarded to an individual not named in the listed options, this question will resolve as **Other individual**. If it is awarded to a non-individual recipient not named in the listed options, it will resolve as **Other organization**.

If no prize is awarded for any reason this question will be **annulled**.

## Fine Print
If the prize is shared, this question will resolve as the option naming one of the recipients. If more than one recipient is named in the options or if none is, it will resolve according to the recipient listed first in the official announcement by the Norwegian Nobel Committee.

## Options
  - Doctors Without Borders
  - Donald J. Trump
  - ICC / ICJ
  - Pope Leo XIV
  - Save the Children
  - Sudan Emergency Response Rooms
  - Mykola Kuleba / Save Ukraine
  - UNRWA
  - Yulia Navalnaya
  - Other organization
  - Other individual

## Sub-question decomposition (planner)
- (w=0.25) Will the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize be awarded to an organization (rather than solely to individuals)?  — Roughly 30% of prizes go to organizations historically; organizational favorites (UNRWA, Sudan Emergency Response Rooms,
- (w=0.30) Will the 2026 laureate be the pre-announcement betting-market favorite or appear on the PRIO director's shortlist / top-5 of oddsmakers?  — Historically the eventual laureate is on prediction lists only ~30-40% of the time (2025 Machado was a favorite; 2024 Ni
- (w=0.20) Will Donald Trump be awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize?  — Trump is the most heavily discussed candidate given Gaza ceasefire and other diplomatic claims, yet the Norwegian commit
- (w=0.25) Will the 2026 prize relate primarily to one of the headline conflicts/themes of 2025-26 (Sudan, Gaza/Middle East, Ukraine/Russia, press freedom, or democracy defenders)?  — The committee often signals on the year's dominant crises; identifying the thematic direction narrows the plausible laur

## Synthesized evidence
1. [sq1 | code_execution | STRONG cred 85 | NEUTRAL | DATED] Organizations received roughly 42% of Peace Prizes from 2000-2025, versus ~22-29% across the prize's full history.
2. [sq1 | question_description | MODERATE cred 90 | NEUTRAL | DATED] Of 287 nominees for 2026, 79 (28%) are organizations and 208 are individuals.
3. [sq1 | wikipedia_lookup | MODERATE cred 95 | NEUTRAL | DATED] The 2025 prize went to an individual, María Corina Machado, cited for civilian courage in Latin America.
4. [sq2 | code_execution | MODERATE cred 70 | DOWN | DATED] Bookmaker top-5 favorites contained the eventual laureate only ~27% of the time from 2015-2025.
5. [sq2 | article_search | WEAK cred 40 | NEUTRAL | VERY_RECENT] Article search (Jul-Sep 2026) returned no coverage of 2026 Nobel Peace Prize shortlists, PRIO picks, or bookmaker odds.
6. [sq3 | code_execution | MODERATE cred 75 | NEUTRAL | DATED] Sitting heads of state or government have won roughly 10% of all Peace Prizes historically.
7. [sq3 | article_search | STRONG cred 85 | DOWN | RECENT] The US completed nine consecutive nights of strikes on Iran in July 2026; Iran launched drones at Kuwait, Bahrain, Jordan.
8. [sq3 | article_search | MODERATE cred 75 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] Trump received FIFA's inaugural Peace Prize before the World Cup, a decision reported as triggering widespread international ridicule.
9. [sq3 | article_search | MODERATE cred 75 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] 2025 laureate Machado gifted Trump her Nobel medal before US military action against Maduro; Venezuelan opposition was later largely sidelined.
10. [sq3 | article_search | WEAK cred 70 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] US Ambassador Rose cut all contact with Poland's parliamentary speaker for saying Trump did not deserve the Nobel Peace Prize.
11. [sq4 | article_search | MODERATE cred 85 | UP | RECENT] Russia launched one of its largest ballistic missile attacks on Kyiv in July 2026 amid escalating Russia-Ukraine conflict.
12. [sq4 | article_search | WEAK cred 60 | NEUTRAL | RECENT] Trump's foreign policy is characterized by CNN as transactional ('get America paid'), including opaque Venezuelan oil arrangements.

## Cross-Market Signals

### No signal found

Information gaps:
  - No current 2026 betting odds or Polymarket/Kalshi favorites
  - No PRIO director shortlist or expert speculation for 2026
  - No status update on Sudan, Gaza ceasefire, or press-freedom candidates
  - No data on Norwegian Nobel Committee statements or composition changes

Key uncertainties:
  - Whether any major peace deal (Iran, Ukraine, Gaza) is concluded before October
  - Committee reaction to sustained US pressure over Trump candidacy
  - Organization vs individual choice given ~42% recent org share
  - Likelihood of an unheralded laureate outside all shortlists

## Required pre-forecast walkthrough

Before giving probabilities, address these explicitly in your rationale:
  (a) The time left until the question resolves.
  (b) The status quo outcome — the option most likely if nothing changes from today.
  (c) An outcome that would be SURPRISING but plausible.

## Calibration guidance

- **Status quo anchoring.** Good forecasters put extra weight on the status quo option because the world changes slowly most of the time.
- **Leave moderate probability on most options.** Good forecasters don't drop options to ~0% — leave ≥3-5% on every option to account for unexpected outcomes, unless you have strong specific evidence ruling them out.
- Avoid uniform-distribution laziness — most options are not equally likely.
- **Anchor on prediction markets.** If liquid market prices (Polymarket / Kalshi) for these options appear in the evidence, treat them as a strong prior and stay close to them absent specific contrary evidence.

## Output

Return ONLY valid JSON, no markdown fences:

{
  "rationale": "<address (a) (b) (c) above, then explain your distribution — 4-7 sentences total>",
  "probabilities": {
    "Doctors Without Borders": <prob>,
        "Donald J. Trump": <prob>,
        "ICC / ICJ": <prob>,
        "Pope Leo XIV": <prob>,
        "Save the Children": <prob>,
        "Sudan Emergency Response Rooms": <prob>,
        "Mykola Kuleba / Save Ukraine": <prob>,
        "UNRWA": <prob>,
        "Yulia Navalnaya": <prob>,
        "Other organization": <prob>,
        "Other individual": <prob>
  }
}

Probabilities MUST sum to ~1.0 (renormalization is applied; close enough is fine).