← all forecasts
Will Google have the best AI model at the end of December 2026?
60%
Agent
62%
Market Price
-1.5pp
Edge
51%
Confidence
558,212
Volume
1.0c
Spread
56
Days to resolution
26
Markets in event
final rationale
- already resolved?
- Not resolved: mirrors (BenchLeader Oct 28 data re-read Nov 4, ChatJudge) and a reported Arena post show Google's Gemini 4 Carbon #1 at 1528 and Argon #2 at 1520, ahead of Claude Opus 5.5 (1509) and Meta Muse Wonder (1507), but these are style-control ON and the resolving style-off table could not be read directly.
- time left
- About 8 weeks remain to the Dec 31 12:00 ET check.
- if nothing changes
- Status quo is Yes: Google holds the top two slots with a ~19-point margin over the best rival and wins exact ties.
- path to no
- Anthropic ships a general-access Fable 5.5 (rumoured ~Nov 30, testers claim it beats Carbon) or Opus 5.6 that debuts above ~1528, as Anthropic flagships have repeatedly taken #1 in 2026. Lesser paths are a style-off reorder or a Carbon checkpoint change; OpenAI and xAI start 47-53 points back.
- path to yes
- Rival releases slip, land below Carbon, or are restricted and absent from the board. The market at 61.5% (Anthropic 31.5%) already prices this two-horse race, and I found no clear unpriced edge, so I stay near the anchor.
price vs. prediction
market price
agent forecast at t+0
17 follow-ups
earlier forecasts on this market
| date | predicted | market price | confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-29 | 55% | 52% | 50% |
1. Planner Opus 5.5
Tools chosen:
polymarket_direct
resolution_source
kalshi_related
polymarket_related
Planner reasoning
This resolves on the LMArena text leaderboard rank with style control off, so the current leaderboard state is the key structured input. The Polymarket price is the anchor. Kalshi runs similar 'top AI model' markets, which give an independent second crowd, and related Polymarket markets (the other companies in this group and monthly versions of the same question) let me check the prices are consistent.
2. Research 4 web research agents, Sonnet 5.5
summary
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports)
Tools
- polymarket_direct: ## This Market's Polymarket Data **Will Google have the best AI model at the end of December 2026?** - Current price (probability): 61.50% (live; bid 61% / ask 62%) - 7-day price change: +4.00% - 30-day price change: +23.00% - Total volume: $558,212 (USD notional) - Price range: 6.00% - 61.50% - Data points: 87 days
- resolution_source: already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=False; last_updated=2026-10-28 (Arena data date reported by BenchLeader; page checked 5 Nov 2026). The official arena.ai page blocked us, so we used a secondary source. BenchLeader, checked 5 Nov 2026 using Arena data dated 28 Oct 2026, ranks Google's Gemini 4 Carbon (high) #1 at 1528. Next are Google's Gemini 4 Argon (high) at 1520 and Anthropic's Claude
- kalshi_related: 2 related markets / summaries. keyword 'top AI model': ok | keyword 'best AI model': ok | keyword 'LMArena': no matches
- polymarket_related: Polymarket search over 3 keyword(s), kept 24 matches. keyword 'best AI model': 8 markets | keyword 'AI model end of': 8 markets | keyword 'Gemini': 8 markets
Research loops, bottom lines
- current state: Google currently holds the top two Arena text slots, with a roughly 19-point margin over the best non-Google model (Claude Opus 5.5) in mirrored data dated 2026-10-28. A challenger (Claude Fable 5.5 or Mythos 5.5, GPT-6.2, Grok 4.8, Opus 5.6) could still release before the 2026-12-31 check. Anthropic has the closest rumoured release, and scores for new models often settle only after weeks of votes.
- base rate: Base rates in 2026 favour whichever lab released last: #1 has alternated between Anthropic (Feb–Sep) and Google (Jan, Oct), and the Nov 5 snapshot has Google ahead by 8–19 points (style-controlled, unverified). The market now prices Google at about 62%, up sharply from about 9% in early September, so the question is mainly whether Anthropic, OpenAI or xAI ships a leapfrogging model before Dec 31.
- yes case: Google holds #1 and #2 on every mirror of Arena Text through 2026-11-04, with margins of 8–19 points over the best rival. YES needs only that no rival release overtakes Carbon in the next eight weeks, and that the style-control-off view doesn't reorder the top.
- no case: The best No case is that Anthropic's Fable 5.5 (or Opus 5.6) ships in November or December, with the board's top spot changing hands as it has after each past flagship release. The 8-point Google gap over its own second model, and the 19-point gap to Opus 5.5, are within the range of a single Claude generation jump. The style-control-off criterion adds uncertainty about the ordering. Counter-evidence: no rival model has been confirmed, and OpenAI and xAI start 47–53 points behind.
tools
| tool | status | time | items | summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| polymarket_direct | OK | 0.1s | 1 | ## This Market's Polymarket Data **Will Google have the best AI model at the end of December 2026?** - Current price (probability): 61.50% (live; bid 61% / ask 62%) - 7-day price change: +4.00% - 30-day price change: +23.00% - Total volume: $558,212 (USD notional) - Price range: 6.00% - 61.50% - Da |
| resolution_source | OK | 19.5s | 1 | already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=False; last_updated=2026-10-28 (Arena data date reported by BenchLeader; page checked 5 Nov 2026). The official arena.ai page blocked us, so we used a secondary source. BenchLeader, checked 5 Nov 2026 using Arena data dated 28 Oct 2026, ranks Google's Gemin |
| kalshi_related | OK | 4.2s | 2 | 2 related markets / summaries. keyword 'top AI model': ok | keyword 'best AI model': ok | keyword 'LMArena': no matches |
| polymarket_related | OK | 0.4s | 24 | Polymarket search over 3 keyword(s), kept 24 matches. keyword 'best AI model': 8 markets | keyword 'AI model end of': 8 markets | keyword 'Gemini': 8 markets |
web research agents
4/4 ok,
16 searches,
4 page reads
| dimension | status | time | searches | page reads | report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current state | OK | 28s | 5 | 0 | 4445 chars |
| base rate | OK | 28s | 3 | 2 | 4822 chars |
| yes case | OK | 22s | 4 | 2 | 4968 chars |
| no case | OK | 29s | 4 | 0 | 6324 chars |
report: current state
- [2026-11-05] The Arena site (lmarena.ai, which redirects to arena.ai) blocked my browser behind a bot check. I could not read the resolution table directly, so everything below comes from third-party mirrors of Arena data. https://arena.ai/leaderboard/text
- [2026-11-05] BenchLeader mirrors Arena Text data dated 2026-10-28. Google holds #1 and #2: Gemini 4 Carbon (high) at 1528 and Gemini 4 Argon (high) at 1520. Next are Claude Opus 5.5 at 1509, Meta Muse Wonder at 1507, and Claude Fable 5.1 and Fable 5 at 1504. The top OpenAI entry I saw is GPT-5.6 Sol at 1485. The top xAI entry is Grok 4.20 at 1475; the page labels xAI as SpaceXAI. Caveat: BenchLeader says these scores are with style control on. The market resolves on style control off, so rank order may differ. https://www.benchleader.com/benchmarks/lmarena_text
- [2026-10-28] Google announced Gemini 4 Carbon, built on Argon. Access is limited to vetted cyber defenders in the Fairwind Program, with no date for the API, Vertex AI or the Gemini app. Mid-November is a guess based on Argon's two-week gap between its limited release and its public one. Carbon appeared in anonymous Arena battles from 2026-10-21. https://projedefteri.com/en/blog/gemini-4-carbon-release-date/
- [2026-09-30] Google announced Gemini 4 Argon. It reached general availability on 2026-10-13. One secondary source says Argon took Arena text #1 at 1525 at launch. Another, dated 2026-10-27, lists Argon #1 at 1517 with Opus 5.5 second at 1509. https://felloai.com/gemini-4-argon/ and https://slash-digital.io/en/insights/ai-models-2026/
- [2026-10-15] A snapshot at that date had Muse Wonder (1509) and Claude Opus 5.5 (1508) tied at the top of Arena text, with Claude Fable 5 at 1504. Argon is not named in the excerpt I saw. https://valueaddvc.com/blog/best-ai-models-in-2026-ranked-gpt-5-claude-4-gemini-2-5-grok-3-compared
- [2026-08-31] Earlier in the year Anthropic led Arena text. Claude Fable 5 was #1 at 1507, with Opus 4.6 and 4.7 thinking variants next. Google's lead dates only from Gemini 4 Argon and Carbon in late September and October. Gemini 3.5 Pro never shipped, despite repeated rumoured dates. https://ofox.ai/blog/llm-leaderboard-best-ai-models-ranked-2026/ and https://qcode.cc/en/gemini-3-5-pro-guide
- [2026-11-01] Anthropic is reportedly preparing releases. A reference to Claude Mythos 5.5 appeared on Anthropic's site, and Claude Fable 5.5 checkpoints are reportedly being A/B tested. Some testers claim Fable 5.5 beats Carbon. This is unconfirmed. https://www.testingcatalog.com/anthropic-prepares-to-release-claude-mythos-5-5-model/
- [2026-11-02] A rumoured release calendar (an X post, not confirmed) lists GPT-6.2 Astra (Nov 2–15), GPT-6.2 Sol (Nov 10–15), Grok 4.8 (Nov 19–30), Claude Fable 5.5 (around Nov 30), Qwen 4 Max (around Nov 16), Carbon's wider rollout (November) and Claude Opus 5.6 (late November or December). https://x.com/mark_k/status/2117323044213625181
- [2026-10-26] OpenAI shipped GPT-6.1 Terra, a cheap model. GPT-6.1 Sol and GPT-6 Astra are on the board at 1481 and 1476, well below Google's top two. Anthropic made its IPO S-1 public on this date. https://www.orcarouter.ai/blog/openai-anthropic-week-44-2026
- [2026-10-30] Some trackers conflict with the above. Swfte and the af.net tracker list Claude Mythos 5 at 1531 as #1 as of 2026-10-25. They appear stale or unreliable, and Mythos 5 is a restricted model. af.net's own changelog shows Google taking first place on 2026-11-02. https://af.net/realtime/llm-leaderboard-tracker/
- [2026-10-28] Google's Carbon scores in Arena's WebDev category: 1,768 Elo, ranked fourth at announcement. This is a different board from the one that resolves the market. https://techgenyz.com/google-continuing-note-not-fetched
BOTTOM LINE: Google currently holds the top two Arena text slots, with a roughly 19-point margin over the best non-Google model (Claude Opus 5.5) in mirrored data dated 2026-10-28. A challenger (Claude Fable 5.5 or Mythos 5.5, GPT-6.2, Grok 4.8, Opus 5.6) could still release before the 2026-12-31 check. Anthropic has the closest rumoured release, and scores for new models often settle only after weeks of votes.
NOT FOUND: A direct read of the live arena.ai text leaderboard with style control off; the style-control-off ranking is therefore unverified. I also found no confirmed release dates for any rival frontier model. Carbon's public rollout date has not been announced.
report: base rate
- [2026-11-05] BenchLeader shows Google at #1 on the Arena text board: Gemini 4 Carbon 1528, Gemini 4 Argon 1520, Claude Opus 5.5 1509, Meta Muse Wonder 1507, then several Claude models at about 1504. The top two are 8 and 19 points clear of the best non-Google model, and the data are dated 2026-10-28. This is a third-party aggregator, and it says its numbers are style-controlled. The market resolves with style control OFF, so the ordering could differ. https://www.benchleader.com/benchmarks/lmarena_text
- [2026-11-05] I could not open the official arena.ai leaderboard because a bot check blocked it. The BenchLeader figures are therefore unverified against the resolution source. https://arena.ai/leaderboard/text
- [2026-11-05] Polymarket's market for this question had Google ahead at 62%, Anthropic 32%, OpenAI 4.2%, Meta 1.2%, xAI 0.9%. DeFi Rate says Google was #1 on Polymarket's monthly markets at the end of January and October, and Anthropic was #1 at the end of every month from February to September. The same page puts Polymarket's end-of-November market at Google 71%. Kalshi's equivalent contract asks whether a company reaches #1 at any point in 2026, so it is not comparable. https://defirate.com/prediction-markets/best-ai-model-odds-this-year
- [2026-10-01 to 2026-10-23] Polymarket odds for this market swung widely. Anthropic was 53% and Google 39.5% on Oct 1, Anthropic 49% and Google 43% on Oct 7, Anthropic 46% and Google 40% about Oct 1–23 per DeFi Rate's earlier snapshot, and Google 62% by Nov 5. In September Anthropic was 56–69% and Google 7–9%. The lead has changed hands with each major release. https://polymarkettrader.com/odds/which-company-has-best-ai-model-end-of-2026/
- [2026-10-03/08] A Kalshi "best AI end of 2026" market (via Dimers) showed Anthropic 51.9%, Google 37.1%, OpenAI 9.6% on Oct 3. A separate Polymarket "#1 end of December" market showed Google 40%, Anthropic 39% on Oct 8. This is a secondary summary and the sibling markets were not independently checked. https://shattered.io/google-vs-anthropic-ai-prediction-markets-2026/
- [2025-11-18] Reference case for Google's release pattern: Gemini 3 Pro debuted at 1501 and took #1 on the text board, ahead of Grok-4.1, Claude 4.5 and GPT-5. Arena itself announced it. https://x.com/arena/status/1990813759938703570
- [2026-02-19] Gemini 3.1 Pro tied for #1 in text at 1500, 4 points behind Claude Opus 4.6, so its #1 lead did not last. Arena posted this itself. https://x.com/arena/status/2024519891295089063
- [2026-08] Third-party trackers put Anthropic's Claude Fable 5 at #1 around 1509–1525 in July–August, with Anthropic holding #1 at each month-end from February to September. Over 2026 the #1 spot has mostly alternated between Anthropic and Google, and OpenAI and xAI have not led. https://localaimaster.com/blog/lmarena-chatbot-arena-leaderboard
- [2026-10-30 to 2026-11-02] Trackers disagree on the leader. Swfte (about Oct 26) listed Claude Mythos 5 at 1531, but it is a restricted-access model, and BenchLeader's top 15 does not show it. A change-log item dated Nov 2 says Gemini 3.0 (Google) took the top spot, and a headline says Gemini 4 Carbon took the top spot with 1528. These are low-quality aggregators, and some may be AI-generated. https://af.net/realtime/llm-leaderboard-tracker/
- [2026-10-28] A model-count caveat: the leaderboard now holds 376 configurations. Anthropic fills many of the top-15 slots (about 8), Google 3 (Gemini 4 Carbon, 4 Argon, 3.8 Flash) and Meta 3–4 (Muse Wonder, Muse Spark 1.3, 1.2 and 1.1). Anthropic's newer models, such as Fable 5.1 and Opus 5.5, are listed at 1504–1509. https://www.benchleader.com/benchmarks/lmarena_text
- [Rules] Rank is the primary sort key, ties are broken by unrounded score, and Google wins any exact tie. Rank in Arena's table can be shared within confidence intervals, so a rank-1 tie decided by score is possible. The check is on 2026-12-31 at 12:00 ET with style control off. Late-December releases from Anthropic, OpenAI or xAI could change the order in the final eight weeks.
BOTTOM LINE: Base rates in 2026 favour whichever lab released last: #1 has alternated between Anthropic (Feb–Sep) and Google (Jan, Oct), and the Nov 5 snapshot has Google ahead by 8–19 points (style-controlled, unverified). The market now prices Google at about 62%, up sharply from about 9% in early September, so the question is mainly whether Anthropic, OpenAI or xAI ships a leapfrogging model before Dec 31.
NOT FOUND: the official arena.ai table with style control off (bot-blocked); a confirmed date for any Anthropic, OpenAI or xAI release before year-end; a track record for these Polymarket and Kalshi markets beyond the monthly settlements DeFi Rate lists; and any independent confirmation that the "Gemini 4 Carbon" figures match arena.ai.
report: yes case
YES means: Google's model holds rank 1 on the lmarena.ai text leaderboard (style control off) at the 2026-12-31 12:00 ET check. A tie on rank is broken by unrounded score, then in Google's favour.
- [2026-10-30] Arena's own account is reported to have posted Gemini 4 Carbon (High) at #1 in Text Arena with 1,528 points. Carbon is also reported #2 in Agent Arena and #4 in WebDev. This is a secondary report of the Arena post. https://explainx.ai/blog/gemini-4-carbon-launch-cyber-defenders-first-59-intelligence-index-pricing-2026
- [2026-09-30] Arena's official post, which I couldn't open directly, is quoted in search results. Argon launched at 1525, "+20 points above" the #2 model, Claude Opus 4.6 (High). Argon ranked #1 in Coding, Hard Prompts, Instruction Following, Longer Query and Creative Writing. A lead across the sub-categories makes the overall lead less likely to depend on style effects. https://x.com/arena/status/2105394855644139908
- [2026-10-30] Style control: a secondary summary of Arena's post says the Argon score was with style control on. Style-off is the resolution basis. Arena's default has been style control on, so the market board is probably a variant of the same data. Google's lead is broad, and a style-off reorder would need a roughly 19-point swing against Google. This is an inference, not verified. https://szymonpaluch.com/blog/posts/gemini-4-argon
- [2026-11-01] The ChatJudge mirror (board dated 2026-10-27) shows Google at ranks 1 and 2, and the highest non-Google entry at #3. All of Google's older Pro and Flash entries sit between #10 and #23. That is a deep bench, but only the top slot matters. https://chatjudge.ai/benchmarks/chat/lmarena-text
- [2026-11-04] BenchLeader re-read the board on 2026-11-04. The top two are unchanged, and the latest result is dated 2026-10-28. No challenger has displaced Carbon in the week since launch. https://www.benchleader.com/benchmarks/lmarena_text
- [2026-10-29] Carbon is #1 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5 at 59, ahead of Opus 5.5 at 58 and GPT-6 Astra at 57. On Google's own table it leads 15 of 17 benchmarks. Independent evals thus put it at least level with the rivals, so the Arena lead isn't a one-off. The same piece says Alphabet's CEO told investors on the Oct 28 earnings call that AI is speeding up Google's training and releases. https://fundaai.substack.com/p/researchllm-gemini-4-carbon-puts
- [2026-10-29] Carbon is not in the Gemini API, and Google has given no public date or model ID. This helps YES in one way. Carbon already holds #1 while restricted, so a wider release only adds votes, and Argon (1520, public since 2026-10-13) is a fallback at #2. Google needs only one of its two models to stay on top. https://www.mindstudio.ai/blog/gemini-4-carbon-frontier-model
- [2026-10-31] Arena's own page says GPT-6 Sol sits at #64 (1458) and below GPT-5.6 Sol. The best OpenAI entry is 1485, and the best xAI entry, Grok 4.20, is 1475 (from the ChatJudge list). Both are 35+ points behind Carbon. Neither would clear that in one release without a record jump. https://felloai.com/best-ai-models/
- [2026-11-01] Meta Muse Wonder (1507) is the best non-Anthropic challenger and is 21 points behind. Anthropic's top Opus 5.5 is 19 points behind. Anthropic's rumoured Fable 5.5 and Mythos 5.5 (colleagues' report of Nov 1) are unconfirmed. In this period the Claude flagships have scored 1504–1509, and the Argon and Carbon steps were +20 and +8 over the previous best. That is the margin a new Claude would have to beat. https://chatjudge.ai/benchmarks/chat/lmarena-text
- [2026-02-19] Precedent on tiebreaks: when Gemini 3.1 Pro debuted, Arena showed it tied for #1 in text (1500) and 4 points behind Opus 4.6. A rival within Arena's confidence interval can share rank 1. Here the rule then sorts by unrounded score, then Google wins any exact tie. A new Claude within a few points of Carbon would not necessarily take #1. https://x.com/arena/status/2024519891295089063
Most likely path to YES: no rival ships a text model that scores above Carbon (about 1528) by Dec 31. Carbon then stays at #1, with Argon as backup. Prerequisites:
- Anthropic's rumoured Fable 5.5 or Opus 5.6 either slips past the cutoff or lands within a few points of Carbon.
- The style-off board keeps the same top-two order.
- Carbon's score doesn't decay after wider rollout. Arena re-baselined scores once before (July 12, per localaimaster), which is a small risk.
BOTTOM LINE: Google holds #1 and #2 on every mirror of Arena Text through 2026-11-04, with margins of 8–19 points over the best rival. YES needs only that no rival release overtakes Carbon in the next eight weeks, and that the style-control-off view doesn't reorder the top.
NOT FOUND: A direct read of the live arena.ai table with style control off. A confirmed release date for any Anthropic, OpenAI, xAI or Meta model before the end of 2026. Any Arena statement about Carbon's public rollout.
report: no case
YES means: Google owns the model with the top rank on the Arena text leaderboard (style control off) at the 2026-12-31 12:00 ET check.
- [2026-10-30] Arena's own post shows Carbon at #1 with 1528 and Argon at #2 with 1520. That is an 8-point gap between two Google models, so the figure the No side must beat is Google's 1528, not Claude's 1509. The 19-point gap to the best Claude model (Opus 5.5, 1509) comes from the BenchLeader mirror. Counter-evidence for the No side: Arena's text page lists Carbon at rank 1 with a rank spread of "1 2", so Google's top two models share the top band. Any rival model that enters the top band is therefore resolved by unrounded score, not by rank. https://x.com/arena/status/2115495002998751262 and https://arena.ai/leaderboard/chat/text
- [2026-11-01] The strongest No catalyst is Anthropic. A Mythos 5.5 reference surfaced on Anthropic's own Mythos page, and Fable 5.5 was reportedly A/B tested. One tweet in the TestingCatalog piece guessed at a Tuesday launch. Testers claim it beats Carbon, but there are no public benchmarks, so this is anecdote. Fable 5.5 appeared briefly in LiteLLM's Azure price list on Oct 13–14 and was then removed. Precedent: Anthropic's previous Mythos-class model (Fable 5) debuted at #1 on Arena text (Arena post, Jun 10). A Fable 5.5 launch would also be the first Anthropic text-board test since Fable 5.1. https://www.testingcatalog.com/anthropic-prepares-to-release-claude-mythos-5-5-model/
- [2026-11-01] Access restriction cuts against the No side. Mythos 5.1 was restricted to verified researchers, and only Fable 5.1 was general. Restricted-tier models may not appear on the Arena text board at all. A Mythos 5.5 release could therefore add nothing to the board. Only a general-access Fable 5.5 would count. https://www.testingcatalog.com/anthropic-prepares-to-release-claude-mythos-5-5-model/
- [2026-11-03] OpenAI timing: GPT-6.2 Astra was seen in Codex usage on Oct 31 and Nov 1, but it is not in the API docs, and no release has been confirmed. Overchat reports Polymarket's "next Astra model" market at 80% by Nov 15 and 98% by Dec 31, which makes a release before the check very likely. OpenAI's 2026 cadence is a release every 1–8 weeks. However, OpenAI's best board entries (GPT-6.1 Sol 1481, GPT-6 Astra 1476) trail Carbon by about 47–52 points, so it would need a very large jump. OpenAI has not led the text board in 2026. https://overchat.ai/ai-hub/gpt-6-2-release-date
- [2026-11-03] xAI is a weak No path. Grok 5 has no date. Grok 4.8 and 4.9 come first, and past Grok 5 targets (Q1 and Q2 2026) were missed. The newest model is Grok 4.7 (Sep 21), at a cadence of 27–40 days per step. A Grok 4.8 could land in the window but starts about 53 points behind Carbon (1475 vs 1528). https://sumus.im/blog/grok-5-release-date
- [2026-10-12] Evidence of fast flips: one tracker (anotherwrapper) had Claude Fable 5 at #1 with 1506 on Oct 12, with Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.1 next, and no Google model on the board. Carbon displaced them within about 16 days. Anthropic held the lead for most of Feb–Sep, and Google's lead is only about 3 weeks old. Status quo is therefore not a stable regime: the lead has changed with each flagship release. https://anotherwrapper.com/tools/llm-pricing/evals/arena-text-elo
- [2026-11-04] A resolution-criteria technicality favours No. BenchLeader says its numbers are for the style-control-on rating, and the Arena page shows a "Style Control" adjustment toggle. The market resolves on style control OFF. In the past, style-control-off boards favoured longer, more formatted outputs, which has helped Claude and OpenAI chat-tuned models. Carbon is flagged for "2.3x more reasoning tokens" and verbosity, so a style-off reorder is possible. Whether the default view is on or off could not be verified. https://www.benchleader.com/benchmarks/lmarena_text and https://alphasignal.ai/news/google-deepmind-s-gemini-4-carbon-tops-lm-arena-s-text-leaderboard-at-72-less
- [2026-11-01] Google may disturb its own score. TestingCatalog reported that Google was testing a new Carbon checkpoint on Arena. A different checkpoint could move Google's top score, and the 1528 is a preview-stage rating. New models usually drift in the first weeks. Carbon itself is limited to cyber defenders, and it is unclear whether the board's "Carbon (High)" is a model the public can use. https://www.testingcatalog.com/anthropic-prepares-to-release-claude-mythos-5-5-model/
- [2026-10-28] Arena's rank spread for Carbon is "1 2". Ties and overlapping confidence intervals can put several labs at rank 1, and then the unrounded score decides. A model that debuts with only a few thousand votes has a wide interval. A late-December Claude release with a favourable early score could take the top score. Google keeps only exact ties. https://arena.ai/leaderboard/chat/text
- [2026-07-10] Arena has a history of re-baselining. Fable 5's scores were re-baselined on Jul 12 to count only post-restoration votes, and Anthropic also had a model suspended and restored on Jul 1. Board values can shift without a new release, which adds noise on the 8–19 point gap. https://localaimaster.com/blog/lmarena-chatbot-arena-leaderboard
- [2026-11-02] Gemini 3.5 Pro never shipped, despite rumoured dates, so Google's own release timing is unreliable. That does not hurt Google here, because it already holds #1. It does mean Google has little room to answer a rival leapfrog with its own new model. A reply is plausible only through the new Carbon checkpoint. https://qcode.cc/en/gemini-3-5-pro-guide
BOTTOM LINE: The best No case is that Anthropic's Fable 5.5 (or Opus 5.6) ships in November or December, with the board's top spot changing hands as it has after each past flagship release. The 8-point Google gap over its own second model, and the 19-point gap to Opus 5.5, are within the range of a single Claude generation jump. The style-control-off criterion adds uncertainty about the ordering. Counter-evidence: no rival model has been confirmed, and OpenAI and xAI start 47–53 points behind.
NOT FOUND: The live Arena table with style control off, and whether the default view is style-on. Confirmed release dates for Fable 5.5, Mythos 5.5, GPT-6.2 or Grok 4.8. Any benchmark for Fable 5.5. The result of the new Carbon checkpoint test.
3. Forecasters 2 draws, Opus 5.5
claude-opus-5-5, high effort
52% conf
| Yes | 60% |
| No | 40% |
- already resolved?
- Not resolved: mirrors (BenchLeader Oct 28 data re-read Nov 4, ChatJudge) and a reported Arena post show Google's Gemini 4 Carbon #1 at 1528 and Argon #2 at 1520, ahead of Claude Opus 5.5 (1509) and Meta Muse Wonder (1507), but these are style-control ON and the resolving style-off table could not be read directly.
- time left
- About 8 weeks remain to the Dec 31 12:00 ET check.
- if nothing changes
- Status quo is Yes: Google holds the top two slots with a ~19-point margin over the best rival and wins exact ties.
- path to no
- Anthropic ships a general-access Fable 5.5 (rumoured ~Nov 30, testers claim it beats Carbon) or Opus 5.6 that debuts above ~1528, as Anthropic flagships have repeatedly taken #1 in 2026. Lesser paths are a style-off reorder or a Carbon checkpoint change; OpenAI and xAI start 47-53 points back.
- path to yes
- Rival releases slip, land below Carbon, or are restricted and absent from the board. The market at 61.5% (Anthropic 31.5%) already prices this two-horse race, and I found no clear unpriced edge, so I stay near the anchor.
claude-opus-5-5, high effort
50% conf
| Yes | 60% |
| No | 40% |
- already resolved?
- Not resolved. The check is the lmarena text leaderboard with style control off at 12:00 ET on 2026-12-31. I could not read the official page directly. Mirrors (BenchLeader with data from 2026-10-28, ChatJudge, and a reported Arena post) show Google #1 and #2: Gemini 4 Carbon at 1528 and Argon at 1520. The best rival is Claude Opus 5.5 at 1509. Those figures are style-control ON, so the style-off order is unverified.
- time left
- About 8 weeks remain until the check.
- if nothing changes
- If nothing changes, Google keeps #1 and Yes resolves. Argon is a backup at #2, and Google wins exact ties.
- path to no
- Anthropic ships Fable 5.5 or Opus 5.6 in November or December, as rumoured (unconfirmed X calendar and TestingCatalog), and debuts above about 1528. Anthropic's prior flagship Fable 5 debuted at #1, and the 2026 lead has flipped with each flagship release. A smaller No path is the style-off view reordering a verbose-output-sensitive top.
- path to yes
- Rival releases slip past Dec 31 or land within a few points of Carbon. OpenAI and xAI start 47-53 points back, and Google may add a new Carbon checkpoint.
The Polymarket anchor is 61.5%. Sibling markets price Anthropic at 31.5% and OpenAI at 4%, and the end-of-November market is reportedly Google 71%, which already prices December release risk. I found nothing the market hasn't priced, so I stay near the anchor with a slight shade down for the unverified style-off ordering.
4. Final plain mean of 2 draws
60%
(51% confidence)
Yes: 60%
No: 40%
- already resolved?
- Not resolved: mirrors (BenchLeader Oct 28 data re-read Nov 4, ChatJudge) and a reported Arena post show Google's Gemini 4 Carbon #1 at 1528 and Argon #2 at 1520, ahead of Claude Opus 5.5 (1509) and Meta Muse Wonder (1507), but these are style-control ON and the resolving style-off table could not be read directly.
- time left
- About 8 weeks remain to the Dec 31 12:00 ET check.
- if nothing changes
- Status quo is Yes: Google holds the top two slots with a ~19-point margin over the best rival and wins exact ties.
- path to no
- Anthropic ships a general-access Fable 5.5 (rumoured ~Nov 30, testers claim it beats Carbon) or Opus 5.6 that debuts above ~1528, as Anthropic flagships have repeatedly taken #1 in 2026. Lesser paths are a style-off reorder or a Carbon checkpoint change; OpenAI and xAI start 47-53 points back.
- path to yes
- Rival releases slip, land below Carbon, or are restricted and absent from the board. The market at 61.5% (Anthropic 31.5%) already prices this two-horse race, and I found no clear unpriced edge, so I stay near the anchor.
Pipeline Timing and Cost
Total pipeline time: 74.5s
LLM cost: $1.19
(Sonnet 5.5 $0.75, Opus 5.5 $0.27, 17 web searches $0.17)
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.