forecasting
agent
← back to scans

Will the US government be shut down on Dec 12, 2026? — Yes

kalshiPolitics·2026-10-10·view on kalshi ↗
27%
Agent
30%
Market Price
-2.6%
Edge
59%
Confidence
14,530
Volume
3.0c
Spread
63
Days to resolution
1
Markets in event
final rationale
Mean of 5 draws (0.25, 0.23, 0.30, 0.30, 0.29). (0) The condition is not met and cannot yet be met. The government is funded through Dec 11, 2026 under H.R. 6500, signed Sept 2 (Holland & Knight, Oct 9). The resolution-source fetch returned no shutdown status. (a) There are about 2 months left. The binding window is the compressed lame-duck session between the Nov 3 midterms and the Dec 11 CR expiration. Dec 12, 10 AM ET falls on a Saturday, the morning after the lapse would begin. (b) If nothing changes, funding lapses at midnight, so Congress must act. The cheapest action, another stopgap, passed 90-6 and 370-48 just weeks ago, and the Appropriations chair is reportedly pre-positioning for another punt. (c) NO: post-election, leaders pass a short CR into early 2027. The Freedom Caucus aims only to block an omnibus, and whichever party wins the House may prefer to punt into the new Congress. (d) YES: unresolved fights consume the few legislative weeks and the CR lapses Friday night, triggering an OMB shutdown directive. These include the defense topline and Iran war costs, impoundment riders, a reconciliation push and a Hegseth impeachment vote. This Congress has lapsed three times in 12 months, so that is credible. The Kalshi anchor is 30% and drifting down. Independent forecasts sit around 24% (TPG), and the lame-duck base rate is about 15%. I shade slightly below the market to about 25%, keeping meaningful weight on this Congress's demonstrated brinkmanship.
price vs. prediction
market price agent forecast at t+0
9 follow-ups
1. Planner Opus 5.5 · picks the research tools
Tools chosen: kalshi_direct resolution_source congress_bills kalshi_related polymarket_related wikipedia article_search
Planner reasoning
The Kalshi price is the anchor. Congress.gov shows the FY2027 appropriations and continuing-resolution status, which tells us whether funding lapses around a likely CR expiry in November or December. The resolution source is the OPM operating status and the OMB shutdown directive. I'm adding cross-venue markets, Wikipedia for the base rate of past shutdowns, and one targeted search for the current CR expiration date.
2. Research parallel tool calls + 4 web research loops (Sonnet 5) · read raw by the forecasters
at a glance
RESEARCH DIGEST (built in code: tool summaries and each report's bottom line; the forecasters read the full tool outputs and reports) Tools - kalshi_direct: ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Yes** (KXGOVTSHUTDOWN-26DEC12) - Current price (probability): 30.00% (live; bid 30% / ask 33%) - Last daily close (2026-10-09): 29.00% - 7-day price change: -7.00% - 30-day price change: -16.00% - Average daily volume: 833 contracts - Price range: 26.00% - 46.00% - Data points: 17 days - resolution_source: already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=unknown. The fetched OPM Current Status page did not return an actual status value (shows 'Loading' placeholder), and the OMB page is generic navigation/about content with no shutdown-related operating status or directive text. - congress_bills: Found 10 bills matching 'continuing appropriations fiscal year 2027'. - kalshi_related: 1 related markets / summaries. series KXGOVTSHUTDOWN: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal) | keyword 'government shutdown': ok - polymarket_related: Polymarket search over 1 keyword(s), kept 3 matches. keyword 'government shutdown': 3 markets - wikipedia: Fetched 1 Wikipedia entries (0 missing pages). - article_search: Fetched 7 unique articles across 1 queries (lookback=30d). 'continuing resolution expiration date FY2027 funding deadline': 8 articles Research loops, bottom lines - current state: The government is currently open and funded through Dec. 11, 2026 under a CR signed Sept. 2, 2026; Congress is on pre-election recess with only 3 of 12 FY2027 appropriations bills passed by the House and none by the Senate, so the Dec. 11 deadline (one day before this market's Dec. 12 close) will force a fresh negotiation in a compressed lame-duck session, leaving real — but not dominant — shutdown risk given 2025-2026's repeated pattern of last-minute CRs and lapses. - base rate: The long-run (1976–2024) base rate for a shutdown at any given funding deadline is low (most lapses were brief or avoided; only 3 of ~20 funding gaps before 2025 exceeded two weeks), but the current 119th Congress has broken that pattern with three shutdowns in the past 12 months, including the longest (43-day) and second-longest (76-day) shutdowns on record; independent forecasters as of late September 2026 put the December 12 shutdown probability in roughly the 15-35% range (central estimate ~ - yes case: The strongest YES path is a straightforward mechanical one: a genuinely crowded, midterm-disrupted lame-duck session with unresolved defense-topline, Iran-funding, impoundment-rider, and reconciliation fights consuming floor time, such that Congress simply runs out of days to pass even a new stopgap before the Dec. 11 CR lapses — a scenario made more plausible by this Congress's demonstrated pattern of three prior lapses in 12 months. - no case: Every dedicated, deadline-specific forecast found (TPG's 24%, central lame-duck base rates near 15%) keeps the probability of an actual Dec. 12 lapse a minority outcome, and the mechanics so far — wide bipartisan CR votes, a House Appropriations Committee that has already cleared all 12 bills, a Senate dispute narrowly focused on the defense topline, and Freedom Caucus messaging aimed at blocking an omnibus rather than provoking a shutdown — all point toward another stopgap CR (a NO outcome) as
tools
toolstatustimeitemssummary
kalshi_direct OK 0.2s 1 ## This Market's Kalshi Data **Yes** (KXGOVTSHUTDOWN-26DEC12) - Current price (probability): 30.00% (live; bid 30% / ask 33%) - Last daily close (2026-10-09): 29.00% - 7-day price change: -7.00% - 30-day price change: -16.00% - Average daily volume: 833 contracts - Price range: 26.00% - 46.00% - Da
resolution_source OK 3.8s 1 already_resolved=unclear; matches_criteria=True; last_updated=unknown. The fetched OPM Current Status page did not return an actual status value (shows 'Loading' placeholder), and the OMB page is generic navigation/about content with no shutdown-related operating status or directive text.
congress_bills OK 1.2s 10 Found 10 bills matching 'continuing appropriations fiscal year 2027'.
kalshi_related OK 1.1s 1 1 related markets / summaries. series KXGOVTSHUTDOWN: 0 markets (skipped 1 no-signal) | keyword 'government shutdown': ok
polymarket_related OK 0.6s 3 Polymarket search over 1 keyword(s), kept 3 matches. keyword 'government shutdown': 3 markets
wikipedia OK 0.4s 1 Fetched 1 Wikipedia entries (0 missing pages).
article_search OK 0.4s 7 Fetched 7 unique articles across 1 queries (lookback=30d). 'continuing resolution expiration date FY2027 funding deadline': 8 articles
research loops · 4/4 ok · 15 searches · 5 page reads
dimensionstatustimesearchespage readsreport
current state OK 34s 4 2 4698 chars
base rate OK 39s 3 2 5517 chars
yes case OK 39s 4 1 4860 chars
no case SNIPPETS 47s 4 0 6109 chars · no page read; snippets only
report: current state
- [2026-09-02] President Trump signed H.R. 6500, the Continuing Appropriations and Extensions Act, 2027, into law, averting a shutdown at the Oct 1 fiscal-year start. Congress has approved and the President has signed a short-term continuing resolution (CR) to keep the federal government funded through December 11, 2026, avoiding a government shutdown at the start of the new fiscal year, approved by the House on September 1 by a vote of 370-48 and signed into law on September 2. - [2026-09-01/09-02] The CR funds government at FY2026 levels and also delays an OMB grants-review rule; the Senate had passed it 90-6 on Aug. 8 and the House 370-48 on Sept. 1. The continuing resolution (CR) funds the federal government at largely current levels through Dec. 11, 2026... The passage of the CR prevents a government shutdown when current federal funding expires on Sept. 30. It buys time for negotiations over final FY27 appropriations until after midterm elections in early November. - [2026-10-09] A Holland & Knight legal alert confirms the government is currently open and funded, with the next cliff being Dec. 11, 2026: The most immediate deadline is December 11, 2026, when the current continuing resolution (CR) expires... The current CR funds the government through December 11, 2026. - [2026-10-09] Appropriations progress remains thin: The House has passed three (Agriculture, Military Construction-Veterans Affairs, and National Security-State) of the 12 FY 2027 appropriations bills, while the U.S. Senate had not completed any comparable floor action before the pre-election recess. - [2026-10-09] The same analysis notes a shutdown remains a live possibility: A partial government shutdown remains possible if the parties cannot resolve disputes over spending levels, policy riders, defense funding, healthcare and Trump Administration authorities before December 11, 2026. - [2026-10-09] Congress is in pre-election recess; the Senate left Washington on Sept. 30, 2026 and will return for a "compressed lame-duck" session after the Nov. 3 midterms to negotiate FY2027 funding, NDAA, Farm Bill, surface transportation, and other year-end items converging on Dec. 11. - [2026-10-03] Independent trackers confirm the operative status: As of October 3, 2026, the federal government has funding through December 11 under the recently enacted continuing resolution. - [History/context] Earlier in FY2026, there were two separate funding lapses unrelated to the Dec 2026 question: a 43-day shutdown from Oct 1–Nov 12, 2025, and in early 2026 a 4-day shutdown (Jan 31–Feb 3) and a 76-day partial DHS shutdown (Feb 14–Apr 30) Date: First shutdown: January 31 – February 3, 2026 (4 days) Second shutdown: February 14 – April 30, 2026 (76 days), Cause: End of certain appropriations from the Continuing Appropriations, Agriculture, Legislative Branch, Military Construction and Veterans Affairs, and Extensions Act, 2026 — showing a pattern of repeated brinkmanship/shutdowns in 2025-2026, though all resolved before now. - [2026-10-09] Congress's three stated year-end options for Dec. 11 are: Enact all or most of the 12 appropriations bills through an omnibus or several minibuses. Pass another CR into early 2027. Allow funding for some agencies to lapse while completing others. - [2026-10-09] Legal analysts assess a divided/compressed lame-duck calendar makes full omnibus passage "unlikely" while a second CR is seen as a "realistic outcome," particularly under divided government outcomes from the midterms. - [2026-09-27] A forecasting outlet (The Political Group) independently estimated roughly a 1-in-4 chance of a shutdown beginning between Dec. 12–31, 2026, citing the cheapness of another short stopgap as the main reason it would likely hold, noting Congress "just passed one 370 to 48." NOT FOUND: No evidence of any funding lapse or shutdown currently in effect as of Oct 10, 2026; no OMB shutdown directive or updated OPM operating-status page specific to December 2026; no confirmed outcome of the Nov. 3, 2026 midterm elections' effect on post-election negotiating posture; no specific legislative text or vote scheduled yet for a Dec. 11/12 CR or omnibus. BOTTOM LINE: The government is currently open and funded through Dec. 11, 2026 under a CR signed Sept. 2, 2026; Congress is on pre-election recess with only 3 of 12 FY2027 appropriations bills passed by the House and none by the Senate, so the Dec. 11 deadline (one day before this market's Dec. 12 close) will force a fresh negotiation in a compressed lame-duck session, leaving real — but not dominant — shutdown risk given 2025-2026's repeated pattern of last-minute CRs and lapses.
report: base rate
- [2026-09-03] FY2027 began Oct 1, 2026 with no appropriations bills enacted; Congress instead enacted a continuing resolution (signed Sept 2, 2026) Fiscal year (FY) 2027 will begin on October 1, 2026, but so far none of the 12 appropriation bills for the year have been enacted; lawmakers enacted a CR on September 2, 2026, to provide temporary funding for federal agency operations through December 11, 2026, at FY 2026 funding levels. This is the exact deadline this Dec-12 market tracks. - [2026-10-02] Primary structural fact for the base rate: this is already the fourth funding cliff within roughly 14 months (Oct 1 2025, Jan 30 2026, Feb 14 2026/Apr 30 2026, now Dec 11 2026), reflecting an unusually volatile fiscal-conflict streak After experiencing the longest government shutdown in history at the start of FY 2026 and two subsequent partial shutdowns, Congress proactively pursued a CR to avoid the possibility of a shutdown before the midterm elections. - [2026-10-10] Historical base rate (pre-2025/26): there have been 20 "funding gaps" since Congress introduced the modern budget process in 1976, according to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, but many of those were only a few days long. Before now, only three funding lapses shut down the government for more than two weeks , meaning that historically most funding deadlines were met and most lapses that did occur were brief. - [2026-10-10] Recent base rate has shifted sharply worse: in the current Congress alone there have been three shutdowns in 12 months — the United States has shut down its government three times in the last 12 months, more funding lapses in one year than the country saw across the whole of the 1990s — including First shutdown: January 31 – February 3, 2026 (4 days) Second shutdown: February 14 – April 30, 2026 (76 days) and the record 43-day Oct 1–Nov 12, 2025 shutdown, so the "modern" reference class for this specific Congress is far more shutdown-prone than the long-run average. - [2026-09-26] Independent forecaster "The Political Group" put odds of a shutdown starting between Dec 12–31, 2026 at 24% (range 15–35%), citing that Democrats "did not extract concrete concessions" from the two 2025-26 shutdowns, lowering their incentive to trigger another, while noting the September CR passed the Senate 90-6 and House 370-48 — a sign both parties currently prefer avoiding another lapse. - [2026-09-30] Prediction-market tracking site reported Kalshi's shutdown-risk gauge had Trump signed a stopgap through December 11, 2026, as Kalshi traders tracked the collapse from 35% to 4% for the October 1 deadline, then (per the same source) pivoted to pricing December risk at roughly 24% as of early October — illustrating how quickly these markets swing as deadlines approach and recede. - [2026-10-02] A separate tracker summarized Kalshi's December 12 shutdown contract at 35% as of Oct 2, 2026, noting as of Oct 2, 2026, Kalshi prices a federal government shutdown on Dec. 12, 2026 at 35% — the stopgap signed Sept. 2 funds the government through Dec. 11, so that is the next cliff (note: this and other cited market prices are dated snapshots, not necessarily current). - [2026-08-24] An earlier aggregator (Octagon AI) compound-market analysis for "another shutdown" running through Dec 12 showed its model at 22% versus a cited market price of 11%, reflecting disagreement among quantitative forecasters about how seriously to weight the post-midterm, lame-duck dynamic Our model reads 22% — 11 pts above the market's 11%. - [2025-12-11] A separate, lower-quality aggregator ("Government Shutdown Prediction 2026") offered a generic 40-45% "expert consensus"-style baseline for any FY2026 shutdown lasting over five days, but this figure predates the current December cliff and reflects general polarization/debt-ceiling framing rather than deadline-specific analysis A survey of 30 budget experts by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget found a median probability of 40% for a shutdown ; its reliability for this specific Dec 12 event is uncertain. - [2026-09-02] Context for why Congress chose a longer CR this cycle: lawmakers "proactively" extended funding past the midterms specifically to avoid election-season shutdown risk, per PGPF Congress proactively pursued a CR to avoid the possibility of a shutdown before the midterm elections — implying the December deadline is the first one where the political "midterm insurance" rationale no longer applies, a key reason analysts flag elevated (though still minority) risk for December relative to the immediately preceding CRs. BOTTOM LINE: The long-run (1976–2024) base rate for a shutdown at any given funding deadline is low (most lapses were brief or avoided; only 3 of ~20 funding gaps before 2025 exceeded two weeks), but the current 119th Congress has broken that pattern with three shutdowns in the past 12 months, including the longest (43-day) and second-longest (76-day) shutdowns on record; independent forecasters as of late September 2026 put the December 12 shutdown probability in roughly the 15-35% range (central estimate ~22-29%), notably elevated above historical norms but still favoring "No." NOT FOUND: No official/government (OMB, CBO, or congressional) forecast or probability estimate specific to the December 12, 2026 deadline; no confirmed, non-stale current Kalshi/Polymarket price (all cited figures are dated snapshots from late Sept/early Oct 2026 and may have moved).
report: yes case
YES means: the federal government is at least partially shut down due to a lapse of appropriations as of 10:00 AM ET on Dec 12, 2026 (i.e., Congress and the President fail to enact a new CR, omnibus, or other funding law before the current CR expires at the end of Dec. 11, 2026). - [2026-09-30] The current CR leaves Congress only "four legislative weeks to prevent a post-midterm shutdown," and as of FY26's close "congressional leaders have no agreed plan to fund the government for FY27" — https://actuminsights.substack.com/p/congress-crowded-lame-duck - [2026-09-30] Republican and Democratic leadership "have not signed off on a strategy for appropriations bills in the lame duck" because the Nov. 3 midterm results are expected to reshape both parties' incentives, and there is "no progress on the negotiations for topline defense and non-defense spending levels" — https://actuminsights.substack.com/p/congress-crowded-lame-duck - [2026-09-30] A concrete sticking point for the defense topline: "billions in Iran war shortfalls and the administration's broader military buildup will make the defense topline especially difficult to resolve," with Trump separately seeking $350B via reconciliation plus $67B for Iran war costs — https://actuminsights.substack.com/p/congress-crowded-lame-duck - [2026-09-30] Even if a topline deal were reached, "the quickest appropriators can generally draft and vote on final appropriations bills is four weeks," meaning a late or post-midterm start to real negotiations could structurally outrun the Dec. 11 deadline, forcing either a rushed stopgap or a lapse — https://actuminsights.substack.com/p/congress-crowded-lame-duck - [2026-09-30] Senate appropriators are separately pushing to add language blocking the administration from unilaterally withholding (impounding) congressionally approved funds, a policy rider that has been a recurring flashpoint and a plausible trigger for a veto threat or a Democratic walkout — https://actuminsights.substack.com/p/congress-crowded-lame-duck - [2026-10-04] Senate Budget Chair Ron Johnson is "pushing for a marathon series of votes on a budget resolution in the lame-duck to unlock... a third budget reconciliation package," a competing, time-consuming floor priority that could crowd out appropriations work ahead of Dec. 11 — https://wate.com/hill-politics/senate-adjourns-until-november-with-republicans-fearful-of-losing-majority - [2026-10-04] The same report frames the Dec. 11 deadline as the trigger for "a high-stakes negotiation to avoid another government shutdown after Thanksgiving," underscoring that the compressed post-midterm calendar (Thanksgiving to Dec. 11) is the binding constraint — https://wate.com/hill-politics/senate-adjourns-until-november-with-republicans-fearful-of-losing-majority - [2026-10-10] A legal-industry analysis confirms the Dec. 11 funding deadline will collide with other year-end deadlines — including a Dec. 31 Community Health Center Fund expiration and healthcare "extenders" — making the funding bill "the principal forcing mechanism" for multiple unresolved fights, which raises the odds that a dispute on any one rider spills into a missed Dec. 11 deadline — https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2026/10/beyond-the-midterms-congress-faces-converging-year-end-deadlines - [2026-09-30] Non-funding fights competing for floor time include an Iran war-powers push and "an impeachment vote against Defense Secretary Hegseth" that Democrats and moderate Republicans intend to force, which could further poison the well for bipartisan appropriations cooperation in the same window — https://actuminsights.substack.com/p/congress-crowded-lame-duck - [Context, 2025-2026 pattern] This Congress has already allowed three separate funding lapses in the prior 12 months (the 43-day Oct–Nov 2025 shutdown and two shutdowns in Jan–Apr 2026), establishing a demonstrated willingness by both parties to let deadlines lapse rather than cave on policy disputes — a directly relevant precedent for the Dec. 11/12 cliff that the "No" case must overcome. BOTTOM LINE: The strongest YES path is a straightforward mechanical one: a genuinely crowded, midterm-disrupted lame-duck session with unresolved defense-topline, Iran-funding, impoundment-rider, and reconciliation fights consuming floor time, such that Congress simply runs out of days to pass even a new stopgap before the Dec. 11 CR lapses — a scenario made more plausible by this Congress's demonstrated pattern of three prior lapses in 12 months. NOT FOUND: No evidence yet of actual stalled negotiations, veto threats, or a specific bill text for the December 2026 CR/omnibus; no confirmation of midterm results (Nov. 3) or their effect on each party's bargaining posture; no OMB shutdown-planning directive or updated contingency guidance specific to December 2026.
report: no case
YES means: the US federal government is at least partially shut down due to a lapse in federal appropriations — i.e., OMB has issued a shutdown directive and/or OPM's operating status shows agencies operating under a lapse — in effect at 10:00 AM ET on December 12, 2026. - [2026-09-26] The Political Group's dedicated Dec-12 forecast, the most recent deadline-specific model found, puts the probability of a shutdown starting Dec. 12–31 at 24% (range 15-35%), arguing "Democrats did not extract concrete concessions" from the two record shutdowns this Congress, which "lowers the chance they start one in December." https://www.thepoliticalgroup.com/forecasts/will-the-government-shut-down-in-december-2026 - [2026-09-26] The same analysis flags that Appropriations leadership is already signaling a punt rather than confrontation: "The chairman is pre-positioning for another stopgap rather than promising an omnibus. That is the language of a punt, which is the NO outcome." https://www.thepoliticalgroup.com/forecasts/will-the-government-shut-down-in-december-2026 - [2026-09-26] TPG's statistical base rate is explicitly built from the lame-duck reference class: "Start from the lame-duck base rate of about 15 percent (2 of 13 since 1980)." — well under 50%, before adjusting upward for this Congress's volatility. https://www.thepoliticalgroup.com/forecasts/will-the-government-shut-down-in-december-2026 - [2026-10-08] A fresh (2-day-old) Hill report on the House Freedom Caucus's post-midterm posture confirms the "no shutdown, just no omnibus" dynamic: a member said the caucus wants to make sure there isn't "some sort of massive Christmas omnibus" and that it could exert influence "including by preventing the movement of any omnibus spending package" — i.e., the conservative flank's stated goal is blocking a big bill, not provoking a lapse, which points toward another "clean" CR as the likely off-ramp. https://thehill.com/homenews/house/6132803-house-freedom-caucus-leadership-shakeup/ - [2026-09-30] Fox News reported Senate Majority Leader Thune's read on why Democrats folded on the September CR: he said Democrats appeared to calculate that a shutdown fight would create "uncertainty that perhaps didn't help their chances" heading into the midterms — a blame-avoidance logic that, while weaker after Nov. 3, still signals neither party has shown appetite to engineer a lapse this cycle. https://www.foxnews.com/politics/schumer-caves-hands-republicans-shutdown-win-months-uncertainty - [2026-09-03] Both chambers have already shown supermajority willingness to simply extend funding rather than fight: the CR passed the Senate 90-6 and the House 370-48, a far wider bipartisan margin than any 2025-26 shutdown-era CR vote, suggesting the path of least resistance (another short CR) remains cheap and available in December. https://ofr.harvard.edu/news/2026/09/congress-extends-government-funding-through-december-11 - [2026-09-03] Contrary to the narrative of total gridlock, the House Appropriations Committee had already "advanced all 12 of its FY27 draft funding bills" by early September, meaning House-side groundwork for a minibus/omnibus fallback is further along than the floor-vote count alone suggests; the Senate's holdup is specifically over the defense topline, a narrower, negotiable dispute rather than total disagreement. https://ofr.harvard.edu/news/2026/09/congress-extends-government-funding-through-december-11 - [2026-10-02] An appropriations-focused law-firm tracker frames the Senate's stall as a single quantifiable dispute — "If Republicans emerge from the midterms intent on pursuing another reconciliation package, congressional leaders will have to balance that effort against a December 11 government-funding deadline" — implying the main risk is a reconciliation side-fight rather than a breakdown over base appropriations, a narrower and more containable source of friction than a full-spectrum shutdown fight. https://www.akingump.com/en/insights/blogs/the-approps-drop/omb-reaches-for-congresss-purse-strings-but-december-is-coming - [2026-10-09] Holland & Knight's year-end outlook explicitly lists "another continuing resolution" as one of only three plausible outcomes alongside omnibus/minibus or a partial lapse, and frames a full-year omnibus as the hardest of the three to achieve in a compressed calendar — leaving a CR (a NO outcome) as a structurally favored fallback precisely because it requires the least new negotiation. https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2026/10/beyond-the-midterms-congress-faces-converging-year-end-deadlines - [Resolution-text technicality] The market's own rules state that "a technical lapse in appropriations occurs, but OMB directs agencies to continue standard operations" type scenarios would NOT resolve Yes; combined with the one-day gap between the Dec. 11 CR expiration and the Dec. 12, 10 AM ET market close, even a brief Dec. 11–12 lapse that Congress clears before OMB issues a formal "orderly shutdown" directive, or before OPM updates its operating-status page, would not satisfy the Yes criteria. BOTTOM LINE: Every dedicated, deadline-specific forecast found (TPG's 24%, central lame-duck base rates near 15%) keeps the probability of an actual Dec. 12 lapse a minority outcome, and the mechanics so far — wide bipartisan CR votes, a House Appropriations Committee that has already cleared all 12 bills, a Senate dispute narrowly focused on the defense topline, and Freedom Caucus messaging aimed at blocking an omnibus rather than provoking a shutdown — all point toward another stopgap CR (a NO outcome) as the modal resolution, with the question's own technical-lapse carve-out further widening the margin for NO even if talks run past Dec. 11. NOT FOUND: No post-midterm (Nov. 3+) statements from Johnson, Thune, Jeffries, or Schumer on December strategy (election hasn't happened yet); no confirmed text or whip count for any December CR/omnibus; no OMB or OPM contingency guidance specific to December 2026; no non-stale current Kalshi/Polymarket price.
3. Forecasters 5 draws · Opus 5.5 + GPT-6 Astra + GPT-5.6 Sol · plain mean
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
50% conf
Yes 25%
No 75%
(0) The condition is not met and cannot yet be met. The government is funded through Dec 11, 2026 under H.R. 6500, signed Sept 2 (Holland & Knight, Oct 9). The resolution-source fetch returned no shutdown status. (a) There are about 2 months left. The binding window is the compressed lame-duck session between the Nov 3 midterms and the Dec 11 CR expiration. Dec 12, 10 AM ET falls on a Saturday, the morning after the lapse would begin. (b) If nothing changes, funding lapses at midnight, so Congress must act. The cheapest action, another stopgap, passed 90-6 and 370-48 just weeks ago, and the Appropriations chair is reportedly pre-positioning for another punt. (c) NO: post-election, leaders pass a short CR into early 2027. The Freedom Caucus aims only to block an omnibus, and whichever party wins the House may prefer to punt into the new Congress. (d) YES: unresolved fights consume the few legislative weeks and the CR lapses Friday night, triggering an OMB shutdown directive. These include the defense topline and Iran war costs, impoundment riders, a reconciliation push and a Hegseth impeachment vote. This Congress has lapsed three times in 12 months, so that is credible. The Kalshi anchor is 30% and drifting down. Independent forecasts sit around 24% (TPG), and the lame-duck base rate is about 15%. I shade slightly below the market to about 25%, keeping meaningful weight on this Congress's demonstrated brinkmanship.
claude-opus-5-5 · high effort
50% conf
Yes 23%
No 77%
(0) Not resolved. Every source (Holland & Knight on Oct 9, trackers on Oct 3) shows the government open and funded through Dec 11, 2026 under H.R. 6500, signed Sept 2. Yes requires Congress to fail to pass any new CR or omnibus before the CR expires at the end of Friday, Dec 11. OMB would then have to have ordered an orderly shutdown in effect at 10 AM ET on Saturday, Dec 12. (a) About two months remain, but the working window is a compressed lame-duck session from mid-November to Dec 11. (b) If nothing changes, the CR expires one day before the check, so the real question is whether Congress punts again. (c) NO: after the midterms, leaders pass another short CR into early 2027. That path is cheap; the last CR passed 90-6 and 370-48, the appropriations chair is already 'pre-positioning' for a stopgap, and the Freedom Caucus aims to block an omnibus rather than force a lapse. Polymarket combo markets imply roughly a 91% chance Democrats win the House, which gives Democrats every reason to punt into a Congress where they have more leverage, not to shut down now. (d) YES: defense topline and Iran-cost fights, impoundment riders and a reconciliation push eat the calendar, or Trump or House conservatives reject a clean CR. This Congress has had three lapses in 12 months, so a weekend lapse beginning Saturday Dec 12 is plausible. The Kalshi anchor is 30% (bid 30/ask 33) and has fallen 16 points in 30 days. The deadline-specific forecast from The Political Group (24%) and the lame-duck base rate of about 15% sit below it. Given the expected divided-government dynamic, I shade slightly under the market, to 23%.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
64% conf
Yes 30%
No 70%
The condition is neither already met nor impossible: the test is at 10:00 AM ET on December 12, 2026, approximately 63 days away. The official OPM fetch returned only a loading placeholder and OMB only generic content, while Harvard's September 3 report and Holland & Knight's October 9 analysis corroborate funding through December 11. Thus the government is reported open now, but if Congress does nothing, existing funding expires before the observation time rather than extending today's open status indefinitely. A NO scenario is another bipartisan continuing resolution, supported by September's 90–6 Senate and 370–48 House votes and the October 9 assessment that another stopgap is realistic. A YES scenario is post-midterm bargaining over defense spending and policy riders blocking even a stopgap, resulting in an actual partial shutdown still effective at the specified observation time. The reported three recent shutdowns warrant substantial risk, but unfinished full-year appropriations do not prevent a short extension, and the outside 24% forecast concerns a different December window. My estimate allows for NO following a technical lapse with OMB-directed normal operations and for uncertainty over timely official documentation; an unavailable OPM update alone does not establish either outcome, and an effective OMB shutdown directive can establish YES. I retain Kalshi's current 30% YES anchor (30% bid/33% ask), because the research supplies no clearly unpriced information justifying a departure, and the compound Polymarket contracts are not independent prices for this exact question.
gpt-6-astra · high effort
63% conf
Yes 30%
No 70%
The outcome is neither already met nor impossible: the official OPM fetch returned only “Loading,” and the OMB landing page contained no operative shutdown directive, so neither establishes the required future status. There are 63 days until December 12 at 10:00 AM ET; Congress.gov records H.R. 6500 becoming law September 2, while Harvard’s September 3 report and Holland & Knight’s October 9 analysis corroborate funding through December 11. If no further funding legislation passes, appropriations expire before the observation time, creating a path toward Yes rather than preserving today’s reported funded status, although an actual suspension of non-excepted work must occur. I retain Kalshi’s live 30% Yes anchor (30% bid/33% ask), because the research provides no clear informational advantage warranting a departure, and the Polymarket election-and-shutdown conjunctions are not equivalent contracts. The principal No scenario is another stopgap, supported by the previous CR’s 90–6 Senate and 370–48 House votes and Holland & Knight’s assessment that another CR is a realistic fallback when an omnibus is difficult. The Yes scenario is that unresolved spending levels or policy riders derail even a stopgap during the compressed post-midterm session, producing an agency shutdown still effective at the observation time; the reported repeated 2025–26 shutdowns make this a substantial risk. Crucially, the cutoff is only ten hours after funding expires, so a technical lapse with OMB directing normal operations remains No, and I price qualifying operating-status risk rather than treating every missed deadline as Yes or the unavailable OPM read as proof of normal operations. Confidence is moderate because the funding cliff is corroborated, but December bill text, whip counts, post-election bargaining positions, and usable official operating-status evidence remain unavailable, while several detailed political claims rest on individual reports.
gpt-5.6-sol · high effort
66% conf
Yes 29%
No 71%
(0) The condition is not already met: the resolution-source fetch found no OMB shutdown directive or usable OPM shutdown status, while the Oct. 9 Holland & Knight analysis says the government is open and funded through Dec. 11; Yes still requires an operational appropriations shutdown to be in effect at 10:00 AM ET on Dec. 12. (a) About 63 days remain until that deadline, including the Nov. 3 midterms and a compressed lame-duck session. (b) If funding law remains unchanged, the current CR expires after Dec. 11, creating a lapse risk, although a merely technical lapse without suspended operations would still resolve No. (c) The clearest No scenario is another short CR, supported by the prior CR's overwhelming 90-6 Senate and 370-48 House votes and by lawmakers' apparent preference to punt rather than pass a Christmas omnibus. (d) The Yes scenario is that unresolved defense, impoundment, healthcare, and reconciliation disputes consume the short lame-duck calendar, no stopgap passes, and OMB orders at least some agencies to execute shutdown plans by the specified time. Kalshi's live Yes price is 30% with a 30%-33% spread, which is the primary anchor and already reflects this Congress's unusually shutdown-prone record. I price Yes slightly below that anchor because the dedicated outside forecast was 24%, another CR is procedurally cheap, and the market's technical-lapse carve-out provides an additional route to No, while keeping substantial Yes probability because this Congress has already allowed three shutdowns in roughly a year.
4. Final plain mean of 5 draws
27% (59% confidence)
Yes: 27% No: 73%
Mean of 5 draws (0.25, 0.23, 0.30, 0.30, 0.29). (0) The condition is not met and cannot yet be met. The government is funded through Dec 11, 2026 under H.R. 6500, signed Sept 2 (Holland & Knight, Oct 9). The resolution-source fetch returned no shutdown status. (a) There are about 2 months left. The binding window is the compressed lame-duck session between the Nov 3 midterms and the Dec 11 CR expiration. Dec 12, 10 AM ET falls on a Saturday, the morning after the lapse would begin. (b) If nothing changes, funding lapses at midnight, so Congress must act. The cheapest action, another stopgap, passed 90-6 and 370-48 just weeks ago, and the Appropriations chair is reportedly pre-positioning for another punt. (c) NO: post-election, leaders pass a short CR into early 2027. The Freedom Caucus aims only to block an omnibus, and whichever party wins the House may prefer to punt into the new Congress. (d) YES: unresolved fights consume the few legislative weeks and the CR lapses Friday night, triggering an OMB shutdown directive. These include the defense topline and Iran war costs, impoundment riders, a reconciliation push and a Hegseth impeachment vote. This Congress has lapsed three times in 12 months, so that is credible. The Kalshi anchor is 30% and drifting down. Independent forecasts sit around 24% (TPG), and the lame-duck base rate is about 15%. I shade slightly below the market to about 25%, keeping meaningful weight on this Congress's demonstrated brinkmanship.
5. Entry Decision Opus 5.5 trader
Side
no
Position Size
$500
Contracts
714
Trader Confidence
59%
Trade rationale
The market prices a December 12 shutdown at 32% and the forecast is 27.4%, so this NO trade sides with the favourite (NO is about 68%). That's the book's profitable type, at 27/5 closed. All 5 forecasts in the ensemble land below the market (23-30%), and confidence is a middling 0.59. The rationale gives concrete reasons rather than just caution. The current stopgap (continuing resolution, or CR) passed 90-6 and 370-48 only weeks ago. The Appropriations chair is reportedly lining up another short extension. An independent forecast (TPG) sits near 24%, and the market is already drifting down. Against that, this Congress has let funding lapse three times in 12 months, and there are several open fights (defense topline, impoundment riders, Iran costs), which keeps meaningful risk on YES. The book holds no other shutdown or funding positions and this market has no prior scans, so there's no stacking.
Allocation logic
The edge is 4.6pp at the mid, but buying NO at the $0.70 ask cuts it to about 3pp after the 3-cent spread. That's a thin same-side edge, so I'm sizing at the $500 floor, as the guidance says for small with-favourite trades with a concrete reason.
Entry price: $0.70
Current: $0.67
Status: OPEN
P&L: -$31.94
Pipeline Timing
Total pipeline time: 121.1s
Per-tool research timings shown in the Research section above.